6 ms·
I'd wager that the vast majority of people that would test as being depressed are depressed because they are in a crappy life situation for one reason or anothe
by empath75 10y ago
I'd wager that the vast majority of people that would test as being depressed are depressed because they are in a crappy life situation for one reason or another. I was depressed to the point where I barely left the apartment for 2 years, other than to go to work. You know what got me out of it? I bumped into an old friend who had just come back to the US from an extended backpacking trip. I ended up quitting my job and backpacking for 3 months. It totally changed my perspective on life, and I met my now-wife, who was also backpacking, and we currently have a kid and I have a much better job than I had before I left. Turns out I was depressed because I was bored and lonely, and all I really needed was a kick in the ass to get moving again.
There are obviously lots of people who seem to be depressed out of all proportion to what's going on in their life, and would benefit from antidepressants to get them going again, but I really don't think that it should be a first resort for all of them.
- mklim 10y agoThe fundamental problem is how cripplingly little we understand about neurobiology. "Depression" is a label given for a common cluster of symptoms, not a single disease originating from a few well-understood causes. We aren't able to objectively test for or treat it the way we can X-ray a broken bone and set it or swab a throat for strep and prescribe antibiotics. There are no methods that are guaranteed to help the vast majority of sufferers and no clear understood root causes. All we can do is ask for the patient to report their subjective experiences and try to tick some boxes in the DSM, find a label that describes at least N/N+M of their symptoms, and then work through an associated checklist of wildly different methods of "treatment" that reduce symptoms in some, but not all (or even a majority, AFAIK) of patients. I personally think that many (if not most) of the mental illnesses listed in the DSM will eventually be understood to be multiple completely unrelated root conditions that all manifest similar symptoms, each with different methods of treatment. Unfortunately research initiatives tend to be shackled to the DSM's set of superficial symptom groupings in order to get funding, so a deeper understanding of them is probably a long time coming. (Related read: http://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2015/08/why-depression-needs-a-new-definition/399902/ http://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2015/08/why-depres...)
- imagist 10y agoYou're not wrong, but it's worth noting that there are some really obvious things we could do which would cure a lot of people. Not, for example, requiring people to work 40 hour weeks when there isn't enough work to employ the entire populace 40 hours a week is one obvious measure, because it removes the need for people to sit at their desks doing literally nothing, and would result in more people being employed. Restructuring business so that people are rewarded for providing value instead of acting as gatekeepers of value would be another. Removing the near-constant bombardment of advertising from our emotional and social landscape would remove a lot of demands on people's attention and allow them to focus on activities they find meaningful. The fact is, people are depressed because the powerful in our society benefit from treating the majority of our society like shit.
- Noseshine 10y ago> Not, for example, requiring people to work 40 hour weeks > when there isn't enough work... Indeed. And the problem isn't actually the work load - but the lack of appreciation and meaning, the former being connected to the latter. In this context: "The boss, not the workload, causes workplace depression" (http://sciencenordic.com/boss-not-workload-causes-workplace-depression http://sciencenordic.com/boss-not-workload-causes-workplace-...) - EDIT: focus is on "not the workload", I believe bosses are incidental and themselves a variable very dependent on existence meaning But even the best bosses can only do so much to make jobs that require convincing people to buy stuff you know they don't need seem meaningful. I bet after WWII when in the war countries the part of the population that remained at home had to work their asses off to produce until then unimaginable quantities of stuff nobody was depressed. The work had meaning. After it was over it helped that they had good job and income prospects - and reasonable long-term job security too. "Flexibility" is nice for those who can afford it.
- imagist 10y agoI agree on the lack of appreciation and meaning, but the problem is more fundamental than good or bad bosses: the problem is that "bosses" rarely are a needed part of the process at all. A good boss can minimize the damage they do, but in the end, most bosses are just middlemen between producers of value and consumers of value, a position which allows them to siphon off value without providing any value themselves. Giving someone who provides no value decision making power over people who provide value is always going to result in the person who provides no value overvaluing themselves. It's no surprise that many people feel undervalued, because inherently bosses are overvalued.
- randomgyatwork 10y agoPoor life situations are depressing, but as a society we think drugs are the solution. There seems to be little encouragement to live more meaningful lives, which in turn will make us more happy and less 'depressed'. Note: There are clinical cases of serious depression, but it seems most cases aren't that.
- cujo 10y ago> but it seems most cases aren't that I like to think this also, but is it actually true? Has anyone done that survey?
- Bartweiss 10y agoWell, we can use the income result as a proxy. 18% of lowest-income adults were depressed, 3.7% of highest-income adults. That doesn't preclude 'medical' depression, but it implies that it's at least mediated by circumstances, which is an interesting place to start.
- GrumpyYoungMan 10y agoSeems more probable that you have the cause and effect backwards. Being affected by depression prevents people from functioning well enough to work in a high income profession.
