2 ms·
I pondered this exact thing, but came to the thought that you actually are talking about multiple people. "As long as they give a good talk" - you're not talki
by madeofpalk 10y ago
I pondered this exact thing, but came to the thought that you actually are talking about multiple people.
"As long as they give a good talk" - you're not talking about one specific person but in fact a general population of speakers.
- mpweiher 10y agoOriginal was: "problems a speaker at a conference might have, as long as he gives a good talk/presentation." The pronoun refers to "speaker", singular, yet indefinite, we don't necessarily know who it is. Let's substitute "they: "problems a speaker at a conference might have, as long as they give a good talk/presentation." Yep, works for me, but I think the "they" definitely talks about about that single (if indefinite) speaker. Yet we use the plural of the verb ("give"), so the sentence is confused, grammatically. I wonder what will give as this evolves, whether "they gives" becomes acceptable or we simple leave "they" grammatically plural even when it is semantically singular. Language. Fun times!