10 ms·
Obama on Climate Change: The Trends Are ‘Terrifying’
- jobu 10y agoBased on the title I was hoping for more actual data about the trends, but this is mostly a political puff piece about Obama's efforts toward reducing greenhouse gas emissions.
- legolas2412 10y agoAnd yet US produces 66% electricity from fossil fuels. And yet US would sue India in WTO over local sourcing of solar panels. It's all business to the american politicians and companies. All the green talk is to keep the voters happy.
- Analemma_ 10y agoWhat's really terrifying to me is all the positive feedback loops inherent to warming. Melting permafrost in tundra regions like Alaska releases methane: more warming. Less snow/ice coverage reflects less sunlight: more warming. Desertification and dying rainforests mean less CO2 absorbption: more warming. Warmer air temperatures mean the atmosphere can hold more water vapor, which traps longwave radiation: more warming. Some of these haven't even hit the hockey stick portion yet. Between that, the "time delay" between atmospheric CO2 and climate (i.e., that we're probably seeing the climate effects corresponding to the CO2 levels of many years ago), and 2016 breaking temperature records every month so far, it's hard not to conclude that we're fucked and it's way too late. Sigh.
- adwf 10y agoYep, that's why it's so scary. By the time the effects have become so obvious that even the strongest deniers realise something must be done... that's too late. And it's not just about temperature. It's about the socio-political effects of climate change. How many people realise that a large part of the Syrian conflict is actually down to crop failures? Migration from country -> town led to big social conflicts, which massively contributed to the eventual military conflict.
- shams93 10y agoA lot of the conflict you see in the middle east has more to do with crop failure and water shortages than oil. Yemen fell into chaos over acute water shortages.
- friendlygrammar 10y ago>Melting permafrost in tundra regions like Alaska releases methane: more warming If it makes you feel any better, the methane disperses in about 12 years. So a bunch of animals will become extinct and then 12 years later everything will go back to normal! Yeah it doesn't make me feel good either.
- dv_dt 10y agoI don't think that's a great model, in 12 years, lot's of the biosphere could die off, generating more methane in decay.
- astrodust 10y agoThat could be twelve years of utterly apocalyptic weather we might not survive. Just saying. Nobody knows how bad that could get, but do you think we could survive over a decade where the outdoor temperature is, on average, 200°F? One of those animals could be the human species, or at least our idea of what that represents.
- zaroth 10y agoWhat is this nonsense? The worst case models predict a 10-20 degree increase by 2100.
- flukus 10y agoThe models don't rely on the silly assumption that all the permafrost would melt and release it's methane instantly.
- astrodust 10y agoA) That's 10-20°C, not °F. We're already seeing temperatures of 120°F (49°C) in parts of the world, so another +20°C puts that at 156°F (69°C). I'm not exaggerating all that much. B) The projections keep getting more pessimistic as more data is accumulated. C) We're talking about the theoretical worst-case scenario where everything spirals completely out of control and Venus starts to look like a temperate climate.
- astrodust 10y agoThere's also positive feedback loops when it comes to opposition of the very idea that the warming exists. When one politician pushes the idea hard, when people show interest in it, there's an incentive for other politicians to double down on their positions or push even farther to more extreme levels of denial. Plus, voters who strongly identify with a party that promotes that platform may find themselves pulled along, wanting to be in line with the party's politics, and in so doing skew things even further.
- dharma1 10y agoHere is a really great, in-depth article of analysing the effects of methane, and tracking it from space. It's not looking good. Humans are not great with stuff they can't see or that spans over decades. http://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/Features/MethaneMatters/ http://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/Features/MethaneMatters/
- spodek 10y agoWhat's terrifying is that people don't connect their behavior to global warming and spew the most ignorant garbage justifying their airplane flights and so on, including the most knowledgeable people. We can't stop what's happening now, but as sure as we wish past generations had reduced polluting, future generations will wish we had. But almost no one does. How many people do you know haven't flown in the past twelve months versus how many have? Everybody cares about the environment until they want to see the Eiffel Tower.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mikeash 10y agoIndividual actions don't make any noticeable difference. Climate change won't be affected if I fly to Europe next month versus staying home. It's a massive collective action problem, and collective action is hard. Individuals changing their habits won't do anything to help.
