3 ms·
Sometimes I wonder if these groups are false flags. I know they aren't, but perhaps it is better to say they are their own parody. There are serious issues out
by noobermin 10y ago
Sometimes I wonder if these groups are false flags. I know they aren't, but perhaps it is better to say they are their own parody. There are serious issues out there, discrimination is alive and has been demonstrated in studies, statistics, etc. Garbage like this makes a mockery of the whole thing, the real hurt and issues gets mixed in with this trash and gives some people, I'm sure, solace that all of it is just a tempest in a teapot, and there are no real issues out there.
Groups and fake controversies like this distract from real issues of discrimination. They do more harm to inclusive movements than good.
- andybak 10y agoAs much as I'd like to think this is true, I don't think it's plausible. It would require a conspiracy of epic proportions. It's a flaw in human psychology that is related to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Narcissism_of_small_differences https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Narcissism_of_small_difference... Another aspect is that as that any idealistic movement is prone to being taken over by it's most intractable members. There's a game theoretic spin on it by Nicholas Taleb if I remember correctly: http://www.fooledbyrandomness.com/minority.pdf http://www.fooledbyrandomness.com/minority.pdf As the emotional tone of a debate is heightened, it's hard to argue for moderation. Anything that pushed emotional buttons forces people to the extremes and those arguing for compromise are often ridiculed by both sides. Therefore we have the phenomenon that many debates end up being between over-the-top SJWs on one side and crazy racists and Red Pill types on the other. And back in the real world, there is still indisputable injustice and discrimination that would be eminently tractable if everyone would come back down to earth. EDIT - I'd like to point out that I'm aware of a major flaw in the above - everyone - myself included regards themselves as a reasonable moderate and others as dangerous extremists. I suppose I'd be quite content to be regarded as a flakey liberal by my friends on the right and a closet imperialist by those on the left. (Except - what happens if the sample of my social group is heavily skewed and my 'left/right' is off the scale? And down the rabbit hole we go...)
- derefr 10y agoEveryone is a moderate; people reposition the callipers around their social group, defining people into and out of it, so as to always stay its most central and reasonable example.
- derefr 10y agoThe one thing I have always found is that usually, when there is an actual example of one individual who is directly hurt by someone else's prejudices, there aren't two sides to the issue: it's pretty clear to neutral observers that the prejudiced person is in the wrong. But in almost every case of people being chased up online for this sort of un-PC behavior, there are no examples of individual people who claim to have been directly hurt by them. There's just the group saying that they're "problematic" in some vague sense. If we could de-legitimize any conversation about injustices that isn't couched in concrete terms of pain caused to non-hypothetical people by non-hypothetical actions, I think there wouldn't be any "tempest" left.