6 ms·
This is fundamentally a failure of the education system. It's coming to the West as well. Schools force you to waste some of the most productive years learning
by adamnemecek 10y ago
This is fundamentally a failure of the education system. It's coming to the West as well. Schools force you to waste some of the most productive years learning about pretty useless things and are super inefficient at that too. What else can you do when you graduate and you don't really know anything about the world, can't really contribute to society and on every step you are reminded of being a failure.
The worst part is that it will take decades for society to fix this.
- m0llusk 10y agoThe economic system is at the core of this. People rise to meet opportunities, but jobs have become difficult, rare, and disconnected from purpose or benefit. In the past there were plenty of jobs at all levels but modern business productivity is so high that demand for labor has become specialized and for many has essentially collapsed. What exactly will replace labor is not clear, but some kind of basic income would enable people to pursue meaningful contributions to society outside the dollars per hour context and thus open up many new possibilities.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- adamnemecek 10y agoI think that basic income should be temporary though. Like I'm having a hard time imagining a functioning society where a significant portion of the population is on basic income.
- cloverich 10y agoI think its fuzzy -- and perhaps because its so different, or perhaps because (as you suggest) it may not be realistic. But were it realistic, I'd assume hobbies would be a big part of a well functioning society. I think we'd see at least some blossoming of hobbyists where, free to pursue their highest interests, you'd see some truly spectacular music and art, some people becoming nearly professional at their sport of choice (and more esports). I think there's at least one (and perhaps many) hobbies for everyone, and that many people working and parenting never get around to discovering them. Having only more recently discovered mine, I can tell you I wish i had more time to pursue them!
- smallnamespace 10y agoThere's another problem with basic income: being able to earn an income is a signal of mate quality, and that norm might take a long time to unlearn. While it's better than letting people starve or get food stamps, you might find a large class of young, unemployed males who have trouble getting interest from potential mates. Historically, that's always been recipe for political unrest. And even if there's not, if basic income becomes a thing, I'll bet there is large positive status attached to someone demanding your labor. People on basic will be second-class citizens, and there will always be political pressure from the 'working class' to reduce the drain on the tax base.
- justin 10y agoWe already have large classes of "second class citizens" -- might as well make life more livable for them.
- eddy_chan 10y agoThe whole point of basic income is that it enables such young males to devote their time to pursuing non-monetary goals in music, arts which would signal 'mate quality'. Or longer term monetary goals such as autodidactically acquiring a skill e.g programming and building something. Poor people in the traditional sense would be able to pursue internships without pay to gain skills because they are underpinned by UB. An option not available today. As an employer I could take on more 'apprentices' on UBI, the contract being that I give them training, give them guidance whilst they work 'for free' until a certain point it becomes worthwhile to pay them above and beyond UBI because they're worth it.
- shagie 10y agoThis is known as "bare branches" http://www.ejhs.org/volume15/Bare.html http://www.ejhs.org/volume15/Bare.html
- zhemao 10y agoWell that's a rather euphemistic translation of guan gun. I've always thought of it as "bare stick" or "bare pole". The phallic connotations being 100% intentional.
- ryandrake 10y agoI guess it depends on your definition of "functioning". People spend 1/3 of their lives at jobs they hate, assuming they are lucky enough to be part of the shrinking group who have employable skills, making barely enough to survive, while the majority of excess value created gets funneled to a smaller and smaller subset of society. That doesn't sound functioning to me (well, it's functioning to the small number of benefactors, I suppose).
- visarga 10y agoIt's not ideal, but it affords a higher level of dignity. People have something (work) to trade for money. After automation, the majority of people will have nothing of value to offer. That would affect their independence and dignity. I believe a better solution would be to put automation in the service of people directly, as property of the people. Maybe small communities would be able to combine work with automation to provide for all their necessities. In the future, a few solar panels, 3D-printers and robots could possibly bootstrap a whole community. Then the role of the government would be to provide the initial technology and to make sure each community has its own bootstrap working in order, not to distribute UBI. People would still have work to do - to supervise automation and work alongside with it, where necessary. Somehow, control and ownership of the means of production (automation) would need to be divided and spread equally in the population, otherwise, it will just detract from the value of people. But if we spread automation ownership, then there could be a new level of independence where a community could provide for all its needs internally and perhaps, even desire more autonomy from the state.
- nylsaar 10y agoPretty sure you just described Technocracy.
- aninhumer 10y agoOne benefit I suspect basic income may have is a vast increase in the quality of jobs. When people are desperate for work, and jobs are hard to find, people will put up with all sorts of bullshit from their employer. When people know they'll be okay regardless, they're much more likely to quit when they get treated like shit. And I suspect for a lot of businesses, the cost of improving working environment may be lower than raising wages. For example, I think "customer is always right" policies cause a lot of employee stress for relatively marginal gains. A less desperate labour force may be willing to take lower wages at a restaurant that lets them tell obnoxious people to GTFO.
