10 ms·
Inside the Federal Bureau of Way Too Many Guns
- Someone 10y ago"He has to have the files printed out, and then the ladies take pictures of them and store them that way. Anything that allows people to search by name is verboten." If that is the only issue, I would construct a database that maps (gun type, serial number) to physical location ((microfiche, page, row) or (binder, page, row)). That should speed up look ups by (gun type, serial number) tremendously, but still would require one to go through all physical data to search by name.
- pjc50 10y ago> I would construct a database .. and that's how you get thousands of armed protestors demanding that your organisation be shut down and your records destroyed. It doesn't matter what the proposed contents of the database are. The politics is extremely volatile and not very rational. (Even the IRA were finally persuaded to put their weapons "permanently beyond use", in the language of the peace agreement.)
- DamnYuppie 10y agoYes it is very political, but I disagree that it isn't rational. The stance is that registration leads to confiscation. This has been proven time and time again. And no we don't want to be like some countries that have registrations and you have to store your weapons in some offsite facility and can only access them for certain times of the year with approved ammunition.
- pjc50 10y agoOh, I'll agree that the ratchet is real and that every proposal is intended to reduce and de-normalise gun ownership. In that sense, I can see why every single measure is opposed. It's the non-hunting rationales for ownership that are the irrational politics.
- douche 10y agoIt seems to be having the opposite effect. Every time there is a threat to institute new legislation, gun sales go through the roof.
- wolf550e 10y agoit certainly looks like the gun control lobby and gun manufacturers lobby are in symbiosis.
- hga 10y agoHeh, something like the Baptist and Bootlegger's alliance? From someone who's been in this fight since the early '70s, nope, the gun manufacturers' lobby, the National Shooting Sports Foundation (NSSF, http://nssf.org/ http://nssf.org/), is a very small political player. The gun owners lobby, especially the NRA, yes, the appearance of symbiosis is to a great extent true, but that took decades to achieve, not until the 1977 Cincinnati Revolt, and it wasn't until the 1994 "assault weapons" ban that a Federal gun control law was passed without the NRA's blessing. We're much bigger, gun and ammo manufacturing isn't a very big industry as these things go. 5 million people in the NRA, at least half the people in the US (last survey, 45% willing to admit to it)? Much larger.
- intended 10y agoAs the article elaborates, thats not the only issue, but at the end it shows how great the guy leading it is > He got to the National Tracing Center in 2005. He never expected to stay. It was a stepping stone to maybe a cushier deal maybe up at headquarters in D.C. > But then he started to think about ways to work with the antiquated system—and make it more efficient. Would it even be possible? “You mind if I do the whiteboard thing?” he says, standing up. > ‘Well, that looks like what I'm looking for.’ Six Sigma, you know that kind of stuff?' > “I just found it at Barnes & Noble,” he says, in a tone suggesting that this shit is basic. > He uses the blue marker. “I mean, I know that the average person can type in 1,600 gun descriptions per eight-hour day,” he says, scrawling the numbers. “Why? Because I time-and-motion studied them. And then—I don't know if you know anything about queuing theory. >Do you have one line with three cash registers—or do you have three lines come into one?” Arrows, circles. He's moved on to the black marker. >“There's a whole science of mathematics behind queuing theory. So what we did was, I sat around trying to figure out what would be the best way to queue the traces up and punch them through.... >And now? Despite no increase in budget, no new technology, no new staff: “I'm doing twice as many guns, twice as fast, and almost twice as accurately as we did when I got here in 2005.”
- lwhalen 10y agoGood. The gov't has no more a right to track my guns as they do my book purchases. "Alcohol, Tobacco, and Firearms" should be a convenience store, not a gov't agency.
- pjc50 10y agoBut you're OK with the car registration system? And the cell phone IMEI database? And the no-fly list? Edit: I should have been more general with the "you". Only the opposition to the gun database has succeeded. There's no general conversation about privacy; there's no coalition of pro-privacy orgs with a consistent view on what should and should not be stored in databases. Why is this?
- DamnYuppie 10y agoAs someone who agrees with the OP I am definitely not a fan of the no-fly list and other centralized registration databases.
- beachstartup 10y ago> But you're OK with the car registration system? And the cell phone IMEI database? And the no-fly list? uh, did he say he was? i'm sorry, did i neglect to read half the article, or half his comment, where these things are mentioned?
- unethical_ban 10y agoCell phone database is questionable, and cars are for those on the road. And I'm not liking the idea that in the near future, plate scanners will know where I'm going all the time. I should be able to move without the government knowing.
- rimantas 10y agoOf course, book is a deadly weapon.
