4 ms·
But police must "break the law" on a very regular basis. Often those actions that are common are specifically exempt (ie breaking the speed limit to catch a sp
by sandworm101 10y ago
But police must "break the law" on a very regular basis. Often those actions that are common are specifically exempt (ie breaking the speed limit to catch a speeder). And sometimes people are killed because the cops broke the law (many have been killed by speeding police cars). So it is too simple to state that they should obey exactly the same rules as everyone else.
- krapp 10y ago> So it is too simple to state that they should obey exactly the same rules as everyone else. I don't think so. They should be held to a higher standard than everyone else, or at least an equal one, but not a lesser one. I'm not particularly concerned that doing so would make it more difficult for them to catch criminals - people who are otherwise innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. It should be difficult (but not impossible) for law enforcement to do its job. That's the sign of a society in which civil liberties still have some meaning. In this particular case, we have the FBI running a child pornography ring to catch child pornographers. Arrest every member of the FBI who was involved, send them to prison and put them on the sex-offenders' list for the rest of their lives. Treat them the way they would treat everyone else. Maybe then they'll learn to actually respect the laws they enforce, and the judicial process would wind up being more fair out of the need for self-preservation.
- xg15 10y agoSo how exactly would they catch speeders then if they absolutely must not break the speed limit?
- dublinben 10y agoRoadblocks, etc. You can't outrun a police radio.
- krapp 10y agoHigh speed chases are a bigger threat to public safety than speeders, so simply not pursuing most speeders and escalating situations would probably save more lives in the long run. They have license plate trackers, cameras, etc - they don't have to chase people down and personally hand them a ticket. But if they did have to, then the police should be charged for speeding as well, since a speeding police car presents the same potential danger as a civilian one.
- nemothekid 10y ago>They have license plate trackers, cameras, etc - they don't have to chase people down and personally hand them a ticket. This is a pretty odd defense. How would you answer OP's question when worded this way - "So how exactly would they catch speeders then if they absolutely must not break the speed limit in 1955?"
- krapp 10y ago>So how exactly would they catch speeders then if they absolutely must not break the speed limit in 1955?" I'm not arguing that they absolutely can't break the speed limit - only that when they do, they should pay for it. The police should have no greater privilege to break the law than anyone else. And yes, sometimes that might mean letting speeders off the hook. I don't have a problem with that. It's better to have the police be hamstrung by the law than to allow them to exercise arbitrary power, as long as they're hamstrung in the same way as every other citizen.
- jliptzin 10y ago1. Have one police car hidden at point A watching for speeders. 2. Have a second 0.5 miles down the road within radio distance. If first car spots a speeder, radio to second car the description of the vehicle and attempt to pull the car over without speeding, or record license plate # in case of speed away, or stop traffic if not on a busy road until the target vehicle is pulled over.
- koverstreet 10y agoChange the law to make it legal for police to exceed the speed limit, in clearly specified circumstances. Which, by the way, is the way it already works. "Police have to break the law to do their jobs" is not a defense, because the law can be changed. If the police want to run a child porn ring to catch pedophiles, let them try to get the law changed to allow that. Having the police decide which laws they are and aren't allowed to break is not a recipe for a free and just society.
- syshum 10y agoI do not support the idea of giving police all kinds of exemptions from the law. The police should have no more power than a normal person, they are simply hired and trained to do what normal people do not have the desire to do. This goes back to the foundation of American style governance, For the people by the people. The police are people, as such they are not the masters of anyone, nor are the people subordinate to them.
- koverstreet 10y agoThere's nothing wrong or unprecedented about creating exceptions for particular circumstances - people acting in a specific capacity or otherwise. For example, ambulances and firefighters are certainly also allowed to speed, when they're carrying out their duties - we've added exceptions to our laws for those circumstances, and done so as part of the normal democratic process. More mundanely, a park ranger is going to be allowed to do things like not pay the same parking fees that everyone else is allowed to, or cull animals out of season when the general population isn't allowed to hunt. This is fine! In a democratic society, we make the laws, and within certain bounds we can make whatever we want legal or illegal. We can also debate about whether or not certain groups that represent us should have certain powers, and it's also perfectly fine to have different points of view about what exact powers they should have. But fundamentally, all that's really going on here is we're deciding to delegate certain powers and responsibilities to a particular branch of government, which of course works on our behalf. The problem here isn't that the police have these exceptions carved out for them, the problem is that - at least arguably, there's room for debate here - the democratic process and rule of law has broken down in this instance, and the police aren't following the law at all. Now there's always considerable shades of gray in situations like this - arguably more so in common law countries, where there's layers and layers of interpretation on top of everything, and a good deal of vagueness in quite a lot of the law. It's been generally accepted for a long time that the police have a certain amount of latitude to break various laws in ways that are not remotely spelled out in the course of investigating crimes; many would argue (with some justification) that this covers what the FBI is doing here. There's nothing inherently wrong with this argument, as long as there really are checks and balances - that is, if the interpretation of what laws police are allowed to break isn't arbitrary, but is the result of some kind of consensus where the judicial system and the legislative system (the democratic process) has set bounds as it sees fit. I personally would be in favor of generally stricter limits, less vagueness and greater scrutiny of precisely what laws the police are allowed to break and when - but still, there's nothing _inherently_ wrong with the situation we're in now, at least to the degree that police conduct does follow the rule of law and it isn't "police getting away with things just because they're police". And on the more general subject of police and the rule of law - I don't find this particular instance with the FBI particularly problematic; I would prefer stricter limits here but I don't think this is an instance where the rule of law has broken down. I do think that the situation with entrapment in general _is_ a genuine problem - for example, the FBI has been manufacturing terrorist plots and cajoling/bribing people to help out in some small way that never would have if they didn't need the money, just because they're Muslim (which the FBI has been doing repeatedly). That, I think, is a clear example of an instance where the judicial system has clearly failed. Or even worse, the many police departments that routinely murder black people with hardly ever any real repercussions. But again - the problem isn't with the police having exceptions to the law, the problem is with a breakdown of the rule of law.
- sandworm101 10y agoSo must we write massive exemptions for police officers into wire fraud laws so that they can 'tell lies' online? Do we need a law excepting them from pretending to be a child during pedophile stings? And another law for giving a false name to a police officer, for when they are doing internal investigations? Cop are given some room for a reason. Adding a bright-line exception to every criminal law is not practical. It is left to the courts to set the rules.
- gwright 10y ago> They should be held to a higher standard than everyone else, or at least an equal one, but not a lesser one. This isn't logically possible, if they had to obey the same rules, they wouldn't have any police powers: - use of force to subdue someone (would otherwise be assault) - handling of evidence that is otherwise prohibited (drugs, munitions, etc.) - physically detaining people, which would be considered kidnapping by anyone else The police have an elevated authority by definition. Certainly there should be (and are) constraints on this authority, it isn't unlimited, but it is too simplistic to simply say they have to obey the same rules as everyone else.
- syshum 10y agoA private citizen most certainly can detain and subdue person violating the law. Atleast in the US. Now if you do this and the person is not in fact violating the law it will be you being arrested however if I catch someone breaking into my home at 3am I most certainly can use physical force to detain him/her.
- gwright 10y agoOf course, but this is an example of a citizen using special police powers because they are acting in the role of a police officer. In that role, the citizen or the actual police officer is enabled to do things that are not otherwise permitted -- they are following different rules.