4 ms·
Doesn't it just mean that they'd have to MITM you to snoop or inject? It's better, since it raises the bar some, but it doesn't really change what's possible th
by mikeash 10y ago
Doesn't it just mean that they'd have to MITM you to snoop or inject? It's better, since it raises the bar some, but it doesn't really change what's possible there.
- bandrami 10y agoSo, we agree: it's strictly better
- jedberg 10y agoIt's not strictly better -- it gives a false sense of security. As you plainly showed by believing that having https at a Starbucks with an untrusted cert is safe, which it is clearly not. Security involve both a technical and social aspect. While the unsigned cert may offer better security (but there is no way for you to know) it most certainly offers a worse social aspect, that being a false sense of security. So I'd say you're wrong -- it is strictly worse, because it offers no better security but a worse sense of security.
- daxorid 10y agoFor non-CA certs, you either manually verify hashes or install the self-signed root cert. So no, the attacker would have to at minimum find a SHA1 hash collision, otherwise the client will know they're being MitM'ed.