4 ms·
Whatever you think of IBM's ends, the use of these means: "Mueller points out that two of the patents that IBM listed in its [threatening] letter to Hercules a
by hga 17y ago
Whatever you think of IBM's ends, the use of these means:
"Mueller points out that two of the patents that IBM listed in its [threatening] letter to Hercules are included in the list of 500 patents that IBM promised to not assert against open source software in 2005."
Can't be seen as good.
- alexandros 17y agoThat was my initial understanding too, but I am not sure if TurboHercules, the for-profit company, is shielded as is openHercules, the open-source project. This loophole may allow them to sue and keep their promise at the same time. Again, I am not quite clear if this is the case.
- hga 17y agoInteresting ... but how could IBM's promise mean anything if TurboHercules, which is an open-source company, isn't protected against assertion of all 500 of those patents. The loophole is a contractual issue between IBM, its customers, and perhaps TurboHercules (in that the latter is encouraging the customers to violate the contract). I don't see it having anything to do with open-source patent assertions and again I can't see how IBM's promise would be worth anything if the latter had its own loophole of a "If we sue you for other reason the 500 patents become fair game."
- _delirium 17y agoI'm guessing when someone notices that they'll drop those two patents from the suit, which still unfortunately leaves 171 patents for which they haven't promised anything. They probably couldn't actually prevail on those two patents anyway, if it went to trial: a public open letter promising not to sue if someone uses the patents could be interpreted as an implicit patent license, or at least trigger estoppel.