20 ms·
‘Superbug’ scourge spreads as U.S. fails to track rising human toll
- fernly 10y agoThe question that comes to my mind is, are the European countries doing any better in tracking MRSA, etc. infections? They certainly exist. One might hope a more centralized health-care system, not balkanized like the USA one[1], would keep better records. Do they?
- gtufano 10y agoRecords are kept at European Antimicrobial Surveillance System (EARSS) or so it seems, at least. Last report (with freely downloadable raw data) I found (2014) is here: http://ecdc.europa.eu/en/publications/_layouts/forms/Publication_DispForm.aspx?List=4f55ad51-4aed-4d32-b960-af70113dbb90&ID=1400 http://ecdc.europa.eu/en/publications/_layouts/forms/Publica...
- okket 10y agoThe Dutch have a MRSA strategy they call "Search and Destroy" with harsh quarantine regulations for non-native patients. http://www.spiegel.de/international/germany/combating-deadly-bacteria-hospitals-have-hope-in-dutch-search-and-destroy-strategy-a-726781.html http://www.spiegel.de/international/germany/combating-deadly...
- jkot 10y agoI think 'balkanized' is good word to describe some health-care systems in Europe. However I think there is a basic difference in approach. Hospitals in europe are usually uber clean, everything is desinfected and there is a small army of cleaners. My impression from US is that McDonnald was cleaner than hospital. Second difference is post-operation treatment. People in weakened state are left in hospital for a few days for monitoring. With broken immune system (after chemotherapy) you get into strict hermetic isolation. In US leukemia patients go to hotel after treatments.
- waqf 10y ago> My impression from US is that McDonnald was cleaner than hospital. I'm really interested in this. Where were you? Because my impression of the US is that they are very thorough on the small stuff … because they can pass the bill on to someone for taking precautions, whereas they can be sued for not taking them.
- ams6110 10y agoThere's a reason that people get these resistant infections mostly in hospitals. Really, unless the alternative is death anyway, you're pretty well advised to stay away from hospitals.
- anexprogrammer 10y agoUK NHS MRSA infections are reported weekly online on data.gov.uk Patients are screened for MRSA if they are being admitted for surgery, cancer and a number of other risk groups, or have had MRSA previously.
- jcromartie 10y agoBut our gov't is right on top of banning even more harmless plants... (Kratom this time).
- danso 10y agoReally fascinating to me how some of the problem originates from the lack of proper coding standards: > As examples in this article show, superbug infections are often omitted from death certificates. But even when they are recorded, NCHS can’t feed that information into vital statistics: The World Health Organization (WHO) classification system the agency uses lacks mortality codes for most drug-resistant infections, though it has codes for more than 8,000 other possible causes of death. > The CDC added codes for use in the United States for terrorism-related deaths a year after the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks. It could do the same for deaths from drug-resistant infections. Officials told Reuters the CDC is instead working to incorporate the codes into the WHO’s next revision of the international classification system. The revised system is expected to be completed in 2018 but not fully in use until the 2020s. The problem of inconsistencies in death certificates have been around since, well, the history of death certificates: http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2014/04/07/final-forms http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2014/04/07/final-forms
- apathy 10y agoPart of the issue is assigning "cause" (singular) of death. I'm still kind of shocked that there isn't mandatory reporting of bacterial vectors (when identified) the way there is for (eg) tumors. Sepsis is common enough that positive identification of the primary strain(s) involved could be a huge unfunded mandate, though, and judging by the way Zika is going, unfunded is being optimistic.
- danvayn 10y agoI wouldn't say sepsis is that common. More with the elderly and alcoholic crowds, but not generally speaking
- openasocket 10y agoFrom the wikipedia page, it seems more common than you would think. In the US it is the 10th most common cause of death, and globally kills 200k a year.
- 10y ago
- codezero 10y agoMy mother in law, a healthy 50 year old, recently died of an unspecified infection. They still don't know what it was or why antibiotics weren't helping. Ultimately, her lungs gave out after more than a week on life support. Was it a superbug? Dunno, and nothing in her medical record leaves any indication that it might have been, the world just moved on.
