4 ms·
The pilot was operating on the assumption that the people he fired upon were militants. Think about it; you shoot at armed militants. Minutes later an unmarke
by sliverstorm 17y ago
The pilot was operating on the assumption that the people he fired upon were militants. Think about it; you shoot at armed militants. Minutes later an unmarked van with some unmarked men pulls up, and they jump out and start loading the wounded. Does the van hold civilians? Y/N.
- gort 17y agoSome unarmed unmarked men. You must assume Y. You can't just start shooting on the balance of probabilities. It might be forgivable if there was some imminent danger to... somebody. But I'm not seeing that.
- Jeema3000 17y agoDoesn't matter. You aren't allowed to shoot wounded combatants who are out of the action.
- philwelch 17y agoAccording to the relevant parts of international law, it doesn't matter if they're uniformed military--if they're unarmed and loading wounded into a vehicle for medevac, you let them go.
- sliverstorm 17y agoMy point is not that the killing was just. I was just objecting to where the parent suggests the pilot opened fire on civilians knowingly.
- philwelch 17y agoYou're correct in that, but civilian or not is a technicality, not the issue.
- patrickk 17y agoThere was a little girl in the van. I guess shes an insurgent too