3 ms·
If the top athletes were never born then there would be still be pro sports using other athletes almost as good, and people would still talk about how skilled t
by skybrian 10y ago
If the top athletes were never born then there would be still be pro sports using other athletes almost as good, and people would still talk about how skilled they are and how they are the best in the world. Similarly for acting and music. These are winner-take-all professions. Being the best is not about reaching an absolute level of skill; it's relative to the rest of the population.
And that's leaving aside the randomness involved in which songs become a hit. If you have positive feedback (the famous become more famous) then the system is not designed to necessarily pick the best. It's just designed to pick someone. You have a filter where any difference will work and if there isn't a difference a boy band will be chosen at random. So the same structure can happen even if unlike sports, skill is hard to measure.
On the other hand there are skills that are easy to measure (who is the fastest worker in an Amazon warehouse) that don't matter as far as pay is concerned. But if we had televised box-moving competitions and they were popular then there's no reason in principle it couldn't be made to matter.
- Retric 10y agoIMO, it's the gap in still not the absolute skill levels that are most interesting. Michael Jordan was not just the best player of his generation he was dramatically better than other players. Remove the top 100 players and these gaps shrink dramatically. Collage sports is interesting in part because the smaller pool of people and large number of teams makes for even wider skill gaps. Rule changes have made the NFL more competitive, but overall the sport is less interesting without unusually good teams.
- skybrian 10y agoYes, agreed. From an entertainment point of view, if the NFL didn't exist people would watch some other sport and find that just as interesting (maybe for different reasons). The skill level isn't essential to the entertainment value.
- Retric 10y agoTo clarify, Michael Jordan was a huge net gain to the NFL well beyond his pay. The Bulls flat out made more money with him on the roster than he cost which is all you need to sport his salary. He also made the sport more popular. At the same time while the average NFL team in 2015 would crush the average NFL team from 1970, but that does not mean the 2015 NFL is more interesting. So, I accept the salaries as a local optimum, but finding a cheaper option is probably very hard. Perhaps retire players after 5-10 years?
- skybrian 10y agore: "gain to the NFL" do you mean NBA? (Not that I follow sports.)
- Retric 10y agoLoL, yea. Was trying to use several examples from different sports. I actually think the NFL has probably changed more due to better physical training. But, the NBA has also gotten dramatically better over time.