3 ms·
> 1. Journalists shouldn't write articles about how person X makes €Xm a year. I disagree. If some CEO says that workers salaries are too high and he himself i
by bjourne 10y ago
> 1. Journalists shouldn't write articles about how person X makes €Xm a year.
I disagree. If some CEO says that workers salaries are too high and he himself increased his salary by 50% the last year, that is important for journalists to write about.
> 2. Researchers: the data could easily be anonymized.
Researches are interested in seeing how different variables correlate with salary. Like gender, age, education level, parents social status and so on. Those correlations can't be made on anonymized data.
> 3. Transparency. Why? Just because you say everything else is public isn't a valid reason (to me).
You misunderstand. Transparency is about the government being transparent with it's data, not about ME being transparent. I'm allowed to keep as many secrets as I want -- the government is not. For example if the government had records on my sexual preference or political affiliation, I for sure would prefer if that data was public and not kept secret.
> 4. Corruption: BS. I would seriously doubt people would be stupid enough to receive “dirty" money and then declare it to the tax authority.
A lot of corruption involves one party "gifting" the other something. That kind of corruption has been caught by the tax authority.
- charlesdm 10y ago> A lot of corruption involves one party "gifting" the other something. That kind of corruption has been caught by the tax authority. Like what? A house? You can't really catch cash transactions. I would assume that in developed economies the "easiest" and least transparent way of corruption happening is friends doing each other favours. I.e. person A can influence the granting of permits through his friend, person B. In return for helping person C get a permit, he gets a board seat in the company of person D, via person C.