10 ms·
Employers Find ‘Soft Skills’ Like Critical Thinking in Short Supply
- Havoc 10y agoStrange - I usually associate "soft skills" more with leadership, people skills etc. And yeah they are in short supply because you can't teach them directly. The employees sorta need to pick them up from experience.
- totalcrepe 10y ago> And yeah they are in short supply because you can't teach them directly. If you can think critically are you going to get past the HR filters and convince them you are the recruit willing to take a deal that will descend into just a little worse than unemployment? (So your empty shell of a life after they spit you out is devoid of any unused benefits.) If you want to openly think critically in corporate employment, step 1 is becoming irreplaceable so they can't replace you when you become inconvenient at step 2. An easier tactic, (employed by the best corporate game theorists that I've encountered) is following directions like a total Svejk, this leads employers to think you lack critical thinking skills. Then more resources are allocated and eventually you have a whole empire of minions.
- dasmoth 10y ago>>> If you want to openly think critically in corporate employment, step 1 is becoming irreplaceable so they can't replace you when you become inconvenient at step 2. Hence all the worry about "bus factors"
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- angry_octet 10y ago> step 1 is becoming irreplaceable so they can't replace you when you become inconvenient It is a hard lesson, but no-one is irreplaceable. Even if it means an entire product/group fails, if you are inconvenient you are gone. Organisations are not rational actors. > following directions like a total Svejk I love that book. It would be nice to seen a version in a corporate setting. Instead of a war it could be some behemoth company doing a massive pivot to the cloud, rewriting every bit of business logic in ruby, etc, and its lowly minion who is forever avoiding work with mandatory training courses, and who never pays for lunch because they appear at the smallest meeting which has corporate catering.
- Edmond 10y agoIndeed, quite odd to describe "soft skill" as critical thinking skills, ie cognitive skills. soft skill typically is social skill, the type of nebulous skill that while it may have value leaves huge room to interpretation.
- curiousgal 10y agoThe way I see it, critical thinking has a social aspect because an individual has to communicate those thoughts, or else how would we know they're critically thinking?
- aqwfgm 10y agoThe way you see it, you could put there physics, engineering or any other hard skill just because you have to communicate what you've learned.
- KirinDave 10y ago> And yeah they are in short supply because you can't teach them directly. Why can't you teach them directly?
- VLM 10y agoWhat we define as "teach" in the west is specifically designed to produce and select interchangeable factory drones with no social skills or creativity. Consider the K12 stereotype of filling out arithmetic worksheets or conjugation of foreign language verbs. Then we stack rank the kids by obedience to authority which usually anti-correlates with creativity and social skills to determine their educational path, and eventually give the "winners" jobs where their management are confused why they have no social skills and no creativity. Imagine a classroom of employees head down silently circling multiple choice worksheets "circle the correct two characteristics of creativity in each set". That's how we'd "teach". Even worse, we'd probably pick the class teachers by who did the best on the last generation of social skills worksheets. Meanwhile the creative or socially skilled are going to tend to not have corporate jobs. Or they'll demand more than minimal money.
- Havoc 10y ago>Why can't you teach them directly? For the same reason that you can't learn riding a bicycle from a book.
- KirinDave 10y agoFunnily enough, this along with failure is exactly how my learned. My family was not exactly "present" to help. Libraries have books with that very title.
- nmstoker 10y agoThis is purely anecdotal, but I've seen a shift in behaviour where even people with these soft skills appear less willing to take the risk of using them. Too much focus of "must look like I'm working hard", so rush things through without sense checking and that type of thing. Getting away with it often then means it becomes a way of working so the skills don't develop and people (one assumes) hope for the best in regards to getting caught!
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- nerdponx 10y agoObviously we need more STEM funding. Music, humanities, and sports have never improved anyone's critical thinking skills and personality traits.
- homarp 10y agoInteresting to compare to the "Math Myth" (previous discussion https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12418788 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12418788 )
- guitarbill 10y agoThank god the Wall Street Journal is encouraging critical thinking, and more importantly fostering the discussion by putting articles like this out for everybody to read /s On a more serious note, I don't believe this is true. In every place I've been, school, university, corporate jobs, the "critical thinkers" always got marginalised. This was the case even if they were truly nice people who cared - i.e. not abrasive and argumentative, just different. This is often called "difficult", because most managers and HR can't be bothered to actually engage with that person. So isn't that people can't do it, just the lesson is "you're better off if you don't say it". Political correctness also doesn't help IMO. I feel like one of my favorite Mitchell and Webb sketches, "Kill the poor", describes this quite well: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=owI7DOeO_yg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=owI7DOeO_yg
- empath75 10y agoDon't mistake being a contrarian with being a critical thinker.