- apathy 10y agoCondolences, it's rough when someone close is taken suddenly. Can't brace yourself for something you can't see coming. Part of the problem is the sheer volume of such cases -- where did the infection come from? Why did it get worse so fast? Was it bacterial, viral, fungal? The diversity of microbial life on earth is so vast, and the rate of evolution so quick, that any one center is going to be hard pressed to keep up just cataloging new strains, let alone figuring out what sequence of drugs to try. This is why it is a national tragedy (at least in the US) that we don't put more emphasis on funding the CDC. Other countries do better or worse, and particularly some states like Minnesota do a lot more. But I can reasonably guarantee that the possibility of humanity being devastated by an easily transmitted bacterial or viral vector is greater than anything a YF-22A is likely to ward off. A centralized repository and clearinghouse can do so much more than any one center, even the richest hospitals, because it can (in principle) see everything at every center. Just needs enough funding and oversight to get the job done. I recognize that nothing can bring your MIL back, but perhaps if the CDC were given a bit more respect (instead of being a political football to defund abortion and legalize Confederate flags, as at the present), you might have some answers and the next person in that situation might pull through. No guarantees in life, but it seems like a higher expected return on investment than many government priorities. JMHO. Sorry for your loss, and the open questions around it.
- dv_dt 10y agoThere was an article a few years ago about the fall of the medical autopsy rate. Because it's unclear how we fund it, and most people aren't in a position of knowledge to request it (or in a financial position to pay for it), the rates of autopsy to find a considered cause of death have been dropping precipitously.
- partycoder 10y agoCan MRSA be treated with teixobactin? Now, E.Coli with MCR-1 is also spreading, isn't it?
- nkrumm 10y agoMRSA is Staph Aureus, a gram-positive organism, and colistin is only (to my knowledge) used in treating gram negative infections (such as e coli, which can carry mcr-1). MRSA can be treated with a number of different antibiotics, including vancomycin, daptomycin, linezolid, Bactrim, and clindamycin to name a few. Teixobactin is not yet on the market or approved for use in humans.
- chmaynard 10y agoI'm sorry for your loss.
- gruyere 10y agowtf is wrong with you? Edit: commenter made a pretty robotic and insensitive comment. My comment is not constructive, however it can be important to let people know when their behavior or words will have a negative impact on others. A more appropriate response would have been "Wow, that's both insensitive and unnecessary. Perhaps you should reconsider your phrasing."
- cdelsolar 10y ago?
- anonymfus 10y agoNon-native speaker here, I would probably express my condolence in the same way ("I'm sorry for your loss"). What is so wrong with these words that they deserve WTF?
- maxerickson 10y agochmaynard decided to retract what they had said earlier.
- chmaynard 10y agoThat's correct. I realized my remarks were insensitive after several readers downvoted them.
- sctb 10y agoWe detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12444330 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12444330 and marked it off-topic.
- esaym 10y agoI skimmed the article, I only saw mention of MRSA. Is that the "super bug" they talk about? This is for the most part why I won't step foot in a hospital unless I am literally on my death bed. The last research I read about MRSA (years ago) was it was hard to study because lab rats could not be easily infected with it unless it was directly injected into their blood stream. This shows just how nasty hospitals are. Nobody gets MRSA unless they are in the hospital.
- giarc 10y agoCommunity acquired MRSA is quite common now.
- DanBC 10y ago> Nobody gets MRSA unless they are in the hospital. You might want to read about Community Acquired MRSA. http://www.phac-aspc.gc.ca/id-mi/camrsa-eng.php http://www.phac-aspc.gc.ca/id-mi/camrsa-eng.php http://wwwnc.cdc.gov/eid/article/8/6/01-0313_article http://wwwnc.cdc.gov/eid/article/8/6/01-0313_article > To estimate the proportion of community-acquired MRSA, we analyzed previous hospitalizations for all MRSA-positive persons in Finland from1997 to 1999 by using data from the National Hospital Discharge Register. Of 526 MRSA-positive persons, 21% had community-acquired MRSA.
- brightsize 10y agoMy brother got exactly this, presumably from swimming in the ocean during a vacation in the Philippines. I speculate that there was sewage being released into the sea somewhere not far from where he was staying. He lived, but the infection site was pretty nasty to behold.
- maxerickson 10y agoIt's worth noting that Finland has been aggressive in controlling MRSA in hospitals, so they may have a higher proportion of community infections. Also from the paper you quote: Based on our study, the proportion (21%) of community-acquired MRSA was relatively high in Finland.