- panic 10y agoHow much of Silicon Valley is funded by selling ad space? Just imagine the ads are gone and the money is coming through the government instead. (And yes, I understand that companies would rather spend that money on ads rather than taxes... you can replace the ad industry with any other industry we'd be better off without.)
- WalterSear 10y agoYou are missing the point: everyone gets basic income, regardless of income. So people with nothing have enough to eat and live and people with jobs don't feel like they are being freeloaded - they are getting the same amount of money on top of their salary. People, justifiably, ask how we could possibly pay for all this, but the current US welfare system costs a comparable amount. Moreover, the US financial system is currently set up to allow money inflows to be controlled and to benefit the central banks. A much more sensible and effective method for controlling the velocity of the economy would be to put place monetary inflows into everyone's individual bank accounts, but obviously the people in control aren't going to give up the gravy.
- semigeek 10y agoHonest question; what numbers are you using to say it's a comparable amount? My quick search shows total 2016 expenditures of ~$3.9 Trillion. If you assume welfare is everything non-interest & defense related, that's about $3 Trillion; there's other non-welfare lumped in that number, but let's just use it anyway. That's $9,250 per person.
- zanny 10y agoAlmost every discussion about basic income comes to talking about it as a monetary black hole where you pour trillions in and your society has no reasonable expectation of return, much like military spending. That is not at all how it works. A basic income within reason would almost always be an economic growth mechanism by transferring money from investment class to consumption class. The market for the guaranteed needs of an adopting nations population would be an incredibly large, incredibly stable business center for competition and innovation, and it would increase market participation by eliminating the barrier to entry that is currently made by gated welfare. Of course we need long run, wide spread, UBI experiments. If all you are talking about is "what if" any reasonable scientist would balk at the conversation. But if you take historic evidence - that giving the poor money makes them, by overwhelming margins, and on average, spend it on their needs in predictable, immediate ways, you would be getting similar economic motivator returns on UBI taxes as you would on some forms of infrastructure. And by comparison, infrastructure projects also considered a net positive policy because the money made by businesses using your infrastructure vastly eclipses the costs of building and maintaining it. UBI works the same way, by creating stable demand for the necessities of life, and providing the means for a similar force multiplier in people wanting to contribute optimally to the economy by their own judgment than by the will of money in the hands of others for those individuals profit. Because sometimes, making a major stakeholder in a company richer does not mean the greatest source of economic growth for the society as a whole compared to the entrepreneurial potential of every citizen presently bound to that model.
- billmalarky 10y agoYour imagination is being limited by our current (though rapidly changing) model, which is humans are required for the production of goods and services. Basic income will allow capitalism as we know it (that is, end users making consumption choices, not an organization making choices for the end user) to continue in a society where production is completely automated. Supply is automated, but how does the system know what to produce? Well dollars are basically votes for production and basic income is enfranchisement in such a society. Most importantly, basic income provides a mechanism that can work during the harsh transition from "some highly skilled humans are still needed for production while the majority of people are no longer needed" to "zero humans are needed."
- pkaye 10y agoJapan however has a low unemployment rate.
- laurieg 10y agoDemographically speaking, I think Japan would be the perfect place to test the basic income: A largely homogenous society where there is almost no one from the outside to be seen as a "freeloading", collectivist values forming strong group bonds too. Unfortunately, I have spoken to a lot of people in Japan who are dead against any kind of social security. It's not an unusual to view unemployed and poor people as 100% responsible and worthy of no empathy.
- timwaagh 10y agowhich is likely due to the working conditions of twelve hour days and such. i have trouble empathising with such people myself when i have to put my life 'on hold' to attend a job.
- unprepare 10y agoIsnt Japans population aging quite quickly though? When some concentration of retirement aged people is reached, surely these attitudes will see a decline also? I always hear about how Japan is making robots to take care of the elderly, because there will soon be more elderly than young - so i guess im going off that.
- smsm42 10y agoI wonder if those two things are correlated - i.e. if the society has collectivist values and tolerates no "freeloading", it'd be easy to introduce basic income, technically, but the society would not want to do it.
- nihonde 10y agoI can say from first hand experience that Just about everyone I know in Japan is an A+ student by American standards. That goes for the chief of an aerospace subcontractor right down to the kid behind the counter at 7-11. You might think I'm being hyperbolic, but I'm not.
- IANAD 10y agoDid anyone notice that it is 0.4 percent of Japan's population? As of 2010, about 2 percent of the U.S. adult population have a severe form of social phobia and have trouble leaving their house, according to the National Institutes of Mental Health: http://www.livescience.com/16216-outgoing-shy-personality-nature-nurture.html http://www.livescience.com/16216-outgoing-shy-personality-na... It's not coming to the west. It's more here than there. I don't know about it being the fault of the education system, though.
