3 ms·
Oh geez, you're giving me flashbacks to trying to introduce Github to non-technical students. I basically just don't even try to explain the difference, because
by danso 10y ago
Oh geez, you're giving me flashbacks to trying to introduce Github to non-technical students. I basically just don't even try to explain the difference, because I have them use a minimal set of git's functionality, that is, the subcommands add, commit, and push...and of course, clone and init at the beginning of the quarter.
And I teach them virtually nothing about Github other than that it's a website that you interface with git. For me, Github is a great place to get students to push their assignments and papers because I can easily comment on them...once in awhile I'll do a force push to fix something. We never do anything with forking, and I strongly discourage them from using the Github web interface to edit documents, as that is the most frequent cause of merge conflicts.
If they follow what I say, git and Github are just glorified document-uploading systems. I've almost never had a student fuck up in a way that we had to rollback something, because for the most part, people who don't use version control as their job don't need it. Version control is only particularly relevant when working in a team, doing iterative work, or deploying to multiple environments. These are things that students do not need to worry about.
And actually, even the comsci students don't really need to worry about it.
If I do attempt to explain the difference between git and Github, I usually use the analogy of git is to Github as your cameraphone is to Instagram.
- cglee 10y agoIf you ever run into this need again, I'd recommend this book: https://launchschool.com/books/git https://launchschool.com/books/git
- paradite 10y agoThanks. I often have troubles explaining to others the difference between Git and GitHub, and I think the camera phone and Instagram is a nice analogy.
- noufalibrahim 10y agoI do corporate trainings on git. Many prospective clients or vendors call me asking for "g.i.t. hub" trainings. Thankfully though, most of these are just the misinformed marketing teams. The engineering people usually grasp the difference easily when I finally reach the parts about collaboration. I like the cameraphone/instagram analogy. Thanks! I usually do all the pushes/pulls etc. using a file:// remote so that people can see what happens and then just tell them that github is what happens with you move the remote to the cloud and give it a nice UI.
- deevus 10y agoInteresting. Do you get a lot of work training people in git?
- noufalibrahim 10y agoIt's reduced a little in the past few months. I've increased my rates a little so that I can focus only on direct clients rather than training vendors who need the prices to be low so that they can take a cut. Also, I think cheaper git trainers have shown up on the market and many people are already familiar with it both of which have reduced the number of requests I get.