3 ms·
You're looking down this telescope from the wrong end. It's not that living in Manhattan itself somehow extends your life, it's that only very wealthy people ca
by smacktoward 10y ago
You're looking down this telescope from the wrong end. It's not that living in Manhattan itself somehow extends your life, it's that only very wealthy people can afford to live in Manhattan -- especially in retirement, when most people are living on a fixed income. And in American society, having great wealth means you also have access to things like high-quality food, great medical care, assistive technologies, all of which are things that really can extend your life.
So if Manhattan suddenly became affordable and hordes of ordinary retirees moved in there, you wouldn't see all those ordinary retirees suddenly start living longer, you'd see the average life expectancy for retired Manhattanites drop as the crappy food and medical care the proles get drag the numbers down.
- msandford 10y agoArticle might as well be titled "to live long, be rich" How they managed to completely overlook the "hidden" confounding of being very wealthy and retiring in Manhattan is rather impressive.
- Chinjut 10y agoThe article isn't making any claims about retiring to Manhattan causing increased lifespan. It isn't even intended as a scientific article at all. I suspect many here only read the headline? It's one man's personal essay on their decision to retire to Manhattan and their enjoyment of it. [Tl;dr: The use of "long life" in the title (probably not even chosen by the author) is figurative, not literal.]
- dwaltrip 10y agoIt's a lifestyle piece, not a societal analysis.
- donretag 10y agoYou are forgetting the hundreds of thousands that have a rent controlled/stabilized apartment.
- otoburb 10y agoI thought that "hundreds of thousands" living in a rent controlled or stabilized apartment in Manhattan was too high, but came away surprised. From a 2015 article only a tiny percentage of units are rent-controlled, but around 47% of rental units on the market are rent-stabilized.[1] The problem is that the statistics refer to the entire city (all five boroughs), and may not necessarily be specific to Manhattan itself. EDIT: Found a Furman Center report from 2011 on rent-regulated units[2]. The key table is on page 2 broken down by borough, where Manhattan rent-regulated units account for 48% of the total rental units. The same table shows a breakdown by neighborhood too. [1] http://citylimits.org/2015/03/09/nycs-endangered-species-a-rent-controlled-apartment/ http://citylimits.org/2015/03/09/nycs-endangered-species-a-r... [2] http://furmancenter.org/files/publications/HVS_Rent_Stabilization_fact_sheet_FINAL_4.pdf http://furmancenter.org/files/publications/HVS_Rent_Stabiliz...