- 10y ago
- ocschwar 10y agoBear in mind that in the US, our lovely republican party literally made it illegal to research where the superbugs are being bred. In the US, the problem is mostly pig and cattle feedlots that rely on antibiotics to keep the animals from being sickened but he crowding. Naturally, there is no proof that superbugs are coming out of the feedlots, because the feedlot owners do not allow any sort of sample collection by scientists. Now comes the GOP with the "ag-gag" laws, which don't just ban sneaking into these feedlots with cameras. They also ban the smuggling of manure samples from the feedlots. This is the GOP's war on science: they literally criminalize it.
- marcoperaza 10y agoShould someone be allowed to sneak into a company's building, or pretend to be an honest employee, just to investigate potential wrongdoing? That's the government's job, not private activists'. If someone wants to walk into your private property and research your operations, you should have the right to tell them to beat feet. If there is a legitimate public interest then the government should create an inspection scheme; there probably should be one but that's a separate debate. But allowing guerilla espionage by activist groups is not an acceptable alternative.
- swasheck 10y agoThere is legitimate public interest as these sites are key components of the food production system. The point that the OP was intentionally making is that the government (via GOP leadership, apparently) has specifically excused itself from creating such an inspection scheme and done so in a way that seems comprehensive enough to understand the alternative paths "guerilla ... activist" scientists could even potentially report on such a matter.
- marcoperaza 10y agoThat the government is failing to investigate something cannot be a license to trespassing or lying your way to a private investigation. If you want government action on something, then you have to win in the political process. Taking matters into your own hands and assuming the powers reserved for the government is not acceptable. =================== Replying to swashek below since I'm rate-limited: what are you talking about "thought crime"? None of the laws here concern thought or the freedom to publish your thoughts. They ban conducting suriptitious investigations on farms, which necessarily involves either trespassing or deceit in gaining access (e.g. an activist getting himself hired as an employee)
- alkonaut 10y agoThis is why antibiotics use in livestock should be a top question in international trade. Not only should every country stop using antibiotics in healthy livestock, all imports of meat and animals from such countries should be banned, and to take it one step further - stop importing umbrellas and calculators from those countries too, in order to apply economic pressure.
- exDM69 10y ago> Not only should every country stop using antibiotics in healthy livestock Antibiotics are not used for healthy livestock in many countries. The US is a very notable exception. It comes down to cutting costs. In the US, it's not typical to clean the facilities between batches of animals like chicken. This mean that the new batch would contract any bacteria left behind the previous animals. It's not even that big of a cost, I'd call it borderline negligence. I agree with you, this practice should end. Giving antibiotics to livestock at all is harmful and it should never be done as a precautionary measure. On smaller farms, isolating or just killing the sick animals would be fine but that will not work in industrial scale.
- daxorid 10y agoThis is not the reason antibiotics are given to livestock. A wide class of antibiotics, when delivered in subtherapeutic doses, increase feed conversion efficiency and result in larger animals for the same feed inputs. So yes, it's about costs, but not for the reasons you cite.
- exDM69 10y agoIt's not the only reason but it is a reason. But that's irrelevant, it's a cost cutting measure with harmful consequences to the society as a whole. The regulations and producer prices should be adjusted to make small to medium scale farming profitable and stop the antibiotics madness.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- EGreg 10y agoThis is exactly why we need open source drugs. I have written about this extensively. http://magarshak.com/blog/?p=93 http://magarshak.com/blog/?p=93 It's the flipside of the factory farm and overprescriptio fiascos. Yes, those are bad, but we haven't discovered new types of antibiotics for decades... and many diseases get far less attention, because of patents and silos. Even researchers working as a result of public funding are snapped up by big pharma once they make a discovery which then acts as a parasite on the public money. Science progresses when anyone, anywhere, can contribute. Same with open source. It is the reason Wikipedia is larger than and just as accurate as Brittanica or any other encyclopedia. It is the reason Android runs on so many phones, and Linux runs on toasters. It has given us everything from WebKit to Wordpress and created a massive amount of solutions for the LONG TAIL instead of just boutique drugs. It took 30 years to discover a new antbiotic type: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/science/2016/03/14/first-new-antibiotic-in-30-years-discovered-in-major-breakthroug/ http://www.telegraph.co.uk/science/2016/03/14/first-new-anti... More people studying eg human bacteria in the nose will find cures if they are unencumbered: http://www.nature.com/news/the-nose-knows-how-to-kill-mrsa-1.20339 http://www.nature.com/news/the-nose-knows-how-to-kill-mrsa-1... We need patentleft! All that phage therapy etc. shouldn't be controlled the way monsanto controls agriculture now.
