5 ms·
Democracy as a whole is kind of illusory at this point; the world has grown to such a scale and the general public so distracted that they often can't make vali
by ravenstine 10y ago
Democracy as a whole is kind of illusory at this point; the world has grown to such a scale and the general public so distracted that they often can't make valid decisions at the polling booth because they are so disconnected from the issues. In the old days, there were only so many things people had to understand before they were given a vote and, while those issues were more impactful on everyday life, they were also less complicated.
Today, the real issues have gotten complicated and nuanced, but the average human IQ and curiosity level has not caught up. As a result, we are handed lots of small and barely-relevant decisions to give us that illusion of choice, both for practical reasons and to shut us up. Local elections certainly have more impact on one's life, and really aren't hard to understand, but life is too good for most people to care enough. And, with people more infantilized than ever, the more they want surrogate mommies and daddies to make the tough decisions for them, just as their own parents did for them in childhood. So, when we are handed a piece of paper so we can say who we want to be our surrogate parents, most of us say "meh" and vote for the incumbents because, well, we have our smart phones, TV, Starbucks, and gourmet restaurants, so the current politicians can't be doing that bad, right?
- wellpast 10y agoGrassroots campaigns (Sanders, Trump) this election cycle raised general awareness of a lot of important issues. I'm not sure the fundamental issues are any more complicated today than they were yesterday. We need more grassroots activism, not cynicism.
- zanny 10y agoThis is why direct democracy doesn't work, and it is also why representative democracy is good. We have just gotten ourselves into a position where decades of "let the people decide" has led to your ballot including a dozen citizen choices you do not care about. In a saner world, we would be focusing on the representative part of the republic - why am I directly electing judges, magistrates, and prosecutors when it would be significantly better to select representatives to make all these electoral choices for me? Political parties have become a bad proxy for true representation. People just start voting party line and the powers that be love that kind of model - it means great persons cannot rise independent of them, and it means you can blame the bad on the individuals but the success on the party as a whole. And party affiliation has always been a horrible proxy for effective leadership. Instead, we are in a situation where our "representatives" are representing millions of people individually, while we vote for dozens of esoteric local elections for things that aren't particularly representative. What we should have is much more localized elections of representatives that then make such bureaucratic appointment decisions themselves, including for the higher levels of government beyond them. IE, you can have a representative for every 3 thousand rather than 3 million people, and that representative will join a local council that appoints the judges, city council, higher level reps, etc.
- ravenstine 10y ago"[...] why am I directly electing judges, magistrates, and prosecutors when it would be significantly better to select representatives to make all these electoral choices for me?" Yes, exactly.
- gautamdivgi 10y ago> And party affiliation has always been a horrible proxy for effective leadership. Very true - isn't that the fascist/communist model? Party affiliation trumps independence & ability?
- sidlls 10y agoYes, which is one reason why I think of the system in the US as being very much closer to a fascist system than many or most are comfortable contemplating.
- likeclockwork 10y agoPretty sure it was the US' model first.
- ravenstine 10y agoIt's authoritarian, but I'm not sure that it's nationalist. So I'm not sure fascist is the right term, but you are otherwise correct.
- slg 10y ago>In a saner world, we would be focusing on the representative part of the republic - why am I directly electing judges, magistrates, and prosecutors when it would be significantly better to select representatives to make all these electoral choices for me? >Political parties have become a bad proxy for true representation. People just start voting party line and the powers that be love that kind of model - it means great persons cannot rise independent of them, and it means you can blame the bad on the individuals but the success on the party as a whole. And party affiliation has always been a horrible proxy for effective leadership. The problem is that these two ideas conflict with each other in a first past the post system. Representatives are motivated to band together to help secure their election and with first past the post the largest group is the only one who benefits. The end results will always be two large political parties.
- slg 10y agoOn the flip side, it has never been easier to research the issues. If you want to be an educated voter, it isn't that hard of a process. The problem is that very few are motivated because on average we all have pretty nice lives. That doesn't mean there is nothing to be improved upon, just that we all have lots to lose by joining political movements like the ones that existed in the past.
- joe_karn 10y ago>the average human IQ and curiosity level has not caught up The lowest IQ humans who are also functional are concentrated in prisons. The crime rate is highest amongst 80-90 range individuals, and it is hard to believe that freeing them wouldn't retard your intellectual catchup. In fact, the French IQ has fallen by almost four points between 1999 and 2009 so if anything we must increase the number of people incarcerated, among other policy decisions.
- jomamaxx 10y ago" In the old days, there were only so many things people had to understand" Most of them were illiterate, had very little access to any real news. The very concept of 'unbiased' news is a modern American phenom. Of course all news is still biased, but they try/pretend not to be. In the 'old days', newspapers were propaganda tools of the owners and their political peers - if you wanted to get elected to 'Senate' or whatever, the best thing to do would be to 'buy a newspaper' - which many of them did. Have a look at 'old timey' news - it's really almost funny - it's all mockery and slander. That said - it had a lot of wit! At least some of it was smart :). But yes - the world is very complicated today - I agree with that sentiment.
- stult 10y agoIt's also partially because the "upper crust" of intelligent, wealthy individuals is far less locally invested than in the past. They're more mobile and tend to connect with others and communities less because of geography and more because of shared experiences (e.g. university alums), shared industries/professions, and similar economic statuses. These are the people who, in the past, would have had strong investment in local politics and the intelligence to problem solve issues at that level.
- hamiltonkibbe 10y agoI'm fairly certain that the average IQ has remained constant at 100