5 ms·
At my workplace, we have about 60 scientists and engineers. The author's observation is accurate, that most people never use math beyond Excel and 8th grade mat
by analog31 10y ago
At my workplace, we have about 60 scientists and engineers. The author's observation is accurate, that most people never use math beyond Excel and 8th grade math. They also never use most of the theory that they learned in their science (including CS) and engineering educations.
The typical career arc is to get through college, then sit down at a CAD workstation, or programming terminal, and forget all of your math and theory within a few years or even months. Time that isn't spent doing CAD, is spent on testing, troubleshooting, dealing with vendors, and so forth. A few of them start prepping for management. It's becoming increasingly common for engineers to start their MBA training as soon as the company agrees to pay for it.
Truth be told, outside of a few life-support-critical applications, most design is done by trial and error. Very little real engineering gets done.
And the products we make, are designed to provide similar benefits in another profession. We are told by management: "Our customers don't want products that require them to think. They want something where a person with an 8th grade education can push a button and get an answer."
When a math or theory problem arises, they take it to the resident "math person." That's me. I'm glad that I spent the better part of my youth learning math and theory, because I'd be as suited to the CAD workstation as I'd have been to working at a loom, or a lathe, 100 years ago. For the most part, the people who emerge as "math people" are the ones who were interested in it as an end unto itself, in the first place. I didn't study math because I expected it to be necessary for a job. I studied math (and physics, programming, electronics, etc.) because I was interested in those things. They were for me an escape from preparing for my career.
- Nursie 10y agoI do complex mathematics for fun sometimes, it always surprises me when I start talking about the fractal images I generate and a large percentage of other engineers are wowed at how, well, complex it must all be. Then start to glaze over a bit... I loved studying all that stuff at school, pretty pictures or no. But as a coder the opportunities to use much of it in anger are really quite restricted.
- Asooka 10y agoMaybe the best argument for teaching people math is to show them how complexity can be tamed via patterns. As in, if you sit down and think logically, you can find solutions or come up with approaches to even the gnarliest-looking problems. And things that sound very simple (e.g. the Fermat conjecture, which can be understood by 5-th graders) can have really complicated solutions. It should teach people how to use their slow thinking rather than their fast thinking and that they absolutely have the capacity to do it. I've similarly never met anyone who had to do 20 accurately timed hops in a row daily, but I don't hear anyone want to remove jumprope and P.E. Still, there should absolutely be a class on "real-world applied mathematics" where you're taught the mathematical principles behind loans, mortgages, taxes, etc.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- nabla9 10y agoAll mathematics is applied mathematics. Pure mathematics is just mathematics applied to mathematics. This is problematic, because the way mathematics is currently taught only small number of students actually grok it and make deep connections that enable them to build up on what they previously learned and learn more. Others have the constant feeling of things getting progressively harder to understand and use. I'm sure that most people (including engineers) would benefit from the ability think and really internalize concepts taught in high school level. Pedagogical research is almost entirely directed towards small children. Psychologists have studied children and know the common hangups children have. What are common misconceptions, how to use them to make children learn. How they learn to count numbers past ten. Competent teacher can help small children to learn faster. I think it's possible to teach most people to think _in math_ but it's much slower process.
- petra 10y ago>> I think it's possible to teach most people to think _in math_ Something like betterexplained.com who tries to develop people's math intuition ?
- rudedogg 10y agoThanks so much for sharing https://betterexplained.com https://betterexplained.com. I'm amazed I haven't heard of it before.
- agumonkey 10y agoWouldn't that be metamathematics ?
- Ologn 10y ago> When a math or theory problem arises, they take it to the resident "math person." When an obvious math or theory problem arises. I'm sure they run across problems that more advanced math can solve, or stumble into problems due to not knowing more advanced math, yet their lack of knowledge prevents them from even understanding they confront a math problem. Sometimes the problem is not what they know they don't know, but what they don't know they don't know.
- learc83 10y agoThis happens constantly to people who think they don't need CS to program. Something that should have been a 2 hour implementation of an algorithm invented in the 60s turns into a 2 week exercise in frustration.
- mmmBacon 10y agoWorked in HW design for 16 years and I've never seen a design that was done by trial and error. Usually lots and lots of simulation and calculation up front followed by a DOE (design of experiment) to provide insight in areas which are difficult or impossible to simulate well. It's most certainly not trial and error.
- analog31 10y agoThanks for mentioning that. My experience could be unique to the industry that I'm in, or even just to the places where I've worked.
- burrows 10y agoDesigning and running a simulation sounds like a trial. Observing the results of the simulation then making a correction, seems to imply a sort of error.
- taneq 10y ago> most people never use math beyond Excel This seems like saying "most people never use science beyond English". Excel is a language for expressing numerical calculations, but how complicated or 'advanced' those calculations (or the theory behind them) are is orthogonal to the tool used.
- antod 10y ago> Truth be told, outside of a few life-support-critical applications, most design is done by trial and error. Very little real engineering gets done. I think people don't even realise when all that extensive math they studied is even helping them. They may have forgotten or not used the specifics in real life, but if they originally understood it well then they probably gained an important subconscious intuition that shapes, optimises and/or narrows that design trial and error. And the best engineers have a great subconscious intuition for finding solutions. Note: I studied Civil Engineering, so my math background was nearly all Trig and Calculus rather than the Discreet Math, Logic or Number Theory etc that a Computer Science degree might entail. I've forgotten nearly all of it and never really used it IRL, but I can still appreciate having a 'feel' for relationships between changing quantities etc that others without that math background don't seem to have. And having spent far longer working with software (self taught) than I ever spent with Civil Engineering, I often wonder what subconscious intuition of CS style math I'm missing that would help me.