5 ms·
What is the point in this exactly? FLAC is useful for selling lossless audio, so you'd be able to re-encode it into any other codec when needed. But to play som
by shmerl 10y ago
What is the point in this exactly? FLAC is useful for selling lossless audio, so you'd be able to re-encode it into any other codec when needed. But to play something on-line (which browser support implies), you can as well use lossy codec like Opus at transparent bitrate, and save the traffic in the process.
That said, it surely doesn't hurt to have that support in the browser, I just don't see it being very useful.
- joobus 10y agoFLAC is useful for listening to high quality music which hasn't been filtered and compressed. It sounds significantly better than lossy audio. Iscit so hard to comprehend that as more bandwidth comes online all the time, people won't want to compromise on sound quality the way they were forced to in the past?
- shmerl 10y ago> FLAC is useful for listening to high quality music which hasn't been filtered and compressed. It sounds significantly better than lossy audio. Doubtful. See https://people.xiph.org/~xiphmont/demo/neil-young.html https://people.xiph.org/~xiphmont/demo/neil-young.html TL;DR: encode above transparency level when using the lossy codec, and it won't have audible difference with lossless playback. But again, that's only for playback. As soon as you'd want to re-encode anything, there is no substitute for the lossless original.
- Noseshine 10y agoI can't for the live of me think of a phrase that gives me Google search results even remotely related to the topic, but I am pretty sure I once found a study that said that consciously inaudible differences in audio due to compression still made a difference - subjects who got the compressed sounds tired more quickly (of hearing them). Having taken a bit of neuroscience I can easily accept that - but I did not take enough (ns) to say for sure that it is so. I can easily accept that merely asking people about anything is not actually objective, it needs more credulity to believe my claim that even people in a blind test who can't tell the difference between two songs (lossless vs. compressed), which is more objective than just asking about qualitative measures, is not a reliable way to determine the question of "lossless vs. compressed". So could anyone confirm or deny such a study and the mechanism exists from a basis of actual knowledge?
- shmerl 10y agoThat falls into some speculation area, unless actually substantiated with serious studies. I'd be interested in it, if you can find a source. There are too many hoaxes going regarding audio, to be skeptical enough. Here is one read on this: http://www.skeptic.com/eskeptic/10-01-06/ http://www.skeptic.com/eskeptic/10-01-06/
- Noseshine 10y ago> That falls into some speculation area, unless actually substantiated with serious studies. I made that quite clear, and I asked for the latter in the prominently placed last sentence. It's the main point of my post, as I think I made clear. I really don't know what more I could/should have done apart from dropping the question entirely, which I don't think is fair - or useful?
- shmerl 10y agoYou said you saw some study, but can't find it now. I guess if it's a known issue, it will come up eventually.
- tmnvix 10y agoThis sounds familiar. It brings a few things to mind. I can't remember the term that was used, but I remember reading about audible frequencies possibly being affected by inaudible frequencies in ways that are perceptible to humans. So if you have two source files played using the same equipment with one including the inaudible frequencies then they will sound subtly different due to the interaction. With the 'getting tired' while listening thing, I know just what you mean. Listening to music on a laptop for instance is a mentally draining experience for me. I've heard it explained like this: your brain knows what a piano sounds like and when it hears the poor imitation it is busy 'filling in the blanks'. Listening on good equipment is much more relaxing - as is listening to something that isn't 128kbps. I don't claim to know that either of the above are true, but to me they are plausible. I'm also a little sceptical of the 'lossless is no better than good lossy' claims that inevitably come up in these discussions. While I accept that there is likely a point that audible differences between lossy and lossless would be imperceptible, I've been hearing those claims for a long time (starting with "it's digital - it's cd quality'). When I was seriously interested in these things there most definitely was a noticeable difference. I was right about 128kbps. I'm confidant I was right about 256kbps. Maybe with 320kbps that's changed now, but I don't know as I haven't had a decent stereo for some time. I'm not about to be convinced by those blind test studies that people keep pointing to as objective and conclusive - they always make me think of that one where it was 'proved' that cheap wine is just as 'good' as expensive wine. I'll stick to lossless when possible and compress to lossy when necessary. Can't go wrong like that!
- mbrock 10y agoThat article is almost entirely about how it's useless to encode audio at excessive sample rates and bit rates beyond the human ear's capacities—not about lossy compression. It does claim that modern lossy compressors are good enough, but admits that there can be reason to prefer lossless distribution since there is then no need to trust the distributor to use a good encoder with correct settings.
