3 ms·
It's really not clear why and how one does become a pedophile, that said the FBI was going after the producers and dealers of child pornography not the consumer
by dogma1138 10y ago
It's really not clear why and how one does become a pedophile, that said the FBI was going after the producers and dealers of child pornography not the consumers.
For the most part the consumers are being left out of major prosecutions, one can also make an argument that blocking all sources of CP might increase sexual assault cases involving children if the users cannot get their relief that way.
But this overall isn't a clear cut case.
- 1_listerine_pls 10y ago> one can also make an argument that blocking all sources of CP might increase sexual assault cases... mmm... I don't see how one could argue that without actual data.
- probably_wrong 10y agoThe idea has been thrown around for a while, but of course, there's no way to get a definite truth on the matter. Here's one article[1] claiming a possible link between availability of porn and abuse. But I'm sure there must be at least one other study arguing the opposite. [1] http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21116701 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21116701
- aerovistae 10y agoIt's a chore sometimes not to break the vulgarity rules here. You do understand that child pornography is created by the rape of children? You're saying, "Well, it could be argued that if we stop letting these guys rape them, possibly more children might get raped. We should let it go." No.
- dogma1138 10y agoAnd? the FBI did not create it, it redistribute it much of it I would assume is pretty darn old, wouldn't surprise me if things that originally were recorded on VHS is still around being sold and traded. I think that the entire argument flew over your head, the FBI isn't going after consumer it is going after the producers you know the ones in your case who are actually doing or arranging the raping.
- gizmo686 10y agos/rape/statutory rape/g In our current environment, this is mostly a pedantic distinction because almost all child porn is produced in an otherwise abusive environment. Also, the definition of child porn is far broader than what would be required to meet the definition of rape, which requires penetration. [0] The definition of child porn is also sufficiently broad to include any pornographic image that depicts an identifiable minor in a sexual act, whether or not said minor was actually ingaged in said act, or involved in the production in any way. The FBI also has a stash of already created child porn. Any harm resulting from the creation of said porn has already been done, and is therefore not a reason to not use it in order to reduce future harm. [0] Technically, many jurisdictions do not have any form of "statatury rape", but instead use other crimes like sexual abuse.
- pavel_lishin 10y ago> s/rape/statutory rape/g We're not talking about a 25 year old filming his 17 year old girlfriend giving him head here. This is the kind of stuff where the people involved cannot consent. Your spellchecker is broken.
- gizmo686 10y ago>We're not talking about a 25 year old filming his 17 year old girlfriend giving him head here. Yes we are. What you describe is child pornography. Depending on jurisdiction, the girlfriend cannot consent. Even in jurisdictions where she can consent, it is still child porn. Even in situations where the 17 year old is acting alone, it is child porn. Even in situations where the 17 year old draws a picture of herself masturbating, it is child porn. I guest you are correct, my comment should read: s/rape/depiction in a sexual manner/g Either way, my point is that we should be careful of the language we use, and recognize that child pornography is far broader than circumstances that would generally be considered "rape" are. My phrasing was sub-optimal due to my other problem with the conflation of statutory rape and normal rape.
- thomas_duncan12 10y agoActually we don't know. It's impossible to know. The government tells us these individuals shared horrifying pictures, but if a journalist (for example) wanted to verify these claims, she'd face prison time too for downloading the images. So in theory it could mostly be a bunch of nude selfies taken by 16 and 17 year old teens which are circulating around these websites. Or maybe it really is horrific imagery of babies and toddlers being brutally raped, as horrifying as that sounds. Impossible to know. If it's the former, I have a serious problem sending people away to prison for decades because they want to see a nude 16 year old (keep in mind by the way the age of consent is 16 in most states). If it's the latter, then by all means. I guess I'm just an optimist, but I have a hard time believing that tens of thousands of people on just this one site want to see toddlers being brutalized. Additionally, I would hope that the supply of such images is quite low. On the other hand, I would imagine there are many more people interested in 16/17 year olds, coupled with the fact that almost every teenager has a camera in his or her pocket, means that the supply of those pictures would be far greater and far more subject to sharing. When the FBI says "suspect X was found with thousands of child porn images including toddlers under 5," that could be 2,000 images of nude teen selfies with 2 toddler images accidentally downloaded. But it's really impossible to know what's going on - it's illegal to do any independent investigative work and this stuff never makes it to a jury. The FBI just has free reign and they tell us "just trust us."
- fad0om 10y agoNot all child pornography is created by the rape of children. Classification of CP can include fictional stories, artistic depictions (often anime style drawings) and 'child models' in suggestive poses. Rape is a crime and should be treated as such. Fictional CP shouldn't in the same way we don't make watching videos of sex, movies containing murder, etc illegal.
- Hondor 10y agoThis attitude is why it's so hard to have a sensible conversation about child porn. Change the subject to torture, murder, genocide or any number of far worse things and people won't get so emotionally wound up. There's something about child porn that bring out the jungle in people beyond proportion. There's nothing wrong with throwing ideas around in a discussion. Nobody here is going to go rape a child just because they talked about the definition of rape.
- angry-hacker 10y agoTorture is worse? The kids grow up and suffer tremendously. They are tortured every day for the rest of their lives. Many, if not majority wish they were dead. You must lack any empathy to make a comparison like that.
- OneTimePatrick 10y agoThe sad-irony here is, the very same wound up individuals don't give anything emotion-wise if a childs rights are violated on a non-sexual basis. Sweatshops to glue those phones, shoes and shirts together? Not a problem. Beating them for religious reasons. Not a problem. Starving them for social ideologies. Thats okay, they are responsible for themselves. As seen in WW2 and later crimes. Genocide on families (including children), okay, as long as you don't have to witness it and can make a profit from it. Its really only sexual crimes that get monsters to rage at monsters. It must be some primal instinct, that is completely detached from the crime and the victim itself. Its really all about the pure existence of the criminal.