- jolynch 10y agoPeople don't use books to kill, maim and disfigure other people, they use guns. There are zero logical reasons to prohibit a database that maps gun metadata to the gun record (search by name is actually detrimental to proper investigations). I've heard lots of emotional reasons, but I haven't heard a single well reasoned logical argument. Just a lot of reductio ad absurdum.
- HarryHirsch 10y agoThe encouraging thing is this: there is a strong sentiment in the US that the government should not track firearm purchases, there are laws in place to that effect, and consequently it is very difficult to track down the owner of a registered gun. The political process works! Now, if we just could de-fang Google, Facebook, the advertising networks that track users across websites and all the other data aggregators!
- onetwotree 10y agoThe obvious difference is that the gun industry is opposed to making it easy to track down guns. There are no powerful financial interests fighting for our data privacy.
- splintercell 10y agoHome come gun industries in other countries fought against gun laws? Maybe it's something to do with the fact that Gun lobby is powerful because we're a huge gun owning country with a constitutionally defined right to keep and bear arms. People don't become alcoholic because powerful beer industry spent money on preventing laws against alcohol.
- onetwotree 10y ago> People don't become alcoholic Perhaps you're right, and we need to treat our countries addiction to guns instead of trying to reduce the supply.
- hga 10y agoPerhaps you're right, and we need to treat our countries addiction to freedom in addition to trying to reduce the supply of liberty. Fixed it for you, as my side sees it.
- splintercell 10y ago> Perhaps you're right, and we need to treat our countries addiction to guns instead of trying to reduce the supply. There's no 'addiction' to Gun. I am an immigrant myself, and before coming to America I was anti-gun. Now, I am not scare of guns anymore and consider it to be a great social good.
- intended 10y agoCharlie is now my hero, he applied queuing theory to improve time take to identify guns. That's the right kind of person (comp sci and Intelligence background), using science to deal with a kafkaesque situation (no computers allowed) and managing to improve outcomes.
- jasonjei 10y agoI loved reading how they optimized the search problem. Charlie has CS education, the way they sorted their tuples and organized their data (as long as it's not by name!) reduced query times. Ironically, a CS education can help you optimize those processes even where computers are not allowed.
- HarryHirsch 10y agoWhat's ironic about this? Computer Science is the study of algorithms, not the study of whatever language is en vogue today. For the latter, you attend Coding Bootcamp.
- jasonjei 10y agoCS is not necessarily just the study of algorithms. I have a formal CS education and it encompasses everything from circuit design to algorithms to data structures to operating systems to statistics and graph, number and decision theory. Algorithms is a subset of overall theory that is a component of Computer Science and Maths. But I do agree, they've implemented some sort of hashing, with several buckets and trees to search from. It may not be efficient compared to actual computer databases, but it's the best humans can do with O(log n). Space requirement is still unfortunately O(n) but hopefully PDFs will help the ATF guys. If anything I'm saying that I'm happy people are recognizing that Computer Science has applications outside of computers, and is practically Applied Maths. A bachelor's degree in CS is only 2-3 math courses away from a minor in Maths. The irony is that a computer scientist is helpful in a computer-less environment. I guess you could say the human mind is a very advanced computer. It may not seem ironic to everyone on HN, but to the layman, what on earth could a CS person do with no computers? And the answer is a lot. After all Djikstra handwrote his algorithms on paper.
- dalke 10y agoWhat is the 1986 law which says "No searchable database of America's gun owners"? Does that mean the paper files can't be sorted alphabetically by name? Does it exclude more complex paper-based search systems, like needle-sorted edge-notched cards? Or does it only refer to computer databases?
- escapologybb 10y agoI wondered this, I'm not an American so the whole gun thing totally mystifies me. I don't think anyone should be allowed to own a gun, not the government, criminals, and certainly not people with mental illnesses. That being a somewhat naive hope then I think restricting them as much as possible is the thing to do. However, I'm not an American so I wouldn't presume to tell you what to do with your own country. You're welcome! /s But at what point does it become a database and searchable, does he have to deliberately pile up the boxes of receipts higgledy-piggledy lest they accidentally fall into some sort of organised and therefore searchable order? Seems crazily broad, no? Edited to Add: Wow, form 4473 doesn't get sent to any kind of centralised place until the gun shop that sold the particular con goes out of business. So this to my mind means a family gun business this been open for 100 years has every 4473 form they've ever written since the law came in, am I reading that right? Surely that can't be right? As in not correct, I don't mean morally, I mean that's just crazy to have a central database that doesn't centralise regularly.
