8 ms·
Welcome to a solved problem: trains. You know what, in some parts of the world, they're automated! Driver-less trains, arriving every 3 minutes, running 24 hou
by djsumdog 10y ago
Welcome to a solved problem: trains.
You know what, in some parts of the world, they're automated! Driver-less trains, arriving every 3 minutes, running 24 hours with no union strikes or bad software that accidentally runs them into a kid or semi truck (if they walk out onto the rails it's really their own damn fault).
Individual personal transport is really a waste. I mean there's nothing wrong with having a car, but you shouldn't need it. It should be there in case you need to haul something or go way off the beaten path. All these single capacity cars taking people to and from work every morning is insane.
- ghaff 10y agoWe're talking spread-out, low-density areas. Trains are great for moving people point to point where there's a certain level of density. But, guess what, even in Europe and Japan, there are a significant number of places that you can't get to by train.
- ng12 10y agoThat's the problem isn't it? The US's obsession with personal automobiles allows it to build these sprawling suburban ghost towns, only to realize in post-boom-times how terrible of a system it is.
- sokoloff 10y agoIs it the US obsession with cars that causes sprawling suburbs or the fact that we have such a radically lower population density inherent in the country? Think about countries with good to great train systems. I think Germany, Switzerland, Japan, Netherlands. Population density of 226, 196, 336, 498 people per km^2. United States is 33 people / km^2. Take all of Alaska's area away and make them all move to CONUS and it's still only 40 people / km^2. With a lower natural population density, it would be surprising if people didn't spread out, and with that sprawl comes the car over the train. It's hard to make the train work when the population is 5 to 12 times more spread out.
- ajmurmann 10y agoWhat you are saying is true and not true. Most people in the US live in a few urban areas. Interconnecting these urban areas with trains is super hard. However, inside these urban areas the situation doesn't have to be that different from other countries urban areas. However, I believe that US suburbs are uniquely spread out and unwalkable largely due to boneheaded zoning.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- xorcist 10y agoYou chose rather dense European countries for your example. Sweden has 21 people/km^2, Norway and Finland has 16 people/km^2. Both have working public transport. Which should show that the average population density of the country as a whole is mostly irrelevant.
- sokoloff 10y agoYes, I chose rather dense countries, but I also chose countries where I've found that having a car is more of a liability than an asset. That's a rough metric I use for "is the rail and public transport system good?" Did I choose dense countries and declare that they had good public transport, or did I choose countries with good public transport and discover they were dense? I've never been to Scandinavia, so I have no experience to fairly judge.
- flukus 10y agoAverage population density is irrelevant when the population isn't evenly distributed.
- ghaff 10y agoI live in an exurban town on a number of acres. Nothing about the area between here and a major metropolis resembles a "ghost town." Nor is it "terrible" nor has it been so through a number of economic cycles. And I've traveled to many different places in the world and my observation has been that, even in areas that have generally good train service, it by no means serves as anywhere to anywhere transportation.
- ajmurmann 10y agoIt's also the terrible zoning. Residential areas must at all cost be devoid of shops, cafes, restaurants etc!
- mjevans 10y agoThe suburban ones you're thinking of are actually too low density for that solution to work. A more Japanese approach (as mentioned several other times on HN within the last year and probably more before that), is roughly to zone by the 'nuisance impact' and also to plan local commutes along slopes of density (nuisance). So you can have a mixed commercial / high density residential district around the transit hub, and a casually walkable (for fit adults/kids) commute from there to lower density housing.
- djsumdog 10y agoJena Germany. <100k people. Four tram lines and 3 intercity rail stations. American could have the same, even for rural areas. It's just been a matter of money, priority and the auto makers lobbying a lot to shift both of those two things.
- gok 10y agoWhich part of the world is that? Driverless, 24/7 train networks are relatively rare. The only one I can think of (outside of the ones that run inside airports) is the Copenhagen Metro. And being automated/driverless certainly doesn't prevent union strikes from shutting the system down.
- djsumdog 10y agoSingapore. Kula Lumpa, Malaysia. London DLR. Parts of the London underground. Almost all American airports (Atlanta comes to mind) EDIT: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_automated_urban_metro_subway_systems https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_automated_urban_metro_...
- nisse72 10y agoVancouver, since 1986
- gok 10y agoNot 24/7 (Although it is an excellent train system)
- jgamman 10y agoi read stories about Uber/Lyft and i'm convinced that the authors just don't even consider bicycles - is this a US-Valley blind spot or something? i mean seriously - the problem of getting 3-4 km without a car? quelle horror... i'll grant you until recently it was annoying and having a train do the heavy lifting was a great combo but e-bikes are changing the way this stuff works. even in Auckland we're seeing them and the hills in this city are everywhere (we built it on a volcano field...) but e-bikes and some bikepath friendly investments are changing the 5-km radius of the isthmus. Uber in NZ will probably do just as well as Starbucks - I think there's one at the airport...
