4 ms·
If your standard for private individuals censuring someone is unimpeachable truth of wrongdoing, there is pretty much no way for that standard to be met. Privat
by vkou 10y ago
If your standard for private individuals censuring someone is unimpeachable truth of wrongdoing, there is pretty much no way for that standard to be met. Private individuals can't conduct criminal investigations, compel testimony, or do any of the things that make it possible for courts to do their jobs. (And in the case of sexual assault, courts are terrible at punishing the guilty.)
Innocent until proven guilty is a thing because the cost of a wrong criminal conviction are absolutely devastating to an innocent person.
In a civil situation, the cost of not censuring a sexual predator is absolutely devastating for the people hurt by them. The converse cost of a wrong censure are much lower then they are in the criminal case.
The fact of the matter is, given how rare rape accusations are, if one person accuses another of rape, you can think of it as a tossup. If ten people accuse one person of rape, odds are much better then 50/50 that they are a rapist.
50/50 odds shouldn't put someone in jail, but I sure as hell wouldn't want to ever see that person as part of my community. The personal cost of this to them is nothing, compared to, say, a felony and a decade in state prison.
- __s 10y agoI've directly known 2 people whom I believe were falsely accused of rape. Might be my region; southern Ontario. Also one did go as far as getting thrown out of court (in favor of the presumably falsely accused)
- vkou 10y agoWere they accused by multiple people, independently? Why was the case thrown out?
- __s 10y agoNot by multiple people, true. & both are completely unrelated people. Case was thrown out because the girl's story was completely inconsistent & lacked any evidence To be clear, I'm not responding about Applebaum. I don't know much about the situation, but yes, multiple accusations does imply much more than a single case. I don't know how much opportunity there was for collusion. I was responding to your assertion that rape accusation is rare. Similarly many, including myself, think Assange was victim to a smear campaign. Sex gets muddy, especially if alcohol is involved
- hackinthebochs 10y ago>The converse cost of a wrong censure are much lower then they are in the criminal case. I don't think people losing their livelihoods is significantly lower than being wrongfully imprisoned. I find them rather on par in fact.
- vkou 10y agoGetting removed from a leadership position in the TOR project is not losing your livelihood. If you're any good, you'll have little trouble getting a day job. Far more employers are willing to hire someone with a history of harassment, then they are to hire an ex-con. If worst comes to worst, there's always flipping burgers. A few years from now, most won't remember. A felony, on the other hand, will always be on your record. Losing earning potential is one thing. Losing your freedom is something entirely different.
- hackinthebochs 10y ago>If you're any good, you'll have little trouble getting a day job. This makes no sense. What you are advocating for, that extra-judicial punishment corrects for cases where judicial punishment isn't likely to occur, would equally apply to the next job he would be a candidate for. Being kicked from TOR isn't a one-off thing. His name is now permanently associated with a crime from which has had neither a fair hearing, nor any ability to defend himself. If TOR is justified in booting him without any sort of objective process, so is every subsequent company. You can't absolve yourself from the consequences of what you're advocating. >Losing earning potential is one thing. Losing your freedom is something entirely different. Not really. How free are you if you must become a low wage-slave just to survive?
- vkou 10y agoHalf this country are low wage-slaves - comparing their lives to doing a decade in prison is hyperbolic, and quite demeaning. Being a lead of a prominent public project carries with it a lot more scrutiny of your behavior then being a line code monkey in an insurance corp. And it's not like he is blackballed from making a living. Of course, if the many scathing, independent accounts of his behaviour are to be believed, he probably would have been fired long before things got to this point in any serious organization. As it turns out, he did get his day in social court - the TOR project reviewed the allegations, and found enough of them to be true to fire him. Consider the consequences of what you're advocating for. We have a prominent community figure that is accused by over a dozen people of harassment and sexual harassment (Let's leave the rape accusation out of this). And the right response it to shrug our shoulders, and say: "No conviction, no censure?" How will you get a conviction, when harassment, and sexual harassment are not crimes? What kind of behaviour would justify social censure, exactly?
- GunlogAlm 10y agoI'm not suggesting that is my standard. I'm suggesting, before declaring an individual to be a "rapist" and discussing their alleged crimes as if they were the unimpeachable truth, we ought at the very least to require something more than mere allegations. Ideally, this would of course occur in a criminal trial. What if I were to accuse you, right now, of rape – having others corroborate my story? Are you ready to accept being 'censured', being the subject of despicable verbal attack, based on the "50/50 odds" I am telling the truth? Abominable. > The converse cost of a wrong censure are much lower then they are in the criminal case I suggest you read up on the effects false sexual assault allegations have on the accused. People lose their jobs, their livelihoods, their friends. Is being falsely imprisoned worse? Yes. Much worse? No.