- maehwasu 10y agoTotally agree, and I would add that critical thinking leads quickly to positions that are not generally accepted.
- guitarbill 10y agoThat was the point I was trying to make when I said "not abrasive and argumentative, just different". Maybe I should have said different perspective. Incidentally, I find working with people with different perspectives hugely helpful when problem solving, although you can see how vastly different perspectives can also cause problems in understanding. I suspect there's a sweet spot, depending on your role/company/environment.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- gameshot911 10y ago
- dgax 10y agoThe article, especially some of the examples, seems abusive to low-wage employees. How many of us would give a job description that said 'this is not a preparation for a slow motion contest' a second glance? The meat and potatoes of the article is mostly just complaints to be honest. A lack of candidates is always the go-to excuse for managers and executives when explaining poor productivity or vacancies. Job seekers will gladly tell you that the pay stinks or that they just flat out don't want to work for a company. Dig deeper and ask the managers and executives to show how they reward and retain employees with these skills.
- ReallyAnonymous 10y agoI work for a >10,000 employee health care system as a physician. What I have seen is that the front line workers are considered disposable, and should be grateful for a job. The superstars ( always nice, compassionate, and excellent at their jobs) are not recognized by management and so when raises are given, everyone gets them, including the lazy ones. This disappoints the worker bees, and leads to incredible turnover and more frustration for us physicians. Unfortunately, a lot of the attributes of a great employee cannot be quantified on a spreadsheet so the MBAs running my organization have no clue how to compensate people. Instead, they just lump everyone in the same pile so the workers get frustrated bc they work twice as hard as the lazies, but make the same amount. I've tried to talk to executives about this, but I think it's essentially to deaf ears - bottom line is the most important, so they can get their bonuses. It leads to disenchantment and then, over many years, inability to get hardworking / intelligent people to enter front line professions. Smart people will recognize that their hard work will never be acknowledged, so they switch careers. Others, who cannot get jobs elsewhere, or pivot, are stuck working there. Not sure what the solution is, but it's just an observation.
- zigzigzag 10y agoIs the issue unionisation? It sounds like the answer is no. The solution is probably to switch to a competitor that does set pay levels individually. In the event that there are none, perhaps take a leap and set up a competitor that does? If it's as big a problem as you say, presumably lots of talented physicians would beat a path to your door.
- Inthenameofmine 10y agoI'm an employer myself, buy frankly the same can be said about most other employers. Critical thinking seems to be in short supply there as well.
- mannykannot 10y agoThere seems to be a trend in management towards an unwarranted belief in the effectiveness and importance of superficial quantitative analysis, and two complementary myths that go along with the trend: a) any number you can assign to something is significant; b) anything you cannot assign a number to is not significant. Anyone approaching recruiting with this mindset is neither using critical thinking, nor likely to hire people who can.
- dilemma 10y agoWhat gets measured gets managed.
- keithpeter 10y agoAnd often there are titanic struggles to manage noise. I mean changes of 1% with sample sizes of 200 or so (education). I especially cherish 'business systems' that produce percentages accurate to two decimal places.
- sixdimensional 10y agoIt's almost as if we have regressed in some ways to the "principles of scientific management" (Frederick Winslow Taylor) with our focus on quantitative over qualitative (and not balanced between the two).
- angry_octet 10y agoThere has been an uptick in user of discredited techniques to screen in recruitment, stuff like MBTI (Myers-Briggs Type Indicator), lots of pseudo science without measuring validity. It seems like HR have been told to find people with soft skills and so they manufacture something that will give a rating and then rank candidates by that.
- naveen99 10y ago> mbti discredited Do you have any good citations? A majority of hacker news readers are INTJ and intp, 2 types that generally find mbti useful in understanding themselves and others. I doubt hr puts much stock in mbti anyway, because it would be an easy test to game if it was officially considered.
- maehwasu 10y agoIt turns out that enforcing political correctness has costs.