- andrewclunn 10y agoSo avoid hospitals unless absolutely needed. Gotcha.
- merpnderp 10y agoOr only go to the top hospitals in the country. Comparing how the staff at a place like MD Anderson manages sanitary conditions compared to county or state hospitals is mind boggling.
- agentgt 10y agoEven with in the same state and county it is pretty mind boggling the differences from hospital to hospital. For example in Massachusetts where we are known for having some of the best hospital there are still certain hospitals in the greater Boston area to seriously avoid...
- lgleason 10y agoMy mother died from a MRSA infection after getting back surgery. It's really nasty stuff and a very painful way for someone to die.
- webXL 10y agoI'm sorry for your loss. Hopefully we as a society can devote more resources to minimize the occurrence of this cruel disease.
- daveloyall 10y agoHello. I work for public health. My job is to support the computer systems that allow epidemiologists to track 'superbugs' (and regular ones). Deathcerts is an interesting dataset. It's not the only one. Even if death-by-MSRA isn't tracked, I assure you that MSRA itself is tracked. There's a specific class of lab test called "antibiotic susceptibilities". The results report includes a bunch of numbers that represent just HOW resistant a particular bug is to a standard battery of antibiotics, broken down per antibiotic. That data is transmitted from the labs that performed the test to the state health department where it is analyzed. Fascinating article, but there's NO WAY that Reuters had that much contact with state public health folks without being aware that they track lab results. Misleading! Edit: elaborated about the susceptibilities results.
- daveloyall 10y agoUpdate... I asked around the office and learned more about this. TL;DR: I'm less right than I thought. Specifically regarding tracking cause of death: Not every disease or condition is "reportable". Each state maintains a list of reportable diseases. When a hospital/lab (hereafter: facility) encounters a disease on the list, then they are required to report it. State health departments will open investigations in various circumstances. You've seen events like e. coli outbreaks in the news--those always precipitate an investigation. There are also investigations associated with individual infections, i.e. every case of tuberculosis. If a patient involved in an investigation dies, public health will find out. But, if a patient dies from (because of) an infection that wasn't on the reportable list, then public health won't know the cause of death unless it is on the death certificate. Just like the article says! Regarding tracking the susceptibility of bacteria to antibiotics (superbugs): Any sample that is tested for antibiotic susceptibility is reportable. The results of that testing generally include the specimen source, but don't include why the test was ordered (i.e. because some person has sepsis and might die) and certainly there's no (deliberate) relation between this data and cause of death.
- pg_is_a_butt 10y agoHello. I read the lies published by Y Combinator. Misleading!
- 10y ago
- webXL 10y agoThis is terrifying. Perhaps we should be devoting more resources to fighting this than ISIS since it's literally in our back yard. It seems like this is a problem nanotech could possibly solve. Microbes won't have much time to build up resistance if we can go after them directly. http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/nanotech-drug-resistant-bacteria/ http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/nanotech-drug-resi...
- wehadfun 10y agoI would vote for a politician that talked about this issue.
- clumsysmurf 10y agoIts our pets too ... My dog was recently diagnosed with MRSP (methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus pseudintermedius) urinary track infection. Having mostly avoided the vet for the duration of his life (being that he was healthy) I have no idea how this happened.
- alexmingoia 10y agoI don't know why I even read news anymore. It makes me feel hopeless when every news story leaves me without actions I can take to change anything.
- ams6110 10y agoBy design. The dramatic recounting of terrible but rare diseases as if they happen as often as sneezing keeps you reading. Eyeballs on ads == $$$ for the publisher.
- thomyorkie 10y agoThousand-year-old Anglo-Saxon potion kills MRSA superbug: http://www.cnn.com/2015/03/31/health/anglo-saxon-potion-mrsa/ http://www.cnn.com/2015/03/31/health/anglo-saxon-potion-mrsa...
- dghughes 10y agoThis is almost like going all the way back to Dr. Semmelweis who figured out that you keep hospitals clean or people will die. Even long sleeves can be the enemy. I know superbugs are different but the concept is the same.