11 ms·
I was sort of there (in the larger social circle, worked at LMI, was a roommate of RMS after that, etc. etc.). If you'd spend a little time with both in that p
by hga 17y ago
I was sort of there (in the larger social circle, worked at LMI, was a roommate of RMS after that, etc. etc.).
If you'd spend a little time with both in that period you'd have absolutely no doubt who's more credible.
As for the specific claims:
I can't speak to how he did it and if he looked at Symbolics source code, but I do know that RMS only created a fraction of the software artifacts that the Symbolics team did on top of the existing code base (RMS is/was back then good, but only so good ... and very possibly below the average for the core AI Lab Lisp Machine team (note that average was very high indeed)).
His effort concentrated on covering the very most important new core stuff ... the last thing I remember talking with him that he was doing before I exited the Lispm community was something like an exception system, but it's been way too long to remember any details.
As for who "invented" TECO EMACS, everyone I talked to at the time said it was primarily Guy Steele, who then turned it over to others after a very short period. At the time, the effort was mostly to get the community to agree on a common set of key bindings, macros, etc. There were something like three popular sets which meant it could be very difficult to sit down at someone else's console to help them. I can well believe David Moon lent a significant hand there, he was one of the very top wizards (e.g. KL-10 (for ITS) and Lispm microcode) but one of the most quiet ones.
- bitdiddle 17y agoInteresting. I recall working a bit on Statice, which I believe Weinreb and Lamb? wrote. There was a phenomenal amount of code coming out of that lab, so it's not surprising that RMS was considered average within that group. I was as TJ Watson then, in math sciences. I recall IBM lawyers not letting RMS come speak at the lab, when one of the guys had invited him to talk about emacs. At the time IBM was quite shy of this "free software" business. I think the account in this article largely comes from the Sam Williams biography of Stallman. I actually own stock in Symbolics, if the company still exists. Last time I saw a statement it was worth $0.02 I was never able to get certificates, which I was hoping to have as a momento, to go with my symbolics mousepad. Thanks for sharing. This sheds a little more light on this piece of history.