- shmerl 10y agoYes. The point is not about that distributor can fail to use a good encoder (anything can happen), but that they can use a good one if they want to, and audible result will be the same as lossless. When I buy music, I always try to buy it in lossless FLACs anyway. And then I encode it to Opus for playback. But for listening to something on-line, Opus would do just fine to begin with.
- sjwright 10y ago> It sounds significantly better than lossy audio. Lossy audio can be completely transparent. If you disagree, you need to provide some objective evidence, because all objective evidence points in favour of good lossy compression being indistinguishable from lossless at sensible bitrates. Look, I've no problem with LAME being supported, but don't make it out to be "significant" in terms of sound quality. Try AAC at 256kbps (what iTunes Store has used for the past decade) or better yet, Opus. Do a serious blinded test and amaze yourself with the results.
- nsns 10y agoIt all depends on how sensitive you are to these things, I've done such blind tests, and to my ears the fall in quality was significant, even painful.
- stdbrouw 10y agoBlind tests comparing lossless against what codec at what bitrate? How many runs and how often were you able to correctly identify lossless?
- themihai 10y agoWhy to bother with various tradeoffs if you can get the best?(i.e lossless). You can make the same argument on video technologies(i.e HDR). The truth is that people usually adapt so "painful" audio or video quality stops being painful after a while.
- themihai 10y agoOn decent speakers you can definitely hear the difference when you switch from a lossless to a lossy format. The blind tests may be confusing if you switch between the formats repeatedly in a short period of time but if you listen lossless audio for a long time and then you suddenly switch to a lossy format you can definitely sense the difference.
- JonnieCache 10y agoAre you positive you can tell the way the difference is going, even (especially) after a long time listening?
- themihai 10y agoWell, the very first day when I switched from Tidal HD to Apple music I could sense the difference. The interesting part is that I didn't really expect any difference because at that time I thought Apple is using a lossless codec too(ALAC) so that made me google it and I've found they are actually using AAC thus the reason why I think there is a noticeable difference. Now I'm still listening lossy audio because for some reasons I decided to cancel the Tidal subscription. I can't say the difference is really like between SD and HD video so you don't miss much but if you get used with lossless audio chances are that you can sense the difference when you switch to a lossy version.
- rakoo 10y agoI imagine now a music store can sell FLAC-only music tracks, and provide FLAC-only stream previews. No need to re-encode anything.
- shmerl 10y agoThat makes some sense, yes. But so far I didn't see any stores which sell only FLACs.
- rakoo 10y agoThat's a chicken and egg problem; if the store only provides FLAC, the browser can't play it, so the potential customers can't try it, so they don't buy it, so the store has to provide non-FLAC alternatives, so there is no need to provide FLAC decoding in the browser, etc... Somebody has to make the first step, and I'm happy Firefox did this. Bandcamp is one of the few stores that does sell FLAC, maybe they'll be the one going that direction.
- pimeys 10y agoHardwax[1] is selling aiff, which can be packed into flac. No metadata though, which is kind of a bummer. Beatport[2] offers wav and aiff as well. [1] https://hardwax.com/ https://hardwax.com/ [2] https://www.beatport.com/ https://www.beatport.com/
- rakoo 10y agoAnother possibility: online libraries, such as archive.org, could store FLAC only to save space and still provide in-browser streaming.
- Joona 10y agoMy music collection is all in FLAC, and encoding it again would be a waste of space and/or resources. Streaming FLAC is completely fine for me, as I don't have bandwidth caps or such. I can see myself building a streaming service for myself to listen to my collection while I'm on the move.
- shmerl 10y ago> My music collection is all in FLAC, and encoding it again would be a waste of space and/or resources. Why so? My collection is also in FLAC, but I always encode it in Opus for actual playback. Hard drive space is cheap, but FLAC will bloat your mobile storage. So the same rule applies. For playback Opus works perfectly. For encoding - FLAC is required.
- stordoff 10y agoIt depends what your needs are. I only even listen to my collection of music from my NAS via (W)LAN connected devices, so maintaining a version more suited to mobile devices isn't necessary or useful to me.
- shmerl 10y agoYes, of course. I like using portable players, so FLAC is counter productive there. I see no point in streaming anything if you can just put files on your player and not depend on any connection.
- Joona 10y ago> I see no point in streaming anything if you can just put files on your player and not depend on any connection. Sure, if that works for you, but my collection is too big to fit on my mobile device (even after encoding it in Opus instead of FLAC). I suppose my use case is rather rare, but even then, why not give the ability?