- prawn 10y agoI wonder if the social phobia is equivalent in both populations, but that Japan is (however it may be) more accepting of aversion to a social life?
- zhemao 10y agoThis implies that hikkikomori are accepted in Japanese society. They are definitely not. Which is part of the reason for their social withdrawal.
- prawn 10y agoI meant in the sense that perhaps parents, with children displaying early signs of social phobia, are more accommodating. Are families too enabling of behaviour that can become entrenched?
- zhemao 10y agoI mean, what are they supposed to do, kick their children out of the house? In the end, the genesis of Hikkikomori's reclusion is their feeling of having failed at life. They can't deal with society's expectations of them, so they withdraw from it completely. There's not much parents can do to change that feeling of failure. It's not really a distinctly Japanese phenomenon. I'm sure you can find just as many young recluses in every developed country. Japan just found a cute term for it, that's all.
- fierycatnet 10y ago> Schools force you to waste some of the most productive years learning about pretty useless things and are super inefficient at that too. I don't know if this is the part of the problem for hikikomori phenomena but you are right about the above. I started working at 16 and have worked multiple industries ever since. I've had many opportunities to advance and have a promotion but I was always held back by one thing, college. Simply because I was told to do it. I've half-assed both things, college and work, not because I wanted to or I was lazy, but because it was hard to do both at the same time. So many missed chances. "Oh you are in school? Sorry we need somebody full time for this position." Now several years later, I have a piece of paper and many lost opportunities with one weird resume. I wish I never listened to anyone about "you must go to college" and just worked and took on opportunities that I had instead of "sorry, it's not compatible with my college schedule, can't take this on". And I gotta say that I am a "recent" graduate now who has been working since 16 but my resume looks like I am a dabbler with no extensive experience in anything. I am worse off now with a debt. I'd be lying if I said it didn't effected me greatly emotionally and physically. The confusion about what I've done wrong is so stressful that I am a borderline hikikomori. So I think you are right in some parts.
- fma 10y agoThe funny thing is that America wants their education to be more like the east, because America is behind in math and science While the east wants to be more like America, because their students are too rigid and instead needs to focus more on creativity and play! http://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2013/12/03/248329823/u-s-high-school-students-slide-in-math-reading-science http://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2013/12/03/248329823/...
- swiley 10y agoWe could have both if we wanted. Real math (not being a human calculator) is very creative.
- aaron695 10y agoBlaming school? School forces you to interact with others from a wide range of backgrounds. This is the worse argument ever, it's exactly the cure. Besides which, school isn't there to baby you, that's supposed to be the parents job. Sure as back up for people with abusive parents, but the concept it should be the default is very scary. It's 7 hours a day, what's happening the other 6? What exactly should you be learning that won't into that extra 6 hours?
- adamnemecek 10y agothe thing is that you get six hours of low energy time. School is pretty exhausting. Also account for things like homework, hygiene, eating. How many hours are you left with? Your argument should be justifying the 7 hours, not saying you have 6 hours left.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- kardashian007 10y agoRote memorization and low details education is good for creating compliant, easily-fooled suckers whom sign up to the Marines because they enjoyed playing America's Army or Halo. Instead, we (all of us) havr to do the hard work in instilling courage, mistrust of blind obedience to authority and critical-thinking into those coming up to be less fooled as adults and more likely to become public interest lawyers, more involved in fact-checking and holding people accountable for their duties / behavior. Standardized testing (NCBLA) is exactly the wrong "medicine." There is no quick/easy fix except spectacular teachers, parents and mentors that care to not spoon-feed, child-proof the world or helicopter parent too much because learning requires someone else doing the thinking to figure out why it's important, not simply being led through random motions aimlessly.
- Tharkun 10y agoSchool is a waste of time for a very, very, very small part of the population. For the vast majority of people it works (surprisingly?) really well.
- adamnemecek 10y agoTell that to the high school and college graduates who are unemployed (and unemployable) and working minimum wage jobs.
- amazon_not 10y agoI don't think the vast majority of the population would benefit from not having a high school education.
- Tharkun 10y agoAh yes, I'm sure they all deeply regret 4 years of learning, growing as human beings, making friends, etc. Being unemployable after college is BS. Being unemployed is a different matter, but uneducated unemployment is much higher than its educated counterpart.
- adamnemecek 10y ago> regret 4 years of learning 4 years of inefficient learning > growing as human beings what does this even mean > making friends You don't need school to make friends. > Being unemployable after college is BS. Do you actually believe this?
