2 ms·
The ribbon is about a lot more than just looks - it finally groups like operations into clusters that account for Fitt's Law - as does the big "Office" button o
by potatolicious 17y ago
The ribbon is about a lot more than just looks - it finally groups like operations into clusters that account for Fitt's Law - as does the big "Office" button on the top left corner now. It's disingenuous to claim that Office's new UI is primarily a visual facelift - ditto for Aero (again, many Fitt's Law improvements among other tangible, quantifiable changes).
I think you're infantilizing the consumer too much - your users are a lot more than dumb bricks that react to "Ooooh Shiny!". When geeks (more specifically, geeks who have no appreciation for UI) rant about how people buy the shiny UI, they're not really grokking the fact that people like it not because it spins and moves, but because it actually better conforms to how they want their computers to work. Animation between switching windows? Geeks call it eye candy, I call it necessary preservation of context.
- psyklic 17y agoCustomers do react to "Oooh shiny!" -- it's a permanent part of our psychology. Ask your average consumer what was new in Vista? Aero. What's Aero? Neat visual effects. What was new in Office 2007? Ribbon. What's Ribbon? It's that new bar at the top of the screen. Consumers remember the visual changes in these products best. Like it or not, those superfluous window animations in Mac OS were exactly what screamed "creative" and "cool" to a lot of customers, over the then "business-like" Windows XP. Video games invest in graphics so they can have impressive screenshots. Office suites tweak their UI so that they can communicate "new and improved" visually. Of course there are other benefits than looks. But the looks, the screenshots are your product's first impression -- if it looks the same as the last version, people just might not buy.