7 ms·
College has been oversold (2011)
- madengr 10y agoAlmost 20x the amount of psychology majors than chemical engineering.
- Noseshine 10y agoFrom what I read on reddit, news media and HN over the years we have no shortage of chemical engineers, but we do have a severe shortage of psychiatrists and psychologists at least here in Germany. Try getting an appointment - the problem isn't the one initial test appointment itself, but that if they accept you to come in for even just that "test talk" they don't have any room for the follow-up of many sessions over many months. I think this is as one would expect: Pretty much anyone might use psychological help at some point (many different kinds exist, from "just talk" to prescribing some heavy drugs). How much need is there for chemical engineering? I've taken a few intro courses (just for fun, I'm happy in IT) so I know those guys don't just build chemical factories but also design devices like apheresis machine (great lecture, great professor: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=38kB2jTOyug https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=38kB2jTOyug). Still each machine needs to be designed only once, humans need help all the time. There should be many more psychologists than chemical or other engineers I think. One field scales much worse than the other one(s).
- jknoepfler 10y agoIn the U.S., one is required to obtain either a Ph.D. or a Psy.D to become a clinical psychologist, and can expect a salary of around $75,000/yr... the shortage of psychiatrists is probably not a function of insufficient psych majors.
- WildUtah 10y agoTO be more specific, a US college psychology major neither trains nor qualifies one for any job whatsoever in the psychiatric care field. Neither is such a major helpful in gaining admission to a trade school where one can learn to be qualified for such a profession. Psychology is simply the default major for many students that have no specific interest in studies.
- beachstartup 10y agoit sure has. but... a good (read: difficult) degree from a good school will always net you at least an interview.
- jschwartzi 10y agoWhat bothers me about this is that we're now telling 15-year olds to make decisions that they won't understand the outcome of until they're 30. If they're lucky like me then they might manage to end up in a decent career despite having a mediocre degree from a mediocre school. But life has been tremendously unfair to most of the kids I went to high school with, and it's because our high school was mediocre and our parents didn't have the money to make up for it. I shudder to think what the future will be like for my friends' kids.
- T2_t2 10y ago... which is the theme of the article! > Educated people have higher wages and lower unemployment rates than the less educated so why are college students at Occupy Wall Street protests around the country demanding forgiveness for crushing student debt? The sluggish economy is tough on everyone but the students are also learning a hard lesson, going to college is not enough. You also have to study the right subjects. And American students are not studying the fields with the greatest economic potential.
- zizzles 10y agoThere will always be disproportionate amounts of arts/media majors vs STEM majors (more so now than ever before according to this article) Not everyone is cut out to be a NASA astronaut space scientist engineering tech-guru UNIX kernel programming god. 1. There exists genetic limitations, and 2. Not everyone has an asperger-style of thinking. It should be no surprise to HN that your average human relates closer to the arts, music and perhaps sports than machine binary code.
- vollmond 10y agoHowever, we have people taking out enormous loans to get educations in non-STEM fields that have much less chance of repaying the investment financially. We as a society push everyone in every possible field towards college. Many of these could be apprenticeships, etc. There's no reason to spend tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars to learn a lot of this stuff. Even if we went back 40 years to when college was (compared to now) fairly cheap, a lot of fields wouldn't make sense in that environment.
- wolfgoatcabbage 10y agoNot sure this is true, although it appears to be the dominant perception. Programming skills bear a closer resemblance to language learning or critical thinking for many practical applications. Perhaps NASA engineers, kernel gods and lovers of binary will remain in the minority, but I wouldn't be surprised to see scripting in languages like Swift and Python become a more ubiquitous skill in the next 10 years. Even writing basic iOS apps is not beyond the range of someone with a creative writing degree.
- WildUtah 10y agoAnd what share of 18-23 year olds are capable of learning a new language or critical thinking? Darn few. But nearly all are capable of partying, drinking, casual sex, and learning to write and appreciate fine arts a little better. That's what we should be providing them with free college for.
- 10y ago
- rayiner 10y agoThis talk of free college in this election has been really upsetting to me. It's a huge waste of money and time for millions of more kids to get worthless college degrees. Nobody benefits but the professors and administrators of universities. And degree inflation creates a perverse situation for the sane people who don't want to spend four years of their life getting a college degree to be an administrative assistant. College shouldn't be the default. It should be an option society encourages only for the very few fields that require four years of dedicated academic study.
- clementangerine 10y agoThese are two separate issues, for the most part. One possible relevant benefit of free college, though, is that it removes a lot of the bad incentives in the university-student relationship. If students aren't in the paying customer role, and universities aren't so strongly incentivized to sell as many degrees as possible, it's a lot easier to enforce strict academic standards. So it could actually improve the degree inflation situation.
- dilemma 10y agoColleges are still going to be rated and paid based on some measure, likely completion rates for courses and degrees. Then you get the situation where the education in the country's best technical university is a joke also known as teach to the test.
- mto 10y agoI live in Vienna an this is not the case here. Problem is the other way round (currently, is under discussion) - Universities just get a fixed amount of money. So they try to restrict the number of students by themselves, using different methods to get rid of them. But all in all, I think it worked out pretty well in the past - no tuition, free access and lectures are public anyway. So everyone gets a chance to try it, most drop out in the first year, probably changing field of study once or twice. But as we don't have that minor/major stuff but the curricula are extremely specialized, this is probably not bad for widening the horizon. Still better than arbitrary tests or the weird numerus clausus in Germany. I don't think that an university degree should be mandatory for everyone (we have a lot of specialized schools as an alternative), but it's good if the option to try it is there.
- alexmat 10y agoFor 1,000 years, parents have bought B.A. degrees for their kids as positional goods: "My son, the college man." But a B.A. no longer provides positional status. There are too many people who possess one. Certification protects many careers: barrier to entry. It does not provide entrepreneurial skills. It provides bureaucratic skills. These will be worth less and less in the digital age.
- WildUtah 10y agoEvidence says that bureaucratic skills have become more and more valuable in the digital age. Fewer and fewer good jobs are available for qualified skilled people and more and more reward licenses, certifications, and connections.
- alexmat 10y agoAs long as government spending and subsides are able to sustain them.
- tiptop 10y agoPeople keep missing the fact that 'liberal arts' is just free money for colleges and helps fund for the labs and science majors.
- CN7R 10y agoYes, but how much of that money is actually going towards funding STEM education in colleges. Isn't a large part of why tuition has increased in the past decade is due to expanding (unnecessary) amenities and administrators?
- munin 10y agono, the labs and science majors are funded by their own students and grants the science professors win. the "liberal arts" is just free money for colleges and goes into their endowment.