5 ms·
I've seen several opinions here. Antibacterial soap is unhealthy and should be banned for health reasons. Antibacterial soap is largely ineffective, so should
by unethical_ban 10y ago
I've seen several opinions here.
Antibacterial soap is unhealthy and should be banned for health reasons.
Antibacterial soap is largely ineffective, so should be banned for false advertising reasons.
Antibacterial soap should not be banned.
Which one is right? Is there any science or ethical political philosophy to justify this executive action?
- Vraxx 10y agoIt's not necessarily unhealthy to an individual person, it's the effect that it has on the surviving bacteria. These soaps are dangerous to society as a whole because they become less effective the more widespread their usage is [0]. Thus, we don't need to use them for every single thing we get on our hands that we want off, we're not in mortal peril of those germs. [0]: http://www.fda.gov/ForConsumers/ConsumerUpdates/ucm378393.htm#2 http://www.fda.gov/ForConsumers/ConsumerUpdates/ucm378393.ht...
- rtkwe 10y agoIt's explained pretty well in the article. Basically the FDA said in 2013 'show us that these chemicals are effective and safe for daily long term use' and companies didn't do it. So there's little to no support for the effectiveness and there may be some long term exposure issues from animal studies.
- 001sky 10y agoIsn't this a straw man? These products are used in hostpitals everyday. Nobody doubts they are 'safe'in any meaningful sense. Otherwise they would need to be banned outright. OCD people, and their kids, are a huge problem in society and should be dealt with, but this is not 'science based' public policy at all. Its like asking someone to prove a negatve, which is absurd in many contexts. "why did something not happen" does not have a finite, knowable answer in the vast majority of contexts.
- rtkwe 10y agoNot a straw man at all. Effectiveness should be simple to show and for safety they're not asking for perfect proof of safety just that it doesn't cause long term effects which is done a lot with animal studies. Hundreds of products go through FDA safety testing it's not some impossible test. Also these aren't the same soaps used in hospitals. Hospital soaps are much harsher and use different chemicals.
- 001sky 10y ago"they're not asking for perfect proof of safety just that it doesn't cause long term effects which is done a lot with animal studies" Lets hope its just one of those shitty translations of 'real science' being lost in translation when subjected to a journalist-friendly press release. Theres 40 years of data using humans. Nobody doubts that dial sope or other similar soaps is safe in any meaningful sense. The science in this argument is being lost. If these were legitimate tests they would have been done years ago and there would not be the various exemptions in this policy declaration. I will insert the caveat here that I'm not a fan of everyday use of anti-bacterials. I also don't doubt that using anti-bacterials and prbably more importantly anti-biotics and various endocrine influencing chemicals and plastics with loose regard for the environment has negative impacts on society. I think kids should eat dirt, assuming it's clean dirt, etc. They are made to handle the stuff that nature thows at them.
- ryen 10y agoThe burden of proof should be on the manufacturers to prove, scientifically, that it's safe and effective. Not the FDA
- Kenji 10y agoWhat? That is an incredibly strange notion. So by default, everything should be banned, and it should only be legal if you can show it's safe? That is not how it works. A ban is an authoritarian action that has to be enforced at gunpoint, always keep that in mind. It is not only a very extreme stance to take, it is a violent one. A ban should only apply on things that are shown to be bad and harmful.
- greglindahl 10y agoThe reason that we've had so many people hurt by nutritional supplements is that they're allowed to add anything until it's proven to be unsafe. In the medical field, which has strict rules today, it was the era of dangerous and ineffective "patent medicine" that caused our existing policies to be created. If you're going to advocate change, don't you think it's important to understand historical and modern examples of the people you're going to kill?
- Kenji 10y agoI am certain that the FDA, with its ban on certain substances, has caused more deaths and misery than it has ever prevented. Not to mention financial losses. Before you ask accusory questions, why not refine your own position and brush off the smugness?
- Bud 10y agoYou aren't actually certain. You think you're certain, based on...nothing. There's a difference.
- allengeorge 10y agoExamples then? Are are you speaking only in unverifiable "if only" hypotheticals?