- teekert 10y agoIt also doesn't help that I see that from ages of 10 and up or so, kids come home from school to do homework every day, instead of going out with friends into the summer sun for a nice carefree afternoon of playing soccer (or whatever). Homework is a killingly stupid idea in my mind. I was smart enough to hardly ever having to do it after school when I was young but I highly doubt that I could manage without doing it in the current system (I did school in the Netherlands by the way.)
- sdrothrock 10y agoParticipation in club activities (sports or otherwise) is basically mandatory in junior and senior high school. Elementary kids often do go straight home and then play with friends or waste time, but once you're in junior high, you're basically considered a young adult and expected to have responsibilities. Many clubs will take up MORE time than homework, with the sports clubs often having an hour or two of practice before school with the same again after school, plus most of Saturday and sometimes half of Sunday. Generally when students get together, the last thing they want to do is play sports since they're doing that pretty much every day of the week!
- teekert 10y agoAnything mandatory outside of the pretty long school hours we already have seems like a bad idea to me. Making sport mandatory, ugh, what a perfect way to get kids to dislike it as early on in life as possible.
- sdrothrock 10y agoSchool hours aren't that long here; they're shorter than mine were in the US!
- paulryanrogers 10y ago> Participation in club activities (sports or otherwise) is basically mandatory in junior and senior high school. Not in my experience. For some parents and communities maybe, but certainly not all.
- mikekchar 10y agoKeep in mind that Japanese schools are very different from NA schools. There are advantages and disadvantages, but for better or worse students are aggressively streamed from junior high school. Basically, you go to whatever elementary school or junior high school that is in your area. When you are ready to go to high school, you choose which high school you want to go to and you have to pass an entrance exam. A high level high school is very stressful and you have to study all the time. A low level high school is very easy going and it is not unusual for some students to graduate without having studied anything at all. At a high level high school you are expected to go on to University and have to prepare for University entrance exams. At a low level high school, you may still prepare for University entrance exams, but you are not necessarily expected to do so. In a low level high school there are many activities surrounding how you can can contribute to society. In the high school I taught in (a very low level one), every Wednesday afternoon was taken up by classes on what it's like to work in a factory, or a convenience store, or a farm. There were classes on basic etiquette, how to talk to customers, how to get along with people, how to dress, etc, etc, etc. I was always annoyed because they wouldn't let me join in on those classes -- it would have been fascinating! Essentially, students in a low level high school are indoctrinated into society as well as having a very basic education. There is a lot of emphasis on skills that students are likely to need (like using an abacus, typing, writing kanji, very simple foreign language exchanges, etc). Things like math, science, etc were taught, but I never got the impression that they were seen to be particularly important parts of school. The main thing about a low level high school is that apart from normal bullying, there is practically no stress. Seeing a student who is not smiling is an indication that something has gone absolutely pear shaped. My colleagues in high level schools told me that things were pretty much the opposite. Tons of stress every day. Pressure to perform. Lots of expectations. Focus on academics, almost exclusively. Students are expected to already know how to act in society, etc, etc. Very different life. But low level schools outnumber high level schools by about 4:1, so the huge high school stress that everyone assumes exists in Japan is really limited to a minority of top performing students. Having grown up in Canada, I would choose the Japanese system hands down over the Canadian system. I would have been in the super stressed high level school and having a much better time ;-)
- n-exploit 10y agoWhile I understand your sentiment, from a certain point of view, I find it sad. I'm likely generalizing, but it seems that the common theme shared among my millennial peers is that the job of the education system should be focused on preparing the individual for "life in the real world" I would greatly fear the movement away from topics like history, science, civics/political science, etc. in favor of the creation of someone I would describe as an "economic drone" I think it would be a great loss indeed to lose focus on our past.
- CaptSpify 10y agoIt feels like there needs to be two different systems. One for "job training", and one for "general learning". I think things like certification are the right direction. I'd love to go to school for general learning all the time, but that's not directly applicable to my job, and with the costs so high, it's just not practical.
- matt4077 10y agoSubjects taught at school haven't really changed – math, science, writing, a bit of philosophy and languages, i. e. the liberal arts curriculum. None of that is "useless" as it's more about learning-to-learn anyway. And young people today are better than previous generations in basically any category: SATs have risen steadily, political participation is at the level of the late 60ies, volunteering is commonplace, crime is at an all-time low and cultural output is exploding. The only thing that could ruin the next generation would be teaching them "pratical skills" by which people usually mean stuff like accounting. That's the humans-as-economic-units view that leads to exactly the situation in Japan: Millions of super-educated, completely generic young people who work 12h a day as told without ever complaining or having an original thought.
- adamnemecek 10y agoThe thing is that the way all of these are taught is very inefficient. Also you Hagee very little choice in what you can learn.