41 ms·
> Also the population density of Finland isn't exactly staggering Except the excuse you hear from Americans in every single thread about mobile tech is "Oh but
by kalleboo 10y ago
> Also the population density of Finland isn't exactly staggering
Except the excuse you hear from Americans in every single thread about mobile tech is "Oh but the US has such a low population density! Obviously our service must be crap and cost a shitload!"
- dogma1138 10y agoPopulation density is misleading because it's usually calculated based on total land area, total private land area, total resdential build up etc. Overall the US is in an odd position where tha large cities are too populated and the suburban metropolitan areas tend to be considerably less dense due to primarily single family housing over fairly large land plots. Combine that with NIMBY mentality and the overall geographic scale and you don't get the best environment for rapidly deploying infrastructure.
- kalleboo 10y agoThe problem is all regulatory. You have other countries with really insane population distributions like Australia, but they have some vague semblance of competition (I'm definitely not claiming the Australian market is sane by any stretch) so people who need rural coverage get the expensive but very high quality Telstra network, but people who never leave the cities can get unlimited data on more focused carriers. The US get the worst of all worlds.
- dogma1138 10y agoCould be, but then again Finland has like what 2 carriers? Elisa and Tellia something. Elisa is effectively the BT/AT&T/BELL of Finland.
- Jommi 10y agoElisa, Sonera, DNA + regional ones. Elisa has the widest coverage, they havebeen buying out regional ones.
- dogma1138 10y agoSonara is Telia, didn't knew about DNA I know that some of the islands and the more remote areas have had setup coop telephone/internet companies but overall there isn't much "competition" as far as number of companies go. If you exclude MVNO's most countries have pretty similar number of mobile and broadband providers.
- ptaipale 10y agoI disagree about that lack of competition: Finland was actually a pioneer in deregulation of telecom services in 1980's-1990's and that was a partial reason for the great success of Nokia since that. The company learned how to deal with operators that are competing on a market. Deregulation followed later in many European countries and throughout the world. There are three physical countrywide LTE/3G/GSM networks in Finland: Telia/Sonera, Elisa and DNA. They then carry some MVNOs so there are more places where you can actually buy a SIM card than just these three. Most people buy their phone here separately from the operator contract, so there are much fewer contract phones than e.g. in the U.S. Thus there is competition for phone sales, and competition for operator contracts, separately. Telia/Sonera is the former state monopoly, Elisa grew out of Helsinki telephone association/company, and DNA is a merger of small countryside operators. Sonera has the best coverage throughout the country, DNA curiously enough has the best coverage in urban areas. Of course, we can still always say that there is not enough competition between operators, as their prices tend to converge. Consumer advocates usually have only two kinds of messages: either all prices are nearly the same ("competition is not working!") or there are large disparities in prices ("competition is not working!").
- dogma1138 10y agoDisagree about what exactly? if only 3 cellular providers is competition then it's the same case for most countries. Oddly enough many countries somehow seem to devolve to the magic number of "3" which is usually the one old state run company, the "1990's/1980's" deregulation one, and the newer one which is also in many countries a consortium of several 2nd wave players that had to consolidate to survive. Clearly there are some other forces driving cellular communication in Finland other than only having 3 carriers.
- rayiner 10y agoMost reports I've seen put Australia's broadband speeds way behind the US. Australia's primary broadband technology is DSL.
- boyter 10y agoTrue. The NBN was supposed to fix that but became politicised and that was the end of that. The mobile networks however are first rate despite having low download quotas. On Vodafone (a cheaper network) where I live I get 60 mbit down and 30 mbit up over 4G. For the record that's 6-12 times faster than my dsl connection depending on if it's raining or not.
- SturgeonsLaw 10y agoYeah our wired network is lousy, we had commenced a rollout of nationwide 100MBit FTTP but that was crippled for political reasons, however we have some very high performing cellular networks. http://www.smh.com.au/digital-life/mobiles/australias-4g-networks-the-fastest-in-the-world-20140220-3350n.html http://www.smh.com.au/digital-life/mobiles/australias-4g-net...
- ptaipale 10y agoThat's not really so odd, it's the same in Finland, if you compare it to one U.S. state (the closest comparison is perhaps Wisconsin). Cities are fairly dense, they have suburban belts, and there is countryside with sparse population. But there's at least HSDPA just about everywhere in Finland.
- dogma1138 10y agoI've been to the states 3 times in the past 2.5 years and even in pretty remote rural areas I didn't had issues with LTE coverage. The only times I had no cellphone coverage at all is when I went hiking and it didn't drop from LTE to 2g it just dropped completely above a certain elevation.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]