- walterbell 10y agoSee Isaac Asimov's classic science fiction story about education, "Profession", featuring the "House for the Feeble Minded", http://www.inf.ufpr.br/renato/profession.html http://www.inf.ufpr.br/renato/profession.html "For most of the first eighteen years of his life, George Platen had headed firmly in one direction, that of Registered Computer Programmer. There were those in his crowd who spoke wisely of Spationautics, Refrigeration Technology, Transportation Control, and even Administration. But George held firm. He argued relative merits as vigorously as any of them, and why not? Education Day loomed ahead of them and was the great fact of their existence. It approached steadily, as fixed and certain as the calendar – the first day of November of the year following one’s eighteenth birthday. After that day, there were other topics of conversation."
- imron 10y agoOne of my favourite Asimov short stories.
- joshkpeterson 10y agoThis is what happens when you tout STEM, STEM, STEM in education. We should be asking, STEM at the cost of what? What are we giving up in order to give STEM that extra time?
- ftio 10y agoI think this is a dangerous and fruitless line of reasoning. It halts the conversation. It makes it harder for management to be introspective. If you look at critical or creative thinking as an inherent skill [1] rather than as a measurable outcome of the right kind of environment and incentives, how can you create and improve a workplace in which your people think critically? [2] I find that bad managers sometimes use the 'lacks critical thinking' criticism as an out for their own ineffectiveness. It's certainly not wrong for managers to delegate, to expect a high level of performance from their employees, to ask for creativity and mental agility in the face of a respectful amount of uncertainty. But when you combine vague goals and sparse planning with ego, bad managers wrongly attribute an employee's failure to correctly 'guess their will' to poor critical thinking skills. It's natural for managers (myself included) to go into self-preservation mode when they've failed to give their employees enough direction, but the reality is that it's a relationship. There is, and there should be, push and pull. Sometimes the manager doesn't give enough direction or doesn't plan well. Sometimes the employee does some lazy thinking. Each needs to have enough humility and honesty to say, "I screwed up. How do we solve this and what can we do better in the future?" If you want to make every decision from the top so that your employees never have to divine your will, you better be a planning savant. If you're a mortal like the rest of us, you need to figure out how to give your people just enough guidance to do their best work, and sometimes that means admitting you haven't given enough. 1. It may be inherent, but that's kind of beside the point. Wouldn't you want to keep the door open to improvement anyway? 2. Actually, the only way to do it is addressed in the article: search for 'critical thinkers,' whatever that means to you, in your hiring process.
- bdob4xcfH 10y ago> It's natural for managers (myself included) to go into self-preservation mode when they've failed to give their employees enough direction, but the reality is that it's a relationship. It is for people who's #1 priority is themselves and not the team or the company at large, and doing the right thing.
- programminggeek 10y agoEmployers don't want critical thinking, they want compliance and results. They might say they want more soft skills, but what they mean is they want someone to solve their problems and make them look good. Usually, that means a yes man. This kind of article is delusional naval gazing.
- KirinDave 10y agoSurprising talk on a forum dedicated to startup capitalism. Culturally, this forum is aligned towards BEING the employers.
- programminggeek 10y ago90% of the people on this forum will never start a startup or possibly even work at a startup.
- MichaelMoser123 10y agoI think it is great that this question is asked by the wsj. Unfortunately the article is behind a paywall. Can someone with access please summarize the article?
- xpac 10y agoGoogle the headline, click link from Google results, see paywall disappear. At least worked for me ;)
- snarfy 10y agoIt doesn't work for me on mobile. I'm not sure why pay walled links continue to be posted to HN. They should be banned.
- rzzzt 10y agoThe small link titled "web" under the header does this for you: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10223645 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10223645
- ThomPete 10y agoIt is not my experience that we are lacking critical thinking, what we are lacking is creative / constructive thinking. There are plenty of great critical thinkers out there. The real challenge is to figure out the next step. Thats' what entrepreneurs do.
- walshemj 10y agoPresentism in 99% of cases what employers say they want and what they actually want are quite different.
- jschwartzi 10y agoAnd when they say they want "critical thinkers" what they mean is that they want people who can criticize their coworkers while thoughtfully praising their managers' foresight.
- curiousgal 10y agoDo the personality tests most companies rely on during the hiring process even account for critical thinking?
- analog31 10y agoIntelligence testing is considered to be illegal. On the other hand, figuring out how to game a personality test is, in a sense, a test of critical thinking
- wolfgke 10y ago> On the other hand, figuring out how to game a personality test is, in a sense, a test of critical thinking Rather not applying at companies that use scientifically-unfounded personality tests is a test of critical thinking.
