7 ms·
There is no mention of installing a sturdy beam across the road slightly lower than the least clearance, just a suggestion that the least clearance should be re
by mannykannot 10y ago
There is no mention of installing a sturdy beam across the road slightly lower than the least clearance, just a suggestion that the least clearance should be reported, and an extended discussion of the multiple (and rather unsurprising, IMHO) ways in which the pilot car system failed.
I am reminded of the half-assed measures that were taken to mitigate the risk of DC10 cargo doors blowing open, prior to the Turkish Airlines crash in Paris. Am I missing something here?
- maxerickson 10y agoIt isn't really that terrible an idea for the owner of the bridge to allow vehicles across that will only fit in the center lanes. They just need to make sure that the drivers understand that the height limit is lower in the outer lanes.
- revelation 10y agomake sure that the drivers understand Yeah, right. https://www.youtube.com/c/yovo68 https://www.youtube.com/c/yovo68
- ars 10y agoThat sign is horrible! It's like it was designed to be utterly useless. "Overheight must turn" means to virtually all "IF you are Overheight you must turn". Obviously that driver doesn't think he is overheight. Change it to "Warning: Overheight truck detected in this lane" (with proper lights/arrows pointing to lane). And blink red as well.
- vt240 10y agoI wonder if they focus grouped the signage ? To me it seemed clear, but now that you point it out... I see where the confusion could happen!
- ars 10y agoThe positioning of the sign doesn't help - so high up. Who looks up that high when driving? The truck driver doesn't realize the sign is only on when he is there, he never sees it when it's off, he has no idea it's illuminated specially for him. This is government saying "We did something", while doing nothing.
- Symbiote 10y agoEveryone looks that high, because the traffic lights are there.
- ars 10y agoNo, people glance up high to look at a color, and that's about it. And this sign is above even the traffic lights. Even someone glancing at the colors would not see this. What they should do is lower the sign to the height of the bridge - so people hit the sign (or something dangling from it). But that would require government admitting that people hitting the bridge is their fault, and not stupid drivers.
- maxerickson 10y agoWashington publishes locations with low clearance: http://www.wsdot.wa.gov/data/tools/bridgeclearance/ http://www.wsdot.wa.gov/data/tools/bridgeclearance/ Someone driving an oversize load can reasonably be expected to check their route for clearance. It's not the same situation as some guy trying to find Taco Bell in his RV.
- sverige 10y agoI-25 in Denver near 20th St. and 23rd Ave. has clear indications painted on the bridges and the signage before the bridges indicating lower clearance on the shoulders. It's not that hard to do. NYC takes the cake for inaccurate bridge height signs, though. Some bridges have signs indicating 12'9" or lower clearance when standard 13'6" trucks can clear them easily. It's a complete mystery why they can't mark them correctly. It's been this way for decades (literally).
- tombrossman 10y agoI got burned by this in upstate New York and it caused an unnecessarily long delay. I was following the directions provided by the customer and came across a 12'6" marked bridge towing a 13'6" trailer on a narrow two-lane highway. I stopped, obviously, and had to ring the highway patrol for help. Traffic behind me was stuck waiting and this low clearance bridge was not properly marked in the trucker atlas and (if it had truly been 12'6") not up to spec for a state highway overpass. I'd done my due diligence so this was the highway patrol or customer's problem to sort out. About an hour and a half later, we established that the road had been recently re-paved and no one was exactly sure what the height was. Backing up to the nearest intersection was not an option because there were none close by and turning the tractor-trailer around was impossible. The cops were cool about it and suggested that I creep forward very slowly and see if I'd fit. I was able to do this and stop just as the trailer reached the bridge. I got out of the cab and climbed up behind the tractor to have a peek and had about an inch to spare. I went for it, very slowly, and made it under. No fun but I did get a cool photo as a memento: http://i.imgur.com/64uYu2z.jpg http://i.imgur.com/64uYu2z.jpg I took a different route on the way back of course!
- caf 10y agoWould it have helped to deflate the tyres on the trailer a bit?
- tombrossman 10y agoNo, this is not practical and you risk damaging the tires. It is possible to deflate the air ride suspension for the tractor drive axles to drop a few inches (useful for backing under a new trailer when the nose is low) but I did not do this because the rear of the trailer would still be too high.
- ubernostrum 10y agoSadly, there's not much that can be done to fix humans. The elevenfooteight bridge now has a traffic light which goes red and stays red on detecting an overheight vehicle, with a lit-up sign saying "OVERHEIGHT MUST TURN". It's still getting hit by overheight vehicles. And then there's the lengths that had to be gone to in Syndey to stop overheight vehicles entering tunnels: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NoTMC-uxJoo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NoTMC-uxJoo
- vanattab 10y agoThat water curtain stop sign is brilliant.
- Terr_ 10y agoThe next best thing to holo-signs: A visual barrier, but won't actually harm you if you hit it.
- vl 10y agoBrilliant, but unfortunately increases stopping distance.
- tombrossman 10y agoThe water is right at the tunnel entrance, not in the area where you would be braking to avoid impact. By the time you've reached the water you will have collided with the top of the tunnel, which should go a long way towards helping you slow down. Literally 'idiot proof' design right there.
- mikeash 10y agoIt depends on what you want to fix. The 11'8 bridge does indeed seem a lost cause as far as preventing people from ruining their overheight vehicles. But the problem for the bridge has been solved: they installed a beam in front of the bridge which takes the impact. The same sort of thing could be done with this bridge. Install a sturdy beam ahead of the structural bits. You won't stop people from driving overheight vehicles onto the bridge, but you will stop them from destroying the bridge in the process.
- ghshephard 10y agoSturdy beam is a great idea. Better to rip off the top of the Truck, and maybe give one driver whiplash, than to take down an entire bridge. Surprised it isn't the default case where bridges are at risk.
- llukas 10y agoWhy sturdy beam? Beam on chains so it can be pushed away by truck but do loung enough BANG to attract drivers attention should suffice?
- Symbiote 10y agoIt depends what the risk is. Chains followed by a beam are probably better, but the driver was already not paying attention when they passed warning signs. If the bridge collapses, other vehicles can be damaged, or people killed. Especially if it's carrying a road or railway. Example from last week: http://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-kent-37207487 http://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-kent-37207487
- leoc 10y agoI can't find the article now, but there was a state somewhere in the southern US which had great success in reducing bridge strikes by setting a row of cowbells. It seems that the sound of many cowbells suddenly hitting the front of a moving truck can really get your attention.
- ghshephard 10y agoMaybe do both. But the idea of the Sturdy Beam is that it's about 500 milliseconds away from a structure which will collapse if hit - after all of the warnings by the drivers have been ignored.
- douche 10y agoThere's a low underpass beneath a railway track near my house that claims at least one panel truck a month (usually beer trucks). It's an old rail line, and the underpass arch is faced with granite. The trucks don't win.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]