2 ms·
It's virtually my mantra on economic issues, but: Second-order effects, second-order effects, second-order effects. The fact that I am not now currently in jail
by jerf 17y ago
It's virtually my mantra on economic issues, but: Second-order effects, second-order effects, second-order effects. The fact that I am not now currently in jail does not mean the law has no effect on my life, and when you put it that way the logical error being promoted here comes out starkly.
(I often find myself thinking this is why capitalism attracts so much enmity, as it is a major economy system that only makes sense when you consider second-order effects, perhaps the only such major system. Socialism and communism all have soothing first-order stories ("Is somebody richer than you? Take it from them, and they'll be less rich and you'll be more rich! And let's not worry about the second-order effects of such actions! Everything will always stay the same! Wheee!") and the problems don't arise until you consider the second-order effects.)
- pw0ncakes 17y agoI often find myself thinking this is why capitalism attracts so much enmity, as it is a major economy system that only makes sense when you consider second-order effects, perhaps the only such major system. Socialism and communism all have soothing first-order stories Most intelligent socialists know about the "second-order effects", to use your terminology. Some of the effects of redistribution are good (better-educated populace, social stability) and some are bad, depending on the extent of it and how it is done.
- jerf 17y agoI don't meet too many intelligent $ECONOMIC_MODEL proponents on the internet. Yes, I freely include my preferred economic model there. I have much more respect for people who hold opinions which disagree with mine and have actually thought them out, rather than just coming to the opinions they have because it seems... nice.