3 ms·
Journalism class was the only worthwhile "language arts" class I took in high school. The "literature" ones were, IMO, mostly a bunch of horse shit and a waste
by davidw 17y ago
Journalism class was the only worthwhile "language arts" class I took in high school. The "literature" ones were, IMO, mostly a bunch of horse shit and a waste of time, to put it very bluntly. There are classes and teachers that I looked back on more fondly when I was done with them because I realized they'd been good for me even if they were difficult, but none of the literature ones were in that category, only the journalism class stuck with me as something useful.
Why? Because the lit ones were about writing bullshit about some teacher's bullshit interpretation of what was more often than not some sort of bullshit book/essay/play/whatever, whereas the journalism class was about how to convey facts to a hurried reader quickly and efficiently.
Ok... rant over:-)
- billybob 17y agoAgreed. I've got a journalism background (though I'm now a web developer) and it has helped me tremendously. The main thing is this: think and write carefully. I get emails from business people that are long, rambling, and at the end, I can't even tell what they mean or want. And the subject line isn't helpful if I need to find it later. I write emails with the assumption that you've got 5 seconds to read it. Subjects like "Are we still meeting at 2PM today?" so you might not even need the body, which is short and to the point. Also, if I have three unrelated questions for someone, I write three short emails. I want them to be able to answer two and flag one for later if necessary, without drudging up the other issues that were already solved. The other great lesson from journalism is "people have short attention spans." The inverted pyramid is for hard news stories, but even fluff pieces try to start with really catchy first sentences and be clear throughout. If you lose people's attention too often, you lose your customers. Many academics and businesspeople should learn from this - they often seem more concerned with sounding smart than really conveying information. Great ideas are no good if nobody hears about them. And in my experience, great minds are generally good at explaining their ideas clearly.
- billybob 17y agoActually, let me backpedal a bit. I don't think literature is crap. SOME literature is crap. But if all of it was, we wouldn't have a standard of quality to judge by, would we? Literature can be wonderful, and reading good stuff can help you write better, too. But different styles of writing serve different purposes. I love Billy Collins' poetry, but it doesn't help me write good business-related emails. Neither does journalism help much when writing a love song.
- yters 17y agoI try to fit my whole message in the subject line (ensuring readability, of course).
- cschneid 17y agoLiterature == art Journalism == engineering (both of the written word). Complaining that literature is a waste of time is like saying I can't paint my house with oil paints and a tiny brush. Technically true, but you're really missing the point.
- davidw 17y agoArt is a fairly subjective thing, and I found literature as presented in high school to be a complete waste of time. And no, I'm not missing the point. Looking back, it really did not have any redeeming value for me. That's the way my brain is wired, and I won't be ashamed of it just because "society" thinks literature is great. I don't, and I'll say so if I please without 'missing the point'. On the other hand, I loved the visual arts courses I took. Thanks in part to a good teacher, I found a lot to appreciate even in works I found "ugly" at first glance.
- bradbeattie 17y agoA large part of primary and secondary education is exposing you to different vocations, at least in part. Taking a course and recognizing that it's not for you is an invaluable experience, especially at such a young age. Think of it as the shotgun approach: Try a little of each to assess your desire and aptitude.
- davidw 17y agoYes, that's certainly fair and sensible. The problem is that lit is one of those things that you had to take every year where I went, so the only respite from it was a year of journalism.
- TheSOB88 17y agoI doubt he's saying the entirety of literature is a waste of time, just the way his literature class (and by extension most of them) was run.
- tsally 17y agoLiterature isn't about writing anymore than Computer Science is about programming. Part of your bad experience seems to stem from you not realizing this. The CS equivalent is assuming you're going to learn how to program in Theory of Computation. The other part of your bad experience comes from the fact that your instructor was a poor educator. Grading solely based on the instructor's interpretation of the work is the canonical teaching mistake in English. Of course, having a bad instructor will make any course a bad experience, regardless of the discipline. It's unfortunate your experience was so terrible because I find English to be very worthwhile. I've taken some of the most advanced undergraduate CS courses in the country and they were very worthwhile. Yet AP Engish senior year in high school and one English course in college match the CS courses in terms of being worthwhile. I think it's best to clarify what I mean by worthwhile. One worthwhile moment in Computer Science was when I finally understood Lisp macros. Another one was when I understood Turing Machines. I'd say I've had about 5 or 6 of these moments over the past few years in CS. These are moments where you feel like you understand something in a fundamentally different and higher way. English produces similar moments, but they are about the world at large instead of just a technical field. Taking one English course per semester has netted me one or two worthwhile moments a month. It's really quite something. If you're ever given the opportunity, I urge you to give literature another try. It's difficult to find a competent teacher, but it's worth the effort.
- davidw 17y agoI got a lot more out of journalism because it was about how to effectively communicate something to other people, which is an extremely valuable skill. "Learning" to "analyze" (i.e. parrot something the teacher told us. And as far as I can tell he never consulted the author of the work to verify the correctness of his assertions) the symbolism in Ionesco's plays is to me, worthless. > It's difficult to find a competent teacher Great teachers in any field are rare, but I found the lit ones to be particularly mediocre. I think it's a field where you can do ok even if you talk out your ass and hand-wave, whereas, say, a physics teacher at least ought to know the material he's teaching, even if he's not the best at conveying it. Truth be told though, the physics teacher I had in HS was one of the really good ones. He was a smart guy, and while at first seemed quite 'harsh', in reality he was demanding and expected precision. I learned a lot from him.