3 ms·
I knew the title couldn't mean what it literally meant. But I find that style of title if not "wrong" at least "bad." That the literal interpretation is obvious
by scott_s 17y ago
I knew the title couldn't mean what it literally meant. But I find that style of title if not "wrong" at least "bad." That the literal interpretation is obviously wrong is the intent; it lures you into reading the post to find out what exactly the author means by it. This is in opposition to a good title, which succinctly states the main point and lures you into reading by being an interesting idea.
I consider this technique linkbaiting.
- roc 17y agoI absolutely agree with that. On the axis of truth vs marketing, this is definitely out toward marketing. I don't think this is quite as bad as linkbaiting, but it's surely kin. I guess I just misunderstood what you'd meant by 'wrong'.
- scott_s 17y agoThat's why I said "wrong," to make sure it was clear I was using someone else's word. I probably would have said "misleading." And that was my first thought after reading through enough of the post to understand what he was really saying. I don't like posts where someone makes a provocative statement, then jumps through hoops to redefine words or attach different semantics to make it fit.