- rhizome 10y agoAs much as any other form of astrology.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- gens 10y agoFunny, i also find critical thinking in short supply.
- JoshTko 10y agoI work for a fortune 100 and critical thinking is highly valued on my team. One thing that I've observed is that expressing critical thinking without communication skill comes across as being argumentative. If you find yourself frequently arguing a point but no one is convinced, assuming you are actually correct on the issue, then you probably just have weak communication skills.
- Glyptodon 10y agoAnother thing I've noticed is that no matter how compelling the argument it's also near impossible to get people to take action to change things that are deeply entrenched even if they agree with you.
- KirinDave 10y agoI have seen this too. I have a theory about it. Most organizations only recognize negative intercessions as praiseworthy, and categorize positive intercession as "business as usual" to be expected, even if sometimes the positive intercession is much harder. "No!" moments are much valued in corporate culture these days. People think this promotes the propagation of critical thinking across an organization. Perhaps ironically, the opposite is true. By tuning everyone to say, "No!" and rewarding them as such, it actually limits the impact of the actual important "No!" moments because everyone is competing for these accolades. Most corporate culture does not reward people for following orders or improving upon someone else's idea. It's a legacy of the strict hierarchy all our organizations descend from (or a consequence of the apathy that more modern "matrixed" organizations breeds in its mid-grade baseline employees, who are taught not to overly invest in a given project).
- angry_octet 10y agoMy experience is mostly in the other direction. While C-level executives out of their depth (which seems to be most of the time when it comes to technology) tend to have quite a few 'No!' moments, maybe because it gives them a sense of control, they don't like hearing No from anyone else. In fact, expressing doubts about the wisdom of pushing ahead with a project, even one already failing, is seen as very poor behaviour, like you have just farted in front of everyone. Likewise, identifying risks is often seen as negativity, rather than a foundation principle of review. People who subsequently roll out one of these failed ideas are often publicly rewarded. In contrast, the people who develop the alternate system that is actually used tend to be ignored.
- whybroke 10y agoIf we're relying on all critical thinking skills to come as an unstated side effect of teaching math and elementary science that is sometimes taught alongside creationism then the results are obviously going to be watery. If on the other hand students were taught just a few formal fallacies and led to analyze just a few arguments and just touched on formal logic while in high school, the nation would be transformed (but I imagine the flyover states would yell bloody murder)
- neurotech1 10y agoOne of the classic examples was Joe Sutter[0]. He was the Boeing 747 program lead & engineer who sadly died a few days ago. Boeing management was putting pressure to cut 1,000 engineers from the program. He knew that would cause the program to fail, and he really needed 1,000 more engineers. He thought he was going to get fired that day, but still said what he believed. The 747 became one of the most successful airliners in history. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joe_Sutter https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joe_Sutter
- rodgerd 10y agoFor my entire I've been listening to organisations purporting to represent employers slag of the education system for not being sufficiently vocationally-focused - for not just eternally chasing a narrow range of whatever skills will turn out good little technicians at no cost to employers - while denigrating anything outside that narrow focus as basket-weaving. And the political landscape in the English-speaking world has largely gone along with that. They have what they asked for. Whoops.
- davidf18 10y agoGenerally a firm can get workers if they are willing to locate in an area that the workers want to live, that they treat the workers well, and that they offer above market rates in salary. But, even wealthy firms such as Apple and Google which both have huge profits have conspired to keep engineering and technical wage rates low. There was recently a settlement for the collusion. It had nothing to do with the amount of money the firms had or could spend for talent, just that they wanted to keep the costs down. So, generally be suspect of these kinds of articles.
- thr0waway1239 10y agoI agree with the following commenter that critical thinking is not a soft skill. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12426545 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12426545 Definition from Wikipedia: "The Collins English Dictionary defines the term "soft skills" as “desirable qualities for certain forms of employment that do not depend on acquired knowledge: they include common sense, the ability to deal with people, and a positive flexible attitude.”" from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soft_skills https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soft_skills I think economics is an important part of thinking critically. Does philanthropy do more good than bad? Does affirmative action always get the desired results? Does equality of opportunity lead to equality of outcome? What should be the role of government and how to fund it? My views on a lot of subjects changed after getting just a rudimentary understanding of economics. While I cannot claim I am a very critical thinker, I am probably a more critical thinker after I learnt economics. And in my view, economics is more science than non-science, and you can grasp it better with more acquired knowledge.