5 ms·
If you have personal preferences about whom you conduct business with, you shouldn't be allowed to conduct business with anyone. This isn't about your home; th
by eropple 10y ago
If you have personal preferences about whom you conduct business with, you shouldn't be allowed to conduct business with anyone.
This isn't about your home; this is about your use of your home as a capital asset. You can allow into your home anyone you choose to and bar anyone you choose to. But as a society we have agreed that we--through our government--most certainly have a stake in making sure that you treat others equitably in your business transactions, and that that use of your home as a capital asset in a business transaction means you forego other rights in the process.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- wyager 10y ago>If you have personal preferences about whom you conduct business with, you shouldn't be allowed to conduct business with anyone. Let's go for the obvious example; Jewish business owners should be forced to do business with neo-nazis?
- tptacek 10y agoNazism isn't a protected class. But Jewish business owners routinely do business with them anyways.
- Unklejoe 10y agoWhat determines if something is a protected class?
- tptacek 10y agoFederal law.
- eropple 10y agoBeing denoted as such in federal law. The original Civil Rights Act, in 1964, specified race, color, sex, religion, and national origin; since then a few classes (pregnancy/marital status, age, citizenship, etc.) have been added over time.
- Unklejoe 10y agoI see. I honestly didn't know much about the specifics of protected classes before today. So, currently, political affiliation is not a protected class, but it is considered a gray area by many. Many may feel that political affiliation should be considered a protected class, however, if it becomes one, would that mean that Nazism is now protected? Or coming at it from the other angle, as it stands, a religious extremist who believes that all members of a particular race/religion/orientation/etc should be put to death is currently protected. Why is that protected but Nazism not? Or does the protection become void as soon as you use it negatively towards another protected class? I'm genuinely asking. Even though Nazism isn’t technically a religion, it seems very similar to religious extremism in many ways.
- tptacek 10y agoNazism is in many ways protected. Cities cannot deny permits to neo-Nazi groups to assemble, for instance. The comparison between Nazism and discrimination against black people is pretty creepy, though. The experience of black people on Airbnb is: "Here is an amazing looking listing. I'm psyched to see if it's available for my trip. Click. Oh! It is available! How excellent. I'll plan accordingly." Then, a few hours later, when the owner has noticed the applicant's African American sounding name, the reservation is rescinded. It happens repeatedly, and there's nothing the renter can do about it. The experience of the neo-Nazi is roughly the same, except the first time it happens they take the swastika out of their profile picture and from then on everything works peachy for them.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> Nazism is in many ways protected. Cities cannot deny permits to neo-Nazi groups to assemble, for instance. That's not being a protected class (which is a statutory issue), or even being a Con-law suspect or quasi-suspect class, that's simply application of the 1st Amendment (incorporated by the 14th). Its a whole different, unrelated area of protection. > The experience of the neo-Nazi is roughly the same, except the first time it happens they take the swastika out of their profile picture and from then on everything works peachy for them. Which pretty much also works for many victims of religious discrimination, but even so religion is (and political affiliation, Nazi or otherwise, is not) a protected class under fair housing law. So, insofar as its a difference between "Nazis" and "blacks", its a difference largely orthogonal to the issue of protected class status under fair housing laws.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Unklejoe 10y ago[If you have personal preferences about whom you conduct business with, you shouldn't be allowed to conduct business with anyone.] Why? If someone chooses to discriminate, why not let them suffer the consequences of lost potential revenue naturally? It gives people who don't discriminate a chance to step in and gain market share. It reminds me of the story of the bakery who wouldn't make a wedding cake for a gay couple. If I owned a bakery, I would put up a sign the next day saying "we will happily make cakes for gay couples".
- tptacek 10y agoBecause we tried that and it didn't work. It wasn't a single decision that resulted in redlining that forced all the black people in cities to under-served slums. It was an aggregation of millions of personal decisions, many of them by otherwise reasonable people who were simply responding to the very powerful human cognitive bias of loss aversion. So, as a society, we decided to do what can to foreclose on that pathology.
- arielb1 10y agoWhy loss aversion? People don't want a black person in their home because they believe that black people are more likely to mess up their home than white people. They would rather not rent out their home at all.
- tptacek 10y agoYes, that is what loss aversion means.
- im4w1l 10y agoAre you saying that if black people live in one society and white people live in one society, then the black one will necessarily be hundreds times worse than the white one? Because that's what it sounds like you are saying.
- eropple 10y ago