5 ms·
> Companies, the authors write, “are unwilling or unable to solve their skill challenges through internal training, even for skills that are highly specific to
by theandrewbailey 10y ago
> Companies, the authors write, “are unwilling or unable to solve their skill challenges through internal training, even for skills that are highly specific to a particular plant.”
That's true for all companies. They don't want to spend the money to train, since employees can (and often do) leave after just a few years (if not months), but are also unwilling to make the workplace a more desirable one.
- Bahamut 10y agoIt's pretty sad, as the solution is staring at them in the face. These are the companies who refuse to adapt.
- collyw 10y agoSounds just like the IT industry.
- lj3 10y agoIt's not that simple. The economic situation on the ground is that anybody making less than $70k a year is better off on welfare. Factory workers make less than half that. Who would willingly train to do a hard, monotonous job when they could sit on the couch doing nothing and get paid more?
- rubidium 10y agoReality check (no idea where you live... but your blithe statement reveals some serious lack of understanding of the situation of most people in the US): The U.S. Census Bureau reported in September 2014 that U.S. real (inflation adjusted) median household income was $51,939. Making $50k a year is WAAAAAAAAAAAAAY better than being on welfare.
- mcguire 10y ago"...median household income..." That's also very likely two paychecks.
- theandrewbailey 10y agoThere are many places in the US where making $35,000/year would make you rich, or at least well-off and comfortable. Many of them don't want to live in metropolitan areas and are completely happy.
- rubidium 10y agoAs a single person, yes you can live very comfortably on 35k a year (I wouldn't quite go so far as "rich"). Raising a family, not so much.
- maxxxxx 10y agoI remember in the 90s you could walk into into an interview and they would say "You are a smart guy, you'll learn it". I got a C++ job based on the fact that I was really good with PL/1 and FORTRAN. No way you could do this today. People wouldn't switch jobs that much if they actually saw a path forward inside the company. Just give them a some raises and actually reward seniority. From my managers I sometimes get the sense that anybody who has worked under them for a few years is spoiled goods and needs to be replaced with fresh outside blood.
- ryandrake 10y agoI got my first job out of undergrad programming device drivers, having never programmed a single device driver before in my life. I skimmed whatever the 90's version of "Device Driver Programming for Dummies" was, on the flight to the interview. That scenario must seem ludicrous to job applicants today. Today, unless I had 5 years experience programming device drivers and could traverse a binary tree on a whiteboard, I wouldn't have the slightest chance at such an entry level programming job.
- eli_gottlieb 10y agoI got a job that involves writing device drivers just last year. Our firm's only technical interview question involves time-space tradeoffs in embedded systems. Meh.
- gregpilling 10y agoit is not true for all companies. It doesn't take much thinking to realize that if you are a business owner, running a factory, and your competitors factory doesn't train then you would have an advantage by training. We do lots of training, because nobody has the skills for our exact setup. I have paid for plenty of training that walked out the door into a new job 6 months later. Life goes on. I look for high intelligence people, and then train them in house. High intelligence people can get trained in a fraction of the time, and not every high intelligence person went to college to become a programmer. I think the skills gap could be more about the draining of intelligent people from blue collar jobs. I went to high school in the 80's and there was a very strong push for "college/computers good, working with hands bad" message from the guidance counselors. I have a person who just graduated from University with good grades in Psychology and English. She applied for 87 jobs from March to July with no luck; now she is one of the robot operators. She says she makes more money doing this than any job she could get with her degree. Perhaps some of the skills challenge is too many white collar path people, not wanting to go to manufacturing for any reason. (my good worker is heading to grad school in a few months though, sad for me).
- r_smart 10y agoThis is an interesting point. I used to have one of these blue collar jobs (several actually), and you're pretty spot on. In addition to the disdain for this kind of work, there seems to have also been a shift to an idea of wanting to derive fulfillment from work. That seems obviously good, but my experience, working in a factory was in some ways more fulfilling. The work itself was not terribly demanding, and so I could do a good job while not tying up much of my mental resources. This left my mind free to wander, and I would write stories, review music theory, and otherwise ponder life's mysteries while performing my various functions. Then, when I got home I was well equipped with ideas and still had plenty of energy to dedicate towards my more intellectually demanding hobbies. I'm not saying it was heaven on earth or anything, but it offered a certain satisfying simplicity, and made self-actualization easier outside of work. Nowadays, I get home and struggle to find mental energy for side projects or writing. The work is better, and I'm wealthier, but I'm not sure that my life is richer.