3 ms·
Could also be easily a case of being overly qualified of them not even taking the application seriously because if some one sent a CV that looks like his to any
by dogma1138 10y ago
Could also be easily a case of being overly qualified of them not even taking the application seriously because if some one sent a CV that looks like his to any entry level tech support / sales support position they would most likely assume it's a gag.
Overall hiring overqualified people is a problem, they might never be happy and they can easily undermine the structure of a company even unintentionally.
This is like hiring some one like Wozniak to do entry level programming at a company hell undermine everyone from the team leader upto the CTO just for being who he is.
- azakai 10y agoAge discrimination and not hiring "overqualified" people are overlapping problems. Older people can often be described as overqualified. It's also unclear whether being overqualified is actually a problem, which you assumed as true. See for example https://hbr.org/2010/12/the-myth-of-the-overqualified-worker https://hbr.org/2010/12/the-myth-of-the-overqualified-worker > research shows that overqualified workers tend to perform better than other employees, and they don’t quit any sooner.
- dogma1138 10y agoAgain age discrimination is also something easily thrown out. And overqualification simply cannot be dismissed as you easily point out, the studies that have been conducted a are both contradictory and in your case completely misleading. Being "overqualified" by possessing an above average intelligence and being more highly educated than the average employee in a menial position such as retail or sanitation is one thing, being overly qualified in a technical field in a highly competitive market is another. Taking on a considerably more experience engineer than the average for an entry level job might end up good, but it also might not end up that well, you can see it a lot during the recession people needing work accepting lower paying jobs which they overqualify for and they leave as soon as they find a better place. so no "> research shows that overqualified workers tend to perform better than other employees, and they don’t quit any sooner." isn't universally true, it can be true for certain circumstances but this isn't even the level of overqualification we are talking about.
- AstralStorm 10y agoOverqualified should be read as "we want someone who works for peanuts". The fact of life is that older people do not like being taken advantage of.
- quantumhobbit 10y agoIf someone who is truly overqualified would disrupt your organization, maybe it needs to be disrupted. After all being overqualified would imply that their judgment is superior to the norm within your organization. If their judgment wasn't good then they aren't qualified much less overqualified.
- macintux 10y agoYou're conflating intelligence (and I suppose other work skills) with wisdom. Having good judgment is more the latter than the former.
- quantumhobbit 10y agoWouldn't wisdom(I'll admit that it is hard to measure in an interview) be part of what makes someone qualified for a position. If you are super smart but lack wisdom, then you aren't overqualified let alone qualified. Overqualified implies that the candidate exceeds by a large margin all requirements for the position whatever those qualifications are.
- bryanrasmussen 10y agoThis is also like the recommendation "hire people smarter than yourself" because if they are smarter than you they are probably also more qualified than you (obviously you can find people smarter than you and train them in your field but how often does that happen?)