3 ms·
It's an interesting counterpoint. Except his generalization is based on the actual behavior of whatever sample he's seen. I'll also note that Google hyperfocuse
by nickpsecurity 10y ago
It's an interesting counterpoint. Except his generalization is based on the actual behavior of whatever sample he's seen. I'll also note that Google hyperfocuses recruiting on specific types of people in a way that automatically excludes all kinds of talent and people based on superficial criteria. Your counterpoint works on them too. ;)
- StavrosK 10y agoSure, but how big can that sample have been? People who claim to be able to make absolute judgements for a whole population based on a few samples can be lumped in the same category, but Google interviewers don't say "I'll never hire an X person". The article, however, does say "I'll never hire a Googler".
- nickpsecurity 10y ago"but Google interviewers don't say "I'll never hire an X person"" You sure? I thought originally you couldn't get your foot in the door unless you were willing to solve some specific puzzles that might be an insult to someone with great resume and references. Or that their interviewing process naturally filters out all kinds of people who mentally handle work in IT better than bogus interviews. That's definitely saying we won't hire X person but in an indirect way where the traits of that person aren't specified clearly. They just follow from the obstacles Google creates for them. "The article, however, does say "I'll never hire a Googler"." That is true. Unlike Google, it's direct, honest, and gives us what we need to evaluate it. I see that it goes too far in a number of criteria where some Google employees clearly don't fit into the category. It would be unfair discrimination. There is one I think is worth evaluating: will they stick with the company over the long haul? This is going down in general but startup and high-tech culture has huge risk of turnover for average company. A smart, experienced candidate focused on life/job stability is a much safer bet by default than a Googler.