7 ms·
You can't make a bunch of for profit companies act in the best interest of users. We keep trying and failing. Healthcare is a basic human right, and should be p
by brianwawok 10y ago
You can't make a bunch of for profit companies act in the best interest of users. We keep trying and failing. Healthcare is a basic human right, and should be provided free of charge to everyone.
- collyw 10y agoLike in the civilized countries.
- talmand 10y agoWonderful argument. Don't do things our way then you are not civilized. That's the way to win people over.
- abritinthebay 10y agoAnd being offended over someone pointing out the uncivilized healthcare in the USA rather than being at the awful healthcare system is so productive, yes?
- talmand 10y agoYes. Because I don't care for the divisive nature of the comment. If the person can learn to refrain from such childish comments in the future then I would find it productive. Besides, my opinion of the comment has no bearing on my opinion of the healthcare system in any way. I can be offended by both at the same time thank you very much.
- robalfonso 10y agoWhile I agree with you, one thing that absolutely drives me nuts with this argument is scale. Norway Pop. 5M (approx) Finland Pop. 5M (approx) England Pop. 53M (approx) Canada Pop. 35M (approx) United States Pop. 318M (approx) The scale is way off from many other countries who have implemented the kind of healthcare reform being talked about. When you get to hundreds of millions of people all kinds of issues arise that you don't see elsewhere. China and India are the only countries more populous than the United States and I'd be nervous to experience their health care system. In fact you have to go quite far down the population list to get a first world country where that kind of healthcare is being implemented (happy to be proven wrong here)
- mywittyname 10y agoWe already have the healthcare system in place, and it already works well. The problem is cost. While it's impossible to say what the cost driver is, when you look at the performance of companies in the healthcare sector, you'll see they're doing extremely well, outpacing the S&P500 by 50% over the past decade. [1] So at least some large portion of this cost increase is going into the pockets of executives and shareholders. [1] https://personal.vanguard.com/us/funds/snapshot?FundId=5485&FundIntExt=INT https://personal.vanguard.com/us/funds/snapshot?FundId=5485&...
- r_smart 10y agoThere's no free lunch. If the government is paying for it, it's not free of charge. And in this country, there's a long record of exponential price costs when the government is the customer. Our premiums would go up, they'd just be called taxes then. You could maybe nationalize all the hospitals or something and make doctors government employees, but I don't think we'd like the outcome. Just the transition would be a nightmare. And that's ignoring the legal aspects of it. It's not so easy as just waving your hand and saying "Free Healthcare! Free for everyone!"
- kennydude 10y ago> but I don't think we'd like the outcome The NHS is fantastic.
- talmand 10y agoThe NHS may be fantastic for one country, doesn't mean it would be for another.
- Ntrails 10y agoI'm pretty sure it would be fantastic for the majority - but not for a vocal minority who have a large amount of power.
- talmand 10y agoI would agree for the most part.
- r_smart 10y agoMilton Friedman has some interesting points about welfare programs and how they interact with immigration. Particulary, that you can have massive unchecked immigration, or extensive welfare programs, but the two don't interact well. The NHS is probably a good example. The UK has historically had low to moderate rates in immigration and the NHS. The US has had a ton of immigration, but no NHS. It seems like half of the country wants to have unchecked immigration and extensive welfare programs, but the consequences of that kind of policy will quickly become bankrupting. I would imagine that vocal minority would be fine with a single-payer system. Again, look at what happens to pricing when the government is your sole customer. And given the influence they can wield, it would be a bonanza for them.