4 ms·
Nice rant, but part of the argument seems to be that games are lucrative and addictive so they're better. That would be true of gambling too. The question is,
by skybrian 10y ago
Nice rant, but part of the argument seems to be that games are lucrative and addictive so they're better. That would be true of gambling too.
The question is, are they worth spending time on? I do spend a lot of time on certain video games, and I have my doubts.
It's sort of like someone saying a book was so compelling that they read it in one sitting. Yeah, okay, so the plot sucked you in, but are you happy afterwards that you did that?
- CoolGuySteve 10y agoThere are diminishing returns with regards to time spent, but I do think playing games can make you a better person. Dark Souls teaches patience and consistency, Civilization teaches you to think about exponential growth among many other things. Even DOOM 2016 on Ultra Violence or Nightmare is a completely different game than on the default difficulty level. The trick is recognizing these diminishing returns and separating them from your enjoyment of the experience. It may sound glib, but I find it much more worthwhile than writing comments on Hacker News only to experience the stress of having them nitpicked by pedants trying to score imaginary internet points. We're still doing it, but I don't think it's worth my time. Rare is the comment reply that changes my mind and I bet that goes for most people. I'm just a masochist I guess.
- adrianm 10y agoOn a good year, I'll play between one and two games. Not because I wouldn't play more, but because the quantity of great games I wouldn't hesitate to put in the same category as great literature or film is usually zero. Last year was special though. I really can't describe how impactful The Witcher 3 was for me. It really opened my eyes to just how great of an art form video games can be. I don't regret a single moment I played that game and its expansions.
- stuxnet79 10y agoI didn't even bother downloading The Witcher 3 on Steam because I knew I'd get sucked in, and would wake up months from now filled with deep regret. But then you are saying the absolute opposite. Why did I have to read this comment ... ? :(
- creshal 10y agoI found the game so horrible I just bit the bullet and bought the books instead. Better story, and no craptastic combat system to struggle with. Wohoo.
- thenomad 10y agoI have recently been comparing The Witcher 3's place in gaming to Casablanca's place in filmmaking. It's that good. It's uneven - some sections are significantly stronger than others - but the strong ones are incredibly so.
- mentando 10y agoWhy would you regret it though? Do you fear to invest too much time in it?
- stuxnet79 10y agoYes! Just started full time work and I have little enough free time as it is. But I've been very stressed the past couple of months so maybe it will be alright to unwind for a couple weeks or so after work. I might download it during the weekend, heard too many good things about Witcher 3.
- zzalpha 10y agoYeah, okay, so the plot sucked you in, but are you happy afterwards that you did that? Uh, yes. Why wouldn't I be? Should art not be compelling? Enjoyable? Must it necessarily be "challenging" (whatever that means) to be "worthwhile" (whatever that means)? Frankly, the real problem with the author is they give a crap what people think about games as a medium. Art. Not art. Who cares? When Dickens was writing, he was writing to entertain a mass audience. At the time I'm sure there was someone somewhere complaining that since it wasn't written in Latin and thus accessible to folks it wasn't worthwhile. And in the end it just doesn't matter. So enjoy your games or books or comics or whatever captures you and let others do the same. Life is far too short to waste time giving a crap about stuff like this.
- skybrian 10y agoIs worrying about crap like this more or less worthwhile than playing video games? Seems like you say it's less worthwhile (and apparently feel strongly about that), but that's a judgment call too. Yes, you can use your free time however you like. It's still a decision everyone needs to make, somehow.
- zzalpha 10y agoSure, so make that decision. But do it based on what you want and what you value, and let others do the same. Wasting time being concerned if someone else thinks what you're doing or reading or playing is important or valuable is a silly waste of time that could be better spent actually living.
- skybrian 10y agoTotally agree that you shouldn't be much concerned about what other people think. (Especially on the Internet.) I don't agree that thinking about what you want to do with your life is a waste of time. I also don't think you need to decide on this alone - talking to other people about it seems quite okay.
- r_smart 10y ago