4 ms·
I get the marketing/publicity angle of this, but there's no way this is cheaper than hiring an actual person. At least for the part of interacting with customer
by koolba 10y ago
I get the marketing/publicity angle of this, but there's no way this is cheaper than hiring an actual person. At least for the part of interacting with customers.
> Furthermore, LoweBot is able to assist with inventory monitoring in real-time, which help detect patterns that will able to guide future business decisions.
This sounds interesting. Having an army of robots marching down the aisles and scanning inventory seems useful. Wouldn't be as accurate as a human checking behind a box or finding mislabeled merchandise but would probably be more than an 80/20 solution to the problem.
- IanCal 10y ago> there's no way this is cheaper than hiring an actual person. I'm not so sure. People are pretty expensive. Lowes are open 6am to 10pm 5 days a week and 8-8 on the weekends. That's 104 hours per week, or ~5400 hours per year. 10% downtime and you're still looking at 5000 hours per year. Google suggests sales associates get $11.70/hour. If you add on maybe 20-30% overhead for all the associated hiring costs, taxes and extra management needed the equivalent cost would be around $75k/year. I expect the true figure would be higher. How much are these bots? They seem to be reasonably generic, but let's say a 5 year total cost is $200k, does that sound reasonable? That's around half the cost of a real person, so if each can replace about half of a person then that's a good deal. And that all relies on what I think are fairly low overheads, a reasonable amount of downtime for the bots, quite a high price for the bot itself and an assumption that the bots can't do anything extra that saves time (the inventory scanning for example, or collecting more useful information). At the very least, I don't think this is obviously much more expensive, and depending on a few factors could easily be much cheaper than a real person.
- shalmanese 10y agoFurthermore, the relevant metric isn't current price, it's the price at the time these get deployed at scale which, for a giant company, is at least 3 - 5 years. Large companies can afford to absorb many millions of dollars worth of losses for pilot projects because the learnings have the potential to far outweigh the losses. Even if each of these robots cost a million bucks a piece, if one robot can help Lowes learn something that reduces the cost of future robots by $100, spread across a 10,000 robot deployment, that robot has paid for itself.
- edwhitesell 10y ago> there's no way this is cheaper than hiring an actual person. They've got to try something. Staff has been noticably cut in both local Lowe's in my area over the past few years. It's still far better than Home Depot, but takes time to find help when you actually need it.
- mabbo 10y ago'Cheaper' is an interesting word. This is high capital cost purchase to reduce variable costs. Expensive to buy compared to the costs of hiring an employee, but (I would assume) low cost to maintain, and runs at all hours (so it partially replaces multiple employees). It's not a question of whether it will pay off, but in how much time. If the answer is 20 years, it's not worth the cost. If the answer is 3 weeks, every store will have them in the next six months.
- dexterdog 10y agoI would think it would be cheaper to have a network of work-from-home experts for each department. Put a kiosk robot that video chats to a real person who can drive the bot to walk with the person around the department and answer real questions like a person. Employees could server all stores at once like a call center. Eventually you can add automation to the process so that the easy questions are answered by code.
- protomyth 10y agoThis is would be a fun startup. Build standard teleconferencing bots with some specialized appendages and then act as a clearing house and broker for talent to use the bots in a business / retail setting.
- dexterdog 10y agoDo you have a connection to funding?
- protomyth 10y agono
- dexterdog 10y agoI sense chemistry already
- protomyth 10y agoHa, but seriously you probably want someone with a bit more experience in remote system programming. I would think a person who plays with drones would be a good fit. Thinking about it, there must be someone on HN whose done the whole police robot thing. Don't get me wrong, I would love to do something like this, but for the time being I'm stuck were I am. Plus, I have a side thing going on myself that needs to get done. In truth though, there are better people than me who could make this a success.