6 ms·
(emphasis mine) > One of the things I like best about my industry is that compensation is standardized for people in the first 8-10 years of their careers. At
by koolba 10y ago
(emphasis mine)
> One of the things I like best about my industry is that compensation is standardized for people in the first 8-10 years of their careers. At large firms (and government), people get paid based on publicly known scales on a strictly seniority basis. This is bad for people who are good at self promotion (whether or not their is a real basis in that self-promotion), but great for women generally and men who do more than they talk about doing.
It sounds like it's great for people who want to do the bare minimum too. If excellence pays the same as mediocrity, why strive for more?
- rayiner 10y agoBecause mediocrity gets managed out.
- koolba 10y ago> Because mediocrity gets managed out. So for the first 8-10 years, keeping your job is your bonus? Honestly that doesn't sound very pleasant.
- harryh 10y agoYes, Big Law (and quite a few other fields) work on an up or out system. Not everyone is expected to keep their job.
- fckyrdumb 10y agoNot in government.
- exstudent2 10y agoWhy would high performers stay in this environment when they could leave to work somewhere where pay is tied to performance and not seniority? It seems the only people who would be happy with this setup _are_ the mediocre.
- vkou 10y ago... Or people who are not good at self-promoting. Or people who are punished for self-promoting (Women). I'll know meritocracy when I see it, and most of corporate America is anything but.
- exstudent2 10y agoAnecdote to anecdote but "... Or people who are not good at self-promoting. Or people who are punished for self-promoting (Women)." is pure conjecture that doesn't align with the results I've seen in industry. What's to stop a high performer from becoming an entrepreