4 ms·
Directed Graph of Which Human Language Is Incomprehensible to Most People
- endtime 17y agoCool. I'd love to see the nodes arranged geographically.
- armandososa 17y ago"The suggestion that the Spanish-American word gringo comes from the expression “hablar en griego”" False. We say "está en chino" (it's in chinese).
- faragon 17y agoAlso is the case for the spanish spoken in Spain, I'm used to ear: "está en chino" or "suena a chino" ("sounds like chinese").
- telemachos 17y agoThe author of the post draws a lot of his examples from a page at Omniglot. The table there (link below) shows variation for a number of languages. Spanish in particular offers both Greek and Chinese as "incomprehensible" languages. Portuguese also offers Greek and Chinese. Slovenian has "Spanish village" and Chinese. (That odd phrase - "Spanish village" - shows up in Macedonian, too.) Greek has Chinese and Arabic. In the comments to the Language Log post, a few German speakers describe variation in German as regional, and that may be true for the differences above. Anyhow, the Omniglot table is here: http://www.omniglot.com/language/idioms/incomprehensible.php http://www.omniglot.com/language/idioms/incomprehensible.php
- mahmud 17y agoHindi is not 'incomprehensible' to Arabic speakers. I reckon more of them can get by in Hindi than Farsi or Turkish. Urdu and Hindi are everywhere. Arabs use Chinese ("Sini") as the archetype incomprehensible language.
- paraschopra 17y agoAnd according to the graph, is there no language that is incomprehensible to Hindi speakers?
- coderdude 17y agoI wonder if there is a connection between English as the 'international language of business' and how the graph shows that no one finds it incomprehensible.
- davidw 17y agoI doubt it. These are all pretty much figures of speech that have been in most of these languages for a while. It would be interesting to attempt to find historical references for them and see when they came into common use.
- sliverstorm 17y agoIt definitely singles out older languages.
- sid0 17y agoI'm sort of disappointed the graph isn't connected.
- curiousgeorge 17y agoI love the way Chinese is the only language that considers itself to be difficult.
- albertsun 17y agoRemember, this is not a directed graph reflecting language fluency or anything like that. It only shows what the most common figure of speech in that language is. So English -> "It's Greek to me." Chinese -> 《跟天书一样》 Others here. http://www.omniglot.com/language/idioms/incomprehensible.php http://www.omniglot.com/language/idioms/incomprehensible.php
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]