- psyc 10y agoSeems even more probable that the controversy exists because it's a two-way feedback effect.
- Bartweiss 10y ago"More probable" feels like a claim that requires evidence, otherwise we're telling just-so stories. I certainly think this is bidirectional, and it probably has some common-cause issues too (e.g. if your parents are too depressed to earn high incomes, you're getting an economics-genetics double whammy). More to the point, though, your narrative is about 'medical' depression causing low incomes. Mine is about low incomes causing 'non-medical' depression, so realistically we're talking about different things. I'm sure they overlap, but I'm also confident that there's a difference between depression from "good life, but serotonin imbalance or immune response or whatever" and "lost my job, lost my house, lost a family member". Most depression screens don't distinguish "depression because depression" from "depression because my life is shitty", and it's not at all clear that anti-depressants are more effective in one case than the other. So my main observation here is that the high incidence at low income could be about untreated medical issues, but it could also be about a failure to differentiate medical from situational responses.
- vlunkr 10y agoThis is the difficult thing about clinical depression, how do you know if it's truly a chemical imbalance or just the normal reaction to your situation? Sure, there are these screenings, but in my non-professional opinion they are pretty bad. Maybe it's an epidemic of false positives on depression screenings.
- zepto 10y agoThe chemical imbalance theory has little scientific support.
- Broken_Hippo 10y agoWe still are in a pretty fuzzy area when it comes to depression and some other mental illness. Some things point to imbalance, others don't. It is really hard to screen for concrete sort of things when we don't have the science quite right yet, nor decent tests like we do with the thyroid. There might be some hope with things like MRI's being able to detect such things, but I highly doubt we are going to use that on a widescale basis nor that all that need screening can afford it. As such, the screenings really are a combination of what society thinks is normal, what the person relays about their mental activity, and whether or not it interfears with their life. And that is always going to be a bit objective. I'm sure there are a few false positives: However, I'd also argue that there are probably more false negatives because so much of it depends on how the person reacts to the words. For example, you aren't suicidal, and you don't want to kill yourself, but you'd like to invisible or left alone most of the time. So you answer no to the suicidal thoughts thing. You just feel kinda numb and empty, so you answer no to the 'down mood' sorts of questions. You remember being happy about stuff, so that is out of the question. The question about losing interest in normal activities? Well, you've never really had hobbies or many friends, so that isn't even applicable. Sometimes it is clearly the situation that is the trigger, but at that point there are two problems. The person's life events or lifestyle, plus a depression that keeps them from getting out. If you treat the depression bit, they might be able to see their way out or be motivated to take some action to improve their life. Some will still need help with this bit, and it is a shame there aren't support networks everywhere to help folks.
- adam12 10y ago> I ended up quitting my job and backpacking for 3 months. Imagine if you were unable to quit.
- empath75 10y agoYeah, believe me I know. I actually had saved up a enough money for the trip more or less by accident, just because my car was paid off and I was such a hermit for so long.
- pdeuchler 10y agoYou're almost there. Maybe we should be questioning why so many people are depressed in the first place. People all around the US (and in many parts of the globe) are seeing their economic prospects slowly disappear in front of their eyes as good jobs evaporate into thin air (and no, the increases in Walmart greeter, part time, minimum wage style employment or "gig economy" freelance paychecks don't count). Political turmoil, lack of true and diverse representation in the political system, an increase in racial tension, foreign instability. All of these things are weighing heavily on the mind of the average American, regardless of actuality. You were able to solve your depression by almost entirely changing your life's focus and goals. Like you said, you totally changed your perspective... but you were only able to do so because I assume (since this is Hacker News) you have skills that translate to good job prospects in the information economy. This gave you the freedom to completely redefine your life. Now imagine you have the same malaise, except you already had kids, a mortgage, debt with no real economic opportunity, don't have the financial strength to quit your current job much less take a vacation of any length, are being told by the TV that your way of life is being threatened by INSERT_BOGEYMAN_HERE, that a certain presidential candidate's election will guarantee catastrophic ruin, and to top it all off you can't (or don't think you can) afford to go to a doctor and get Zoloft because your new insurance plan under the ACA heavily dis-incentivizes taking action on medical issues. I'm just scratching the surface here, these problems are huge and intertwining. However I feel this single manifestation is good proof of how seriously our society is being strained. People's social identities are being attacked and we're getting articles about how we need to push some of the most prescribed drugs in history to more people. On its face this is insanity. We need to start questioning the fundamental power structures that are creating these situations rather than continuously trying to bandage the symptoms or we will experience continued social decline regardless of technological achievements, improvements to quality of life, and advancements in other areas.
- aboonaboo 10y agoYep and by definition you can't have a clinical diagnosis of depression if you have any life situation that would explain it better MDD and the like are mental disorders, not moods