5 ms·
I love this casual implicit assumption that the existence of large-scale crime syndicates with nothing in practice to fear from the law is in no way noxious to
by throwanem 10y ago
I love this casual implicit assumption that the existence of large-scale crime syndicates with nothing in practice to fear from the law is in no way noxious to society. Tell me more.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- CamperBob2 10y agoSome might say that your description could basically be used as the dictionary entry for "police." It's been suggested that they're the best-armed gang on the streets, if not the best-disciplined. They're certainly beyond the reach of the law, at least by the standards the rest of us are held to.
- throwanem 10y ago"Some might say"..."it's been suggested". What do you say? What do you suggest?
- CamperBob2 10y agoOverall, I think the police catch a lot of heat and resentment for the actions of their political bosses. Like corporations and unions, a community usually gets the police force it deserves. Unfortunately, that's no consolation to the individual citizens who cross paths with them. A good start on repairing relations with the police would involve holding them to higher standards of behavior than the rest of us are expected to exhibit, instead of lower ones. I think most good cops would agree with that basic sentiment, since they're the ones who behave as if it were already the case. Ultimately, though, when the government decides to launch an impossible war on drugs, terror, pornography, or some other abstract noun, the police will have to do the inevitable dirty work, and they will have to take much of the blame for the consequences. The real problem here isn't the FBI agents running the servers, but the administrative and legislative bosses they answer to.
- throwanem 10y agoI dunno. It sounds like on the one hand, you're blaming police officers and departments for problems which have origin in corruption at a pay grade well above theirs, and on the other, you're defining (or would define, perhaps) any attempt by police forces to influence, rather than merely execute, policy, as stigmatic of a police state. Seems like a bit of a Catch-22 to me.
- CamperBob2 10y agoIt is a Catch-22, definitely. At some point you get into the whole "Nuremberg defense" thing. There is little practical difference between the Black Marias described by Solzhenitsyn and what happened to Freddie Gray in the back of a van in Baltimore. But how can we fix that sort of thing at an institutional level, when supervisors, prosecutors, judges, and juries insist on going easy on the actual perpetrators? That's the sort of question I'm compelled to ask when the FBI comes around, hat in hand, to ask for even more surveillance and enforcement powers.
- throwanem 10y ago> There is little practical difference between the Black Marias described by Solzhenitsyn and what happened to Freddie Gray in the back of a van in Baltimore. You horrify me, sir. You truly do. We agree, I think - I hope - that our current system of rule staggers under an enormous burden of corruption, which if not addressed will continue to expand until it bears us all under. And we agree, I think - I hope - that this is something which would better be prevented than otherwise. But to equate what happened to one man, himself and his fate far from usual in myriad ways, with what happened as a matter of official policy under a regime that murdered thirty millions of its subjects simply because they were inconvenient? Where is the sense, or the value, in this? You have succeeded in horrifying someone who has otherwise considerable sympathy for the point you sought to make, although not so much the lack of nuance with which you did so. What effect do you imagine yourself likely to have on someone who does not start out with such sympathy?
- 10y ago
- digler999 10y agoSomalia is police-free. Are you up for it ?
- CamperBob2 10y agoSomalia is a failed state run by divisional chieftains and warlords with military weaponry. In other words, it's all police. That aside, how surreal is it to argue in favor of the application of equal justice for all under the rule of law, only to have "herp, derp, why don't you move to Somalia?" thrown in your face as a counterargument?
- digler999 10y agoI suggested it because it's equally fallacious of you to equate police with "warlords with military weaponry". You can use all the fancy nostalgic buzzwords you want, but ultimately if the law has no bite, nobody will honor it. That bite is called enforcement and it's done by police. Get over it.
- throwanem 10y ago> I suggested it because it's equally fallacious of you to equate police with "warlords with military weaponry". I agree. Do you think perhaps it might be of some value to argue this point in a way that's not trivial to dismiss for valid reasons? I think perhaps it might be of some value. Feel free to continue to caricature yourself for the benefit of unsympathetic interlocutors if it pleases you to do so, but please also consider the possibility that you might argue more effectively by doing otherwise.