3 ms·
It's way too early for this type of hand-wringing. It's not like native apps are fundamentally less capable of UGC than web apps, it's just that the iPad was r
by dasil003 17y ago
It's way too early for this type of hand-wringing. It's not like native apps are fundamentally less capable of UGC than web apps, it's just that the iPad was released, uh, 1 day ago.
Media companies don't have anything against interactivity, they're just excited about the fact that Apple has had some success creating markets where people actually pay for a la carte content. The true old-world of limited distribution is certainly not going to come out of the app store—Apple is a gatekeeper yes, but they don't have any interest in enforcing an artificial scarcity on behalf of old media.
The hardware limitations are just v1 stuff. Remember when the iPhone launched without an SDK? People were shitting cinderblocks all over the blogosphere, but Apple took its time and came out with a killer product in due course.
I'm all for open platforms, but the way some of this stuff reads it's like Apple already has achieved a monopoly on general purpose computing with the iPad. Yes, it's too bad that Apple couldn't have been a little more open with the iPad, but realistically they are innovating more than anyone else in the market. We should be glad just to have them injecting ideas into the marketplace even if their platform remains fully closed. It's still better than Microsoft buying and killing anyone with a promising idea, or free software's inability to create a compelling end-user experience. When Internet usage starts to approach 50% iPad then maybe we have something to worry about, but for now it's just rabid punditry desperate to cash in on the hype.