2 ms·
The people I talked to, from Symbolics, did not tell me the Stallman version. So at least I have a lot of doubt about the story that the article linked tells.
by lispm 17y ago
The people I talked to, from Symbolics, did not tell me the Stallman version. So at least I have a lot of doubt about the story that the article linked tells.
Especially since Stallman and the FSF surrounds a lot of propaganda. Essentially Stallman was working for a government lab paid for mostly by the military (DARPA). DARPA wanted to see their investments applied to military software and created the commercial structure to do that. Stallman was living in his dream world thinking that all that money was coming for free and for the best of mankind and he could play there forever, working on editors and other stuff - when in fact the military wanted all kinds of advanced software for their projects, which then lead to 'Strategic Computing Project (SCP)' and 'SDI'. DARPA paid the whole show and had the goals - intelligent software for weapons, battle management, pilot training, logistics, etc.
- hga 17y agoThe above is interesting, but I never felt it was a driver of any significance for RMS, especially since the AI Lab was so very far removed from the sharp end of the spear. A much better explanation someone told me was that one day RMS realized he no longer had anyone who'd go out to lunch or dinner with him (since they'd almost all gone to work at Symbolics and [you can fill in the rest]). Now, there were people working on that sort of thing, e.g. I did some customer support for an LMI CADR that was sold to MITRE in Virginia (as I recall) where they were trying to do what you might call "battlespace SIGINT with memory", i.e. help get around the switching your transmitter on and off and hopping frequencies fun. Very interesting problem, but it was very early level research, I think more a proof of concept than anything else. I.e. unclassified research, at least at the level I've described it (I certainly didn't have a clearance). And then there was the company that had Lispm's driving bulldozers (for maximum efficiency), but I was only told that 2nd or 3rd hand.
- lispm 17y agoI don't know if Stallman was aware that he was working as a programmer in an early stage (basic research, tool building, ...) of a multi-year military project. All the stuff was basically paid for by DARPA (and related). Symbolics sold much of their initial production to SDI projects. It was thought that the SDI systems were extremely complex and that many Expert Systems were needed to design, deploy and maintain the space-based weapons and their infrastructure. The SCP projects were more down to earth: battle management, logistics, pilot training, etc. SCP was spending one billion dollar in ten years on AI - add to that the money that was spend on the AI-related parts of SDI. The background of SCP is told here: http://books.google.com/books?id=eD4taFgeTUYC http://books.google.com/books?id=eD4taFgeTUYC 'Strategic computing: DARPA and the quest for machine intelligence, 1983-1993'
- hga 17y agoPlease ... we all knew the money came from DARPA and that they weren't interested in improving the state of the art in plush toy design. SDI officially started in March 1983 (although BMD had been a hot topic for decades) ... and that was about the time RMS started transitioning out of Lispm work. We were roommates in September 1983 when he officially started the GNU Project. We certainly had debated BMD/SDI (before I started working for LMI I was the editor of the ARM-D mailing list), and I can't remember him ever saying GNU had anything to do with that sort of thing. It had to do with end user freedom, as he has explained at length, with a singular purpose of mind and consistency. If this was a major motivator, shouldn't he have put in a "you can't use this software for evil" clauase in the GPL? His GNU EMACS and GCC work has certainly enabled much more development in weapons and the like than anything he did at the lab, and I assure you he's intelligent enough to have realized that, and at least in the '80s he had enough intellectual honesty to realize that ... we all had to ask ourselves that question (and I wouldn't let anyone weasel out of it if they tried :-). Hmmm ... maybe he claimed this to others, but he knew it wouldn't fly with me. But surely only as a minor aspect of why he was going from proprietary Lispm work to free software.
- bitdiddle 17y agoI think a whole lot of AI research was DARPA funded, Reagan's star wars initiative and so forth.