- jacquesm 10y agoThat's the biggest cop-out ever. Of course 'individual actions don't make any noticeable difference'. But every collective action is ultimately enacted by lots of individual actors the sum of whose actions is making a noticeable difference. The bigger problem is that there are so many people in the pay of those who'd rather watch the world burn that the short term interests are going to win out or have at least significant enough effects that in the longer term we're going to be paying a very hefty price indeed. Individuals changing their habits will do plenty, if enough individuals are involved. It's a sales and marketing job. If you can get 100's of millions of people to download a stupid game then you probably could get 100's of millions of people to think about whether or not they really need to make that trip, about whether or not they need a new car or not and whether or not they really need to have the AC running 24/7, and to vote for parties that have an eye out for the environment (never mind that in a two party system that's a pipe dream but in countries with coalition governments those parties do tend to get into positions of relative power and the changes they cause are large enough to matter).
- strommen 10y agoIf it makes you feel better, melting permafrost is currently a small portion of overall global methane emissions. There's a potential for a massive release of gas, but it isn't happening yet.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ralusek 10y agoClimate change is one of the most interesting issues in politics because of how pure and overt the motivations of the opposition are. It's so hilarious to me that you can have a politician with major donations from Coal/Fossil Fuels try to legitimately discredit a trend that 98% of the scientists in this field have agreed is proven by data. I also can't think of another issue where 98% of experts in a field have empirically demonstrated with data that trends are occurring, yet we're still allowed to just "believe" or "not believe" in its occurrence.
- mikeash 10y agoIt's also interesting because of how important it is. If people didn't believe the Earth was round or that smoking causes cancer, it would be sad and ridiculous but it wouldn't have a huge impact. Lots more lung cancer and heart disease deaths for the second one, but life goes on. But this is one of the few issues where convincing people it's real makes a huge difference for our civilization. It's crazy (but perhaps also expected) that it's also one of the few issues where the scientific conclusion is simply not accepted by so many.
- curiousgeorgio 10y ago> this is one of the few issues where convincing people it's real makes a huge difference for our civilization Without arguing over the validity of AGW here, is there really any evidence that we could make a "huge difference" as you claim? Apart from using technology to deal with extreme climate conditions, is there anything demonstrably within the realm of human possibility that could significantly delay or reverse such climate change?
- mikeash 10y agoIt's too late to stop it, but greatly cutting CO2 emissions will make the damage much less severe. Climate change isn't a binary proposition, where we either get it or we don't. We're pretty much locked in to some degree of change at this point, but how much change we get still depends on how much more CO2 we dump into the atmosphere.
- sqeaky 10y agoThis is gonna get me totally downvoted, but... What if I said I was pro-global warming.... I am buying property that will be at or around beach level when all the ice melts. In the mean time just a couple of houses and I rent them out reasonably. But in time when all the snow stops and the climate here is subtropical the warm waters of the bay of Texas will lap onto the shores of what are hills today. And the property will have increase many-fold. These properties will have been netting me and my family money the entire time. /what if I have not actually done that, but not shoveling would be nice.
- mikeash 10y agoThe problem with that is the high value of beachfront property is based on having a civilization with a great deal of consumer surplus, where a large number of people can afford to take time off to go to the beach for vacation. The worry for climate change isn't just that it'll displace people, but that it'll severely disrupt civilization due to massive refugee problems and agricultural failures. By the time the seashore reaches your inland property, people may be too busy trying to survive to care about beach vacations, or you may have lost your property and/or life in the turmoil.
- pavlov 10y agoIt's kind of like stocking up on sunscreen and iodine pills in the hope of selling them for a tidy profit after a nuclear holocaust.
- sqeaky 10y agowhat if... I think total societal collapse is unlikely, these events will not happen in a vacuum and will take a hundred years or more to fully play out. Governments and peoples coalitions will resist, make attempts to fix and generally resist total anarchy. If owning land becomes unstable then the general notion of owning wealth is impractical. Leaving property, and well stocked proptery, so that my descendants can convert it to whatever is required still leaves me better off than not saving. /what if
- the8472 10y ago
- rdoherty 10y agoAside from companies working on electric cars and solar projects, who else is working on large-scale projects to ameliorate climate change? Any truly massive projects akin to putting a man on the moon?
- lukifer 10y agoI can't speak to what is actually being done but here's an interesting and quasi-comprehensive write-up of what engineers, developers and designers have to offer in the climate change fight: http://worrydream.com/ClimateChange http://worrydream.com/ClimateChange
- rosege 10y agoBill Gates is trying to fund some of the research that might lead to break through technologies
- jfaucett 10y agoFor anyone interested in this topic I would recommend reading "The moral case for fossil fuels". It gives a big picture look of this problem in the context of human flourishing. As someone who had only ever been exposed to the gloom and doom predictions like this article it was a refreashingly clearly thought and precisely structured counter argument.
