3 ms·
Jerry Weinberg told a story about how IBM used to send him around to their most expensive projects. He would report back about which ones deserved further inves
by gruseom 19y ago
Jerry Weinberg told a story about how IBM used to send him around to their most expensive projects. He would report back about which ones deserved further investment and which were hopeless and should be killed. Usually they took his advice, but there was one he couldn't get them to kill no matter how hard he tried. This was a project to create an "automatic debugging machine". The executives were too enthralled by the diagram the people on the project had drawn for them: a box with an arrow going into it saying program with bugs and an arrow coming out the other side saying program without bugs. (At this point he was met with incredulous laughter and insisted it was true.) Although they had sunk millions of dollars into this with nothing to show, the executives had been so burnt by programs with bugs that they refused to give up the idea.
At long last, Weinberg said, he finally came up with the argument that got the project killed. It went like this. "Say you have an automatic debugging machine. I could feed it a blank sheet of paper, and out would come the program I wanted. So you'd have to have a mind-reader in there!"
- mattmaroon 19y agoHa, yeah, what kind of moron would try to build a debugging machine? Any idiot can see that it should be a software program. I'll list that on elance too.