6 ms·
Parallel universe: http://www.mail-archive.com/dev@openoffice.apache.org/msg28200.html http://www.mail-archive.com/dev@openoffice.apache.org/msg282... If we
by okket 10y ago
Parallel universe: http://www.mail-archive.com/dev@openoffice.apache.org/msg28200.html http://www.mail-archive.com/dev@openoffice.apache.org/msg282...
If we look at LibreOffice and compare:
LibreOffice, that is *good* (not more) software and
*excellent* public relations.
OpenOffice, that is *excellent* software and *pretty bad*
public relations.
Proof: http://www.mail-archive.com/dev@openoffice.apache.org/msg28203.html http://www.mail-archive.com/dev@openoffice.apache.org/msg282...
Secondly, as alluded to above, we should prepare ourselves
for the FUD, the "AOO is dead" victory chants, the numerous
anti-AOO and anti-Apache spewings, etc... There are some
who will use this as a self-serving soapboxing opportunity,
and warp the facts into some Bizarro alternate universe
history. We should be there to set the facts straight but
also resign ourselves to the fact that their voices will
likely be louder than ours.
[...]
But the main reason why, imo, was because we were also
end-user. End users needed to make a *choice* between
AOO and SomethingElse.
Don't say the word.
By no longer being an end-user application, that goes away.
End users play no role any more? Good luck with that.
- jimjag 10y ago"End users play no role any more? Good luck with that." In what parallel universe do you get that conclusion from that thread?
- okket 10y agoMy last remark was too snarky and out of context, I am sorry. You want both projects to merge again with OO being the 'core' and LO the 'user interface'? Sounds intriguing, but are both code bases still compatible enough for that? Would this not be more effort than gain? What is obvious is that the AOO project cannot support, at the present time, being an end-user focused effort. I would suggest we focus on not being one, but instead being a framework or library that can be consumed by actual end-user implementations. (Quote from your email)
- jimjag 10y agoI didn't say "merge". Being a library or framework which can be consumed, either in whole or in part, by another entity is in no way a "merge".
- okket 10y agoWhy should LO have an interest to switch to an OO core/library? Just to gain the OO name back and be present on the website? Tough deal. Also, I still think the code bases are too different by now [1] and there is little to gain. Without at at least one 'consumer'/UI (which you do not want or cannot provide) there is little point in developing an OO core/library, or is it? Which leads to my snarky comment about end-users and their role... [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12413218 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12413218
- jimjag 10y agoThe Open Office eco-system is larger, by far, than LO and AOO. Maybe LO may not benefit at all from a permissive licensed core (although it certainly has benefited from it, as noted elsewhere), but certainly other OO implementations might. We have seen, and even the FSF admits it, that open standards do best with permissive licensed implementations. So if you want wide adoption of open standards, a permissive license is likely better. The world is not just LO or AOO. After all, the enemy, so-to-speak, is this proprietary s/w called MSO...
- chris_wot 10y agoDefine "ecosystem"?
- chris_wot 10y agoActually, I'd love to see the VCL be turned into a standalone library :-)
- CopperWing 10y agoOpenOffice and LibreOffice are already "merged". In fact in the past years, after the fork, LibreOffice developers regularly tracked OpenOffice source code repository and merged all the useful changes they could find, by either picking the original code or re-implementing it their own way. In addition to that they also completely overhauled and simplified the build system, removed tons of dead code and translated German comments which where there since StarOffice, replaced Java components with equivalent ones written in C/C++, are in the process of switching from GTK2 to GTK3 (mandatory to get Wayland support in Linux), etc. Doing so they made the LibreOffice source code base sustainable on the long term and lowered the difficulty entry level for new contributors, while apparently OpenOffice buildbots are not even able to rebuild their software since last year... The only useful asset which remains to OpenOffice is the trademark.
- taserian 10y agoI'd hesitate to claim that OpenOffice is "excellent software", if the security issues aren't being addressed in a timely manner.
- clintonc 10y agoThere's a distinction between the software itself being excellent and the team being fast-moving.
- davidgerard 10y agoAOO is neither, per the security problems that brought about discussion of retiring the project.
- the_duke 10y agoHow exactly is OO excellent and LO good? What is that based on? Please back that up.
- antoineMoPa 10y agoMy experience would be the contrary. I felt Libre Office had better document compatibility and a better user experience, so I stopped using Open Office. Maybe it improved since then. I would also like to see something to back up the claim you are talking about.
- okket 10y agoPlease ask the author on the OO-dev mailing list, I just quoted him http://www.mail-archive.com/dev@openoffice.apache.org/msg28200.html http://www.mail-archive.com/dev@openoffice.apache.org/msg282...
- the_duke 10y agoI misread your comment.
- bArray 10y agoIn my personal experience, when I first tried Open Office it ended up being a clunky, unreliable clone of older Microsoft Office products. It was still better than a kick in the teeth though. In all honesty, after writing my own simple manual editor for PDF, I really don't envy the task of making something compatible with multiple other formats. It would be nice to see the project archived or completely released to the community to continue work on.
- MichaelMoser123 10y ago> ... clunky, unreliable clone of older Microsoft Office products. It was still better than a kick in the teeth though. That's exactly why i am using Open/Libre office; at some point Microsoft Office got such a complicate UI (ever since they pushed the ribbon bar - that's when they kicked me in the teeth) that i am unable to use it - the alternative uses a much less complicated UI so i am with it. Does the MS Office UI conform with the Windows UI guidelines ? I am not quite sure.. As for 'unreliable' - i can't share this perspective; LibreOffice works for me; didn't have any problems with OpenOffice either - before i switched to LibreOffice. I switched because LibreOffice is supposed to have better support. Interesting that MS often gets to a point where the UI is quite adequate, but then they have to come up with something new, so they come out with an update that breaks it all. Happened with Windows, Office, Visual Studio, Visual Basic - you name it; i think it also happened with gmail - so it does not seem to be something exclusive to MS; i wonder if that is a general law of software development.
- JetSpiegel 10y agoThat second mail has more interesting stuff in the bottom. > I would even suggest us considering going further and redirecting AOO traffic to LO