- kabdib 10y agoFirearms have been nicknamed "equalizers" for a reason: An 80-year-old grandmother can successfully hold off an assault by someone many times her strength, size and agility. Get rid of guns and you now leave a large subset of society defenseless. Personally I think the 4473s should be destroyed after a reasonable time, and never subject to bulk capture. It's no business of the government's what purchases I make.
- dalke 10y agoHow many times has that "80-year-old grandmother" scenario happened? In all those countries with stricter gun laws, how many more times are those defenseless grandmothers been assaulted than in the US? I believe it's a fraction, perhaps even a small fraction. In the US, how many times has a child picked up a gun and killed someone by accident? More times than grandmothers have defended themselves, or less? How many times has a police officer shot someone for worries that the officer's own life was in danger of being shot, only to find that the person had no weapon? How many times have SWAT and no-knock warrants been justified for worries that the person being served might be armed? And of those, how many people have died? And how many died when the police went to the wrong house? How come having a gun didn't help Clarence Daniels keep from being assaulted by Michael Foster? http://www.motherjones.com/mixed-media/2015/01/black-man-gun-permit-walmart-florida-vigilante http://www.motherjones.com/mixed-media/2015/01/black-man-gun... Regarding your last sentence, I think real estate titles have shown some of the advantages to having the government track who has purchased a piece of property, so I disagree with your blanket statement.
- Redoubts 10y ago> No, says the gun lobby. It would give the government a tool to confiscate our guns. The idea of a gun registry is the great fever dream that lies at the heart of gun-control conspiracy theories: Government evildoers are going to attack us any day now. We have to be ready. (And you don't give the enemy an inventory of all your weapons!) I mean, I constantly see the concerns of gun owners derided like this, but I've never seen a good reason why they shouldn't be scared of a national registry. The debate has been purely adversarial for quite some time, so I'm not sure why/how both sides should come together for a good-faith compromise.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- bjt2n3904 10y agoThanks for recognizing the adversarial nature of the debate. Historically, registration precedes confiscation. Australia comes to mind. As a gun owner, I'm not sure how there can be "compromise" with "universal registration", especially when politicians are actively touting confiscation as an option on the table. Something I'd liken this to is Obama's "Key Escrow". Apple holds half the key to the encryption, The Feds hold the other. Look, a reasonable compromise! We promise that we won't do anything evil.
- hga 10y agoAustralia comes to mind. You can add California, SKSes due to an AG reinterpretation of the law, New York state, and right now Massachusetts is going through such an event due to their AG. And as you note, it's not like there's any lack of public figures including politicians who are touting outright confiscation, including those praising the Australian model, which include one of the two major party nominees for this presidential election. "You aren't paranoid if they are out to get you."
- 10y ago
- fredgrott 10y agoI got a stupid question from a stupid American(me): What would happen if ammo was taxed the same way cigarettes are in the USA? An example, someone buys a semi-automatic gun or automatic weapon...well than the ammo is taxed at a modest 5000%. You can have the guns all you want..but if you want to use them you pay the right cost to the degree of dangerous of the gun weapon...ie automatic ammo is taxed higher than say shotgun shells. State, both local, US states and federal would be exempt from the ammo tax.
- douche 10y agoReloading would become an even bigger deal than it already is. Already, anybody that shoots seriously and goes through a lot of ammunition will usually get setup with reloading equipment, because buying the powder, primers and bullets, with reused brass, is at least half as expensive as buying new ammunition. Also, there isn't a meaningful distinction between ammunition used in semi-automatic vs other types. 9mm is 9mm is 9mm, whether you're shooting it out of a Glock or a revolver or a single-shot target pistol. Same thing with rifle ammunition - NATO 5.56x45 tends to be what a lot of AR-15 variants, the so-called "assault weapons" are chambered in, but there's no reason you couldn't also have a bolt-action hunting rifle in the same caliber.
- hga 10y ago5.56 NATO was derived from the .223 Remington cartridge developed for the original AR-15, which was derived from the .222 Remington varmint cartridge and intended to be between it and the .222 Remington Magnum. My father's primary hunting partner when I started hunting had a .222 bolt action rifle; if this had happened later, it would undoubtedly be a .223 due to the reduced costs of the 5.56/.223 ecosystem.
- douche 10y agoIt can be incredibly frustrating to find slightly odd-ball calibers like that. My father has a couple of old lever action deer rifles that he's inherited, and they can be lots of fun to track down ammunition for, since some are larger caliber rimfires that are virtually extinct, and the rest are tend to be odd flat-nosed Winchester cartridges, to accommodate the tubular feeds.
