3 ms·
If you want Linux to be a primary end-user OS, it needs to stop trying to approximate the experiences of other OSes, and provide an experience the others don't.
by eyelidlessness 10y ago
If you want Linux to be a primary end-user OS, it needs to stop trying to approximate the experiences of other OSes, and provide an experience the others don't. For some, this is the freedom (source, legal, configuration) that others don't provide. For nearly everyone else, this is "I want to be able to accomplish something. Make it possible, or where it's possible make it better."
The closest thing to this I've found is Ubuntu's Unity, which makes some specific desktop tasks more intuitive than on other OSes. That experience should be expanded!
I don't want a Linux environment to be just as good as my Mac. I want it to be better. I'd gladly switch, I'm not tied to much of the Apple ecosystem (other than iCloud Keychain, and I can reset all of those passwords). But my platform choice has always been driven by experience, and I'll choose the best experience I can find. So far, my experience with every Linux distro I've tried has been to approximate, not improve.
- reitanqild 10y ago> If you want Linux to be a primary end-user OS, it needs to stop trying to approximate the experiences of other OSes, and provide an experience the others don't. For some, this is the freedom (source, legal, configuration) that others don't provide. For nearly everyone else, this is "I want to be able to accomplish something. Make it possible, or where it's possible make it better." > The closest thing to this I've found is Ubuntu's Unity, which makes some specific desktop tasks more intuitive than on other OSes. Seems weird to me: for me Unity just cloned the UI / UX of Mac (single menu, dock, alt-tab switcher). I've always liked KDE which was more Windows-like but ahead of Windows in providing searchable app launcher (Start menu for Windows users) way before Windows did. (My point is: if you don't like Ubuntu with Unity then remember on Linux you have lots of choices.)
- slavik81 10y ago> Seems weird to me: for me Unity just cloned the UI / UX of Mac (single menu, dock, alt-tab switcher). Unity felt a lot more like Windows 7 to me. It has the Start menu vertically on the left side, just I kept mine in Windows. It has the same keyboard shortcuts for starting pinned programs, and the dash is just a better implementation of the Windows 7 start menu's search field. Then it adds its own twist, allowing you to search menus with alt. I loved it. I suppose the fact that the menu is at the top is like OSX, but because programs close when all windows are closed, it doesn't annoy me like it does on macs.
- XorNot 10y agoI want to disagree with everything you just said. Linux needs to not do this at all. There is no possible way for open source to compete effectively with the design and research resources of large companies. But there's also no need to: everyone has been screwing it up for years. Linux just needs to be simple, stupid but work. And the kernel level is pretty good at this. My window manager (cinnamon) is very good at this. At some point we've actually solved UI on a flat screen, and we're just going around in circles trying to reinvent it poorly. So I disagree - Linux needs 2 or 3 mimics of other window manager layouts, and we need standards to ensure everyone can code to all of those easily.
- Sylos 10y ago> If you want Linux to be a primary end-user OS, it needs to stop trying to approximate the experiences of other OSes, and provide an experience the others don't. You say that as if they were mutually exclusive. Linux is not just one OS which has to do one thing. It's hundreds of OSs which all can do different things. If some of those want to solely offer an improved experience over other OSs, while others decide to completely diverge from any known concepts, that's no problem at all. Also consider that there's only so many concepts which will work with a desktop OS. You can build something that's completely different, but chances are that you end up with Windows 8 or Android or a media-center or Eagle Mode [0] which are great in their own right, but not exactly what most people will expect on a desktop computer. [0] http://eaglemode.sourceforge.net/index.html http://eaglemode.sourceforge.net/index.html