- danso 10y agoEr...have you tried biking around America's cities? Some are decent. New York and Chicago have a couple of dedicated paths along their respective bodies of water, and biking can be faster than taking the train. And both cities are big enough to support well-paved/painted cross-town roads. But going off of those designated streets can be dicey. In New York I feel relatively safe because traffic is such a crawl anyway that, aside from getting doored by a inattentive taxi passenger, you probably won't get run over at a high speed. And then you have many of the other cities in America. Dallas in particularly strikes me as a city especially un-optimized for bicyclists despite the huge amount of land there. I mean, there's plenty of lanes for cars, and just about nothing for bikes. An initiative to change America's non-car culture would probably take as long as it would take to make self-driving electric vehicles mainstream. And automated vehicles are probably more viable when thinking of the future, as America's population continues to age and fewer people can physically bike (or even walk).
- jgamman 10y agoyeah agree - and i'd have said the same about Auckland until about 2-3 years ago. i guess the wider point is that it is weird that so much time/effort/treasure is being devoted to eliminating an entry level job and not investing in some pretty basic infrastructure. Auckland has just about had a heart attack trying to push through some planning rules that allow 3 story apartments and bike paths/PT in the city... i think that's the blind spot. check out the US civil engineers report card on infrastructure - seems to be a thing around the world. maybe if fewer deciders flew on private jets we'd have bridges that stay up? still disagree on future viability - sounds like tech for tech sake.
- curioussavage 10y agoYeah trains are so superior. I mean all it takes is for one guy to decide to off himself or one failure and an entire city is unable to get anywhere for hours!!! Personally I can't wait to move back home where I could own a car, and live in a nice house in the beautiful suburbs where everything I need is 5-15 minutes away and I can go shopping at any time of day without worrying about being robbed. I live a block from the train station. The store is less than a block from the next station. It still takes FOREVER to go there and back. I don't know how people who live farther out do it. Not to mention you have no privacy. Cars let you have a lot more privacy than trains. Most people on hacker news care about online privacy,why they are so biased towards something in meatspace that preserves a little of the privacy we have left is beyond me. I've read all the arguments and I just don't think it's superior in terms of privacy period, for convenience; public transit is only better in the most dense cities, even then it's convenience varies greatly by person depending on where you live and where you need to go.
- flukus 10y agoWhat are you doing that you need privacy while driving?
- curioussavage 10y agoThere are a lot of great rebuttals out there to this attitude. I think Snowden voiced a great one about privacy - "Arguing that you don't care about the right to privacy because you have nothing to hide is no different than saying you don't care about free speech because you have nothing to say,". I hope you can figure out how that can be applied to this too... But to point out the obvious it's not just about what you do/say while you are driving but also where you go, when, and with who to name a few things.
- flukus 10y agoBut you're in public, why would you have any expectation of privacy?
- curioussavage 10y agoTrains are like a monolithic architecture while cars/roads are like micro services. A failure in part of the system can't affect other parts as easily. There are many good reasons why cars have won over all in the US. Whether people should need a car is not(and shouldn't be) determined by your arbitrary moral judgment. It depends on their actual circumstances.
- return0 10y ago> There are many good reasons why cars have won over all in the US. Given how trains have won over in Europe, its got more to do with city planning.
- curioussavage 10y agoThat's oversimplification, Europe is a very different place with different history/geography/cultures. For one thing, everyone in Europe is squished together (relatively speaking) and has been for centuries. Just because we could plan all our cities around trains doesn't mean Americans will want to. I think a lot of people here are overconfident about how much better it would be if we just build trains all over. Not all of us want to wait around everyday to be packed into a smelly, dirty disease distribution system that can shut down your commute for hours or take away your ability to get anywhere for days when they have maintenance issues.
- ahh 10y agoThey're trying to build a train system in my town (Seattle.) I live in the middle of the city in a major neighborhood. If there are no cost overruns (hah) or schedule slips (anyone want to bet on that?) then I will have access to one train stop, about a mile away by foot down an extremely steep hill. That station will, admittedly, connect me to interesting places I can go in the city, after two transfers and about an hour's travel time. I will have this station, at the cost of $54 billion, in _nineteen years_. If everything goes exactly as planned. Uber can get me anywhere I want to go, for $8 or so, in fifteen minutes, today. I don't like cars much either, and because of the calculus above, traffic is only getting worse. But you want to know why we don't have trains? Because America can no longer build infrastructure. In any sane country we could do this in five years at a tenth of the price, but for whatever reason, we can't. This is the only reason Uber exists at the scale it does: because it's a workaround for the fact we can no longer build anything requiring fixed infrastructure. (By the way, talk about an industry ripe for disruption. What I wouldn't give for a good construction startup.)