4 ms·
There is plenty of blame to go around, but one of the biggest mistakes leading up to the financial crisis was significantly lowering the amount of cash reserves
by btilly 17y ago
There is plenty of blame to go around, but one of the biggest mistakes leading up to the financial crisis was significantly lowering the amount of cash reserves the investment banks needed to keep on hand. That happened on Bush's watch with Republicans in charge of every branch of government.
And the revoking of Glass-Steagall under Clinton? That was introduced by Republicans in both the House and Senate, with the Senate vote being almost entirely on party lines. Yes, Clinton signed it, but it was a Republican bill.
- grandalf 17y agoAs for the issue of reserves, I think if you make the argument you are making you have to state what you think the optimal reserve requirement is. If the recent crisis had been a bit smaller, existing reserve levels would have been fine. If the crisis had been a bit bigger, then it's not certain whether even the previous reserve requirements would have been sufficient. The only way you get 100% security is to have a 100% reserve requirement. Anything less is gambling. So if you critique the lowering of reserve rates you are obligated to state what sort of odds you think are more reasonable.
- anamax 17y ago> And the revoking of Glass-Steagall under Clinton? Irrelevant because it didn't have any effect on the crisis. In fact, it allowed some transactions that had some hope of slowing things down. Note that the non-regulated institutions did better, as did the non-regulated arms of regulated institutions. AIG was regulated up the wazoo.
- btilly 17y agoSome of the "too big to fail" issues we saw was definitely because companies got into multiple lines of business that Glass-Steagall would have prevented.
- anamax 17y ago> Some of the "too big to fail" issues we saw was definitely because companies got into multiple lines of business that Glass-Steagall would have prevented. Those "other lines of biz" provided some diversification that gave them some chance of survival. It also made it possible for banks to save some of the trading firms. You clearly disagree, so let's have names.