4 ms·
Gobsmacked to find this on HN. Thank you. It is worth noting that the critics had little interest at all in Queen during the band's heyday. They loved Bruce Spr
by tomcam 10y ago
Gobsmacked to find this on HN. Thank you. It is worth noting that the critics had little interest at all in Queen during the band's heyday. They loved Bruce Springsteen and Elvis Costello. Queen, Klaatu, Kansas, Styx, Led Zeppelin, Yes? Not so much. The attitude toward Freddie changed when Freddie was sanctified by virtue his death.
One of the stories that impressed me most was Freddie's innate solidity as a musician. He did the piano parts and many vocal parts in "Bohemian Rhapsody" at night--before the drum part was recorded. So Roger Taylor (who also sang the highest parts in that and other Queen songs) ended up using Freddie's part as a click track.
- cyberferret 10y agoYep - that documentary that I posted on here "Inside the Rhapsody" has Dr. Brian May talking about Freddie being an absolute metronome on the piano - with no click track to play to. Apparently his sense of time and control over the instrument was second to none. That documentary is well worth 27 minutes of anyone's time.
- linker3000 10y agoIn June, I was working in Switzerland installing a multi-petabyte storage array for the Montreux Jazz Digital Project (http://metamedia.epfl.ch/montreux_jazz_digital_project/archiving/digitize/digital_media_storage http://metamedia.epfl.ch/montreux_jazz_digital_project/archi...), and during a break in work, myself and a colleague were taken to the home of the late Claude Nobbs, founder of the Festival. The building houses the original recordings of the festival performances (everything from 2" Ampex to digibeta and beyond), plus an overwhelming collection of memorabilia from the guests that stayed in the house and chalets around the grounds; we saw a David Bowie kimono mounted like a large picture on a wall, motorbikes, guitars and other musical instruments, electronic audio equipment from numerous decades, jukeboxes, lots of model trains (Claude collected them)...and Freddie Mercury's piano. Having psychopathic tendencies (so my Mrs tells me), I don't get emotional about many things, but running my fingers across the piano was spine tingling - I really felt in the presence of greatness. /csb
- serge2k 10y ago> Dr. Brian May He's also a CBE, so how does that work with titles?
- SmellyGeekBoy 10y agoDr. Brian May CBE
- 1_2__3 10y agoI was alive and into music this time and I don't think what you're saying is true at all. Almost all those bands were insanely popular in they're heyday - that's why it's called they're heyday, generally. Are you claiming they were on the radio and filling stadiums and making headlines... But the critics were ignoring them? The one I might grant you is Yes, but that's only because they were a little eclectic. But while we could argue about when their best years were do remember that MTV played "Leave It" on repeat for 24 hours once, partly taking the piss but still. For an under appreciated band that's some crazy exposure.
- ekianjo 10y ago> But the critics were ignoring them Not that they were ignoring them - more like they had a negative view of Queen. Freddie started to refuse giving interviews to the press and tabloids were all over the place reporting on his private life.
- tomcam 10y agoThe groups were popular--but critically excoriated.
- jasode 10y ago>But the critics were ignoring them? I think "ignore" in that comment meant "dismissive". The critics were dismissive of Queen during its popular period probably because of the lighter weight songs such as "Another One Bites the Dust" and "Radio Ga Ga". A song like AOBTD sounds like something that a glam metal band could do. A song RGG sounds like something a lot of teeny boppers would sing. Yes, those songs are still loved today and will be always included on any Greatest Hits compilation. However, it's the rule-breaking songs like "Bohemian Rhapsody" that is very "critic friendly" and with the death of Freddie Mercury, its stature as a magnum opus keeps growing. A song like that influences critics to re-evaluate Freddie's and Queen's artistic merit.
- pimeys 10y agoAnother One Bites the Dust is their best disco track and gets people singing in Berlin clubs still. I've head that and Radio Ga Ga to be played in the best nightclub in the world and the whole audience was singing along. The production values of these tracks are amazing. The use of synths and the beats. Knowing something about music production myself I can't help but enjoy hearing some of these 80's megahits. And John Deacon is very underrated. Easily one of the best bass players in the world. And made some of their biggest hits too.
- 1_2__3 10y agoI was alive and into music this time and I don't think what you're saying is true at all. Almost all those bands were insanely popular in they're heyday - that's why it's called they're heyday, generally. Are you claiming they were on the radio and filling stadiums and making headlines... But the critics were ignoring them? The one I might grant you is Yes, but that's only because they were a little eclectic. But while we could argue about when their best years were do remember that MTV played "Leave It" on repeat for 24 hours once, partly taking the piss but still. For an under appreciated band that's some crazy exposure.
- michaelcampbell 10y agoI honestly don't recall any particular apathy or dislike of Queen while they were active. I do recall many articles of their musicianship, but perhaps that was regional, and/or the things I read then.