- carsongross 10y agoThe reality is that this is putting the very people whom guns are supposed to protect us against in charge of their regulation. The second amendment is there not for hunting or sporting, but rather to maintain a state militia, literally a state-level military: A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed. You can see this underlying (and, to many modern folks, uncomfortable) reality being admitted to implicitly when they go after long guns first, despite the fact that long guns account for a vanishingly small amount of total gun crime. Long guns are excellent for challenging an overreaching central government, however.
- kabdib 10y agoRegistries in the US have very poor compliance rates; under 5% for a rifle registry in CA in the 1990s (the Atty General called the registry "a failure"), and a similar rate for a more recent attempt to register long guns in Connecticut. The government can run through the physical paperwork (held by dealers), but it's slow, inaccurate and inefficient. Many people think that is a feature. [The funny thing about "assault weapon" bans is that of two firearms that are functionally identical, one will be banned because it merely looks evil -- black and creepy looking -- while the other will be explicitly allowed in legislation. It's political posturing that just creates more criminals and does nothing to address the underlying causes of violence, namely failed socio-economic policies and the war on drugs, which creates a nice, solid economic base for gangs].
- bjt2n3904 10y ago> "I've got this form in my hand here. I'm looking at the form. I can tell you for a fact right now the purchaser and possessor are the same person." Seems that either the author doesn't understand how the 4473 works, or Charlie. Most likely both. A Form 4473 defines the possessor of the firearm like the IP address defines the user of the Internet connection.
- greggyb 10y agoI read some into this and could certainly be wrong: The possessor is determined by the gun being found by local law enforcement finding an individual, A, in posession of the gun in question. A trace request is submitted. The gun (in police custody after being found in A's possession) is associated with a form 4473. That 4473 is found, and the original purchaser is indicated to be A. The quotes excerpted in this article seem to be missing a lot of context and to have come from longer discussions that are noted to be emotional in many cases. I am interpreting that quote as part of a longer conversation where the speaker is jumping around a lot. The whiteboard section clearly indicates that Charlie does not necessarily express his thoughts linearly and in an easy-for-the-author-to-follow manner.
- Eric_WVGG 10y agoWould a "bot approach" to searching these records work? Say you were looking for (to use the article's example) a 9-mm semi-automatic Beretta 92 sold at Annie's Get Your Gun, serial number ABC123. You have the scans of all the Form 4473s put into folders (or maybe not, maybe just everything in a dump), and tell the bot to go looking for any form that matches this pattern. Importantly, the bot would NOT cache or structure data for later lookups; every search would be virgin. You'd have a lot of false positives (the O 0 and I 1 problem), it would not be terribly helpful at handwritten forms, but it could reduce a pile of a million records down to, hopefully, a few hundred or thousand.
- NKCSS 10y agoI guess it's me, but this while system and all those scared comments here of people afraid to have the gov. Know which guns you have, completely baffel me. I expected some smart individuals here, being able to recognise how weird this whole attitude is, but I am sorely dissapointed.
- hga 10y agoSmart is orthogonal to this issue, unless you consider it a synonym for wise (and few young smart people are also wise, something that's been notes for millennia). Educated or knowledgeable is all you need, those who know about the history of confiscations and often genocides following gun registration are of course afraid to let the government know. Or let me ask you, how do you know the government will stay as minimally benevolent as it already is? Especially with it's trending not so benevolent in the last few decades, as, for example, peace officers morphed into warrior cops? The War on (Some) Drugs, anyone?? What else might dissuade you of this notion you implicitly admit to? Weird? Disappointed? We're out-grouped? Maybe so, but that doesn't mean we're actually wrong, you know.
- NKCSS 10y agoMaybe it's because I live in a country where I am not afraid of the government and see the state of the US Vs. countries here in Europe where having a firearm is prohibited; I just don't get it. It feels the same like telling a 3 year old it's not allowed to handle a chefs knife on their own, but it gets mad because dad said it was OK, it will get mad if you take it way because someone said it was OK before, even though it's not the smart thing to do or in the best interest of the child.
- hga 10y agoMy god, according to your website and whois info, you're in the Netherlands. As I relate in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12425485 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12425485 in living memory, invaders have used your country's gun registration list to confiscate all the people's firearms, with public execution of whole families as a penalty for not producing a gun on the list. Oh, and owning a firearm in Europe is most certainly not prohibited, and that's not counting Switzerland, although the reported figures for the Netherlands https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Estimated_number_of_guns_per_capita_by_country https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Estimated_number_of_guns_per_c... look close to a total de jure prohibition. I guess the post-WWII ruling class was satisfied with what the Nazis wrought on its people; you certainly are....
- Overtonwindow 10y agoInteresting article but I felt like the author put too much emphasis on making a caricature of Charlie Houser. Starting from the first photo. It just set a strange tone for the whole article.