- Analemma_ 10y agoI looked up that book's author, it's a guy named Alex Epstein. Who is he? > Alex Epstein is an American author, energy theorist and industrial policy pundit. He is the founder and President of the Center for Industrial Progress, a for-profit think tank located in Laguna Hills, California, and a former fellow of the Ayn Rand Institute. Sounds like a reliable source to me!
- kafkaesq 10y agoAll those so-called researchers in academia just have an axe to grind. Think tanks are definitely what you should bank on, intellectually. Especially the for-profit ones.
- lossolo 10y agoReading things like this [1] every couple of days it seems we are standing on the train tracks hearing the train is coming but we choose to cover our ears instead of stopping the train. There will come a time and we will need to pay the price for covering the ears, we just postpone it but train is coming closer and closer every day. Soon we will feel vibrations on the tracks but then I am afraid it will be already too late to stop the train. [1] http://phys.org/news/2016-09-unprecedented-atmospheric-behavior-disrupts-earth.html http://phys.org/news/2016-09-unprecedented-atmospheric-behav...
- fckyrdumb 10y agoMost modeling suggestions paradoxically that there will be more arable land as vast swathes in Canada warm, and already crops are being planted further north. There is certainly plenty of political denialism of global climate change, and some of it comes from government distrust . Sadly most governments use climate change as an excuse for more power and abuse. Also economicly no one knows if it's cheaper to spend wealth now to avoid the worst results or wait and spend wealth later to mitigate the worst consequences. Wealth isn't infinite, and funds spent on climate change is money not spent on combating malaria or researching new antibiotics etc.
- lifeisstillgood 10y agoThe link to http://worrydream.com/ClimateChange/ http://worrydream.com/ClimateChange/ below was good and lead me to think what are the basic philosophical underpinnings of, well, an HN point of view? Equality Externalities Empiricism A good start?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- haberman 10y agoI sometimes wish descriptions of climate change would include one or two potential positive benefits, no matter how small. This would give me more faith that the discourse coming from climate scientists is entirely objective and descriptive. Even if we accept that climate change is overwhelmingly negative for human life on the whole (which I do), I still find it hard to believe that there aren't one or two minor effects that could actually be beneficial. Much of the left seems to view climate change as a crime that humans commit against nature. This view seems as morally blind to me as the right's view that God gave humankind the Earth to have dominion over. The objective view is that the activities of humans are changing the climate, and the effects are X, Y, and Z. Changing the climate is not wrong because it makes an anthropomorphized Mother Nature shed a tear, but because X, Y, and Z are harmful to animal and plant life, including us humans. Unfortunately if I get what I want (an objective account that includes possible upsides of climate change), climate change deniers might seize on that as an excuse to do nothing.
- eli_gottlieb 10y ago>Much of the left seems to view climate change as a crime that humans commit against nature. This view seems as morally blind to me as the right's view that God gave humankind the Earth to have dominion over. The objective view is that the activities of humans are changing the climate, and the effects are X, Y, and Z. Changing the climate is not wrong because it makes an anthropomorphized Mother Nature shed a tear, but because X, Y, and Z are harmful to animal and plant life, including us humans. As a leftist, I want climate change addressed because fully automated luxury communism is going to require a technological base, of the kind we can't create or maintain if the ecosystem collapses out from under us, the fossil fuels run out, we can no longer run what we need without downgrading to human and animal labor, and a mass extinction occurs while everyone's working a lot harder.
- haberman 10y agoWhat you say isn't the same as my admittedly extreme "Mother Nature sheds a tear." But a phrase like "the ecosystem collapses out from under us" implies that climate change is a total and unambiguous attack on "the ecosystem." This is the assumption that I often feel is inadequately justified. For example, CO2 is used for photosynthesis in plants. This Nature article concludes: > Under elevated CO2 most plant species show higher rates of photosynthesis, increased growth, decreased water use and lowered tissue concentrations of nitrogen and protein. Rising CO2 over the next century is likely to affect both agricultural production and food quality. The effects of elevated CO2 are not uniform; some species, particularly those that utilize the C4 variant of photosynthesis, show less of a response to elevated CO2 than do other types of plants. Rising CO2 is therefore likely to have complex effects on the growth and composition of natural plant communities. http://www.nature.com/scitable/knowledge/library/effects-of-rising-atmospheric-concentrations-of-carbon-13254108 http://www.nature.com/scitable/knowledge/library/effects-of-... When articles and arguments acknowledge both positive and negative effects of something, I trust them more.