3 ms·
Part of it is, I think, subreddits tend to get very narrowly defined—as you mentioned, programming, entrepreneurship, academic news, etc. Whereas HN is program
by mcphage 10y ago
Part of it is, I think, subreddits tend to get very narrowly defined—as you mentioned, programming, entrepreneurship, academic news, etc. Whereas HN is programming+entrepreneurship+academic news. So rather than different communities for each discussion, you get a broader community that can discuss a number of things. Reddit could have such a subreddit, but generally that's not how Redditors do things.
A second is, I think, that you get abilities more slowly. You can't downvote comments until, what, 500 karma? Rather than it being easy to make sockpuppets to downvote a group you dislike.
A third is, HN is a lot smaller. Much lower traffic, it's more out-of-the-way, so it has more adults discussing their jobs. And there are fewer random passers-by who already have commenting, upvoting, and downvoting rights—able to interrupt the community without needing to actually be a part of it.
And a fourth is, HN is pretty well moderated. That's definitely a good thing when trying to maintain your signal-to-noise ratio.