4 ms·
The difference is, you sacrifice almost nothing (save a few dollars) to have the Smart TV gubbins inside. The TV still works great as a display -- in fact, my n
by rconti 10y ago
The difference is, you sacrifice almost nothing (save a few dollars) to have the Smart TV gubbins inside. The TV still works great as a display -- in fact, my new Smart TV has more inputs and other such non-Smart-TV features than my old Dumb TV did.
Also, I call BS on being obsolete in 12 months. My mom wanted to buy a 20" iMac back in ~2009, and I was hesitant to go along with it, as I felt the same way as you did. Then I realized computers last longer and longer these days, and are approaching display level lifespan.
She's still using that iMac today, and it works great. And guess what, I bought a 5k 27" iMac to replace my 10 year old Mac Pro (which has a high-end-for-its-time 24" Dell 2407WFP connected to it).
The reality is, by the time the computer was too old to be particularly useful, a 1080p 24" display was old hat as well.
I don't disagree it makes the disposable culture a bit worse; I'm not particularly likely to try to repair the iMac after a couple of years (which is one reason I sprung for an extended warranty on it which I typically avoid like the plague), but it's not so bad as you suggest. And, of course, the machine can still be used as an external display (or output to another display if it's the display that fails instead of the computer).
Perhaps your strongest argument should be that Smart TVs may accelerate the decline of standalone streamers. If that comes to pass, TVs may come to look a bit more like the all-in-one computer world.
But for now I'll enjoy my 4k streaming on my Smart TV apps, and replace those functions with standalone devices that do it better, as they come on the market. They're not there yet, though, and I'm not about to throw out all of my other devices and replace them just because I bought a new TV.
- dfox 10y agoThere is one thing that is painfully missing on any smart TV I've seen: VGA input.
- rspeer 10y agoVGA has limited bandwidth, so it looks horrible at the scale of a modern TV screen. Show someone a VGA signal on a TV and they'll assume the TV sucks.
- douche 10y agoHuh? Maybe if you're trying to push 4K through it, but it's plenty good enough up to 1920x1080.
- theandrewbailey 10y agoI was using VGA to drive a 1920x1200 monitor at work for months. The image was more than sufficient to write code on. Most people looking at VGA on a TV at TV viewing distances wouldn't be able to tell the difference. You get more artifacting from the video codec than VGA output.
- mintplant 10y agoVGA-HDMI adapters are cheap and readily available.
- stuaxo 10y agoThis must be a regional thing, in the UK (possibly the rest of Europe) they do. I normally connect my laptop like this.
- rconti 10y agoI haven't owned a laptop with a VGA output since about 2008, so it's not relevant to me. I don't think it's a smart TV drawback, it's just a "newfangled stuff doesn't support old stuff" problem.
- qq66 10y agoYou don't just sacrifice a few dollars to have a Smart TV inside... It has security vulnerabilities, features stop working, etc... Especially with the "stick" format of Roku etc., I just see no point. I understand why the manufacturers want you in their heinous "LG ecosystem" with an "LG Live Account" etc. but I'd pay extra to have the smart features on a removable stick.
- kgwgk 10y agoIf the features stop working, the only thing you have lost compared to the TV which never had those features is... a few dollars. If you are worried about security issues don't connect to a network, you will be just sacrificing a few dollars.
- theandrewbailey 10y agoThat's the point: leave the features out and sell a cheaper TV.
- 4ad 10y ago> The TV still works great as a display No it doesn't. Every Smart TV I've seen has horrible ergonomics. It takes a while to boot, the remote has lag, it takes a long time to change from one input to another, it takes a huge amount of time to start the app that is responsible for changing inputs. They just suck. Yeah, they have inputs and everything, but android-based UI is hands down the worst UI I have ever had to use, and this included typing magic commands into the mainframe of airline global distribution systems. Oh yeah. You want perfectly synchronised audio/video streams, just like you had before? Not possible with Smart TVs.
- rconti 10y agoI never thought of my TV in terms of ergonomics. Yes, my tv takes perhaps 20-30 seconds to boot if you have it unplugged, but from its normal standby/off mode, it's as fast as any other tv -- perhaps 2 seconds? I don't have input switching problems, but then again, I typically use my receiver as the switch; the TV stays on HDMI4 (ARC). I've never noticed non-perfectly-synchronized audio/video so I can't really comment on that. I've got a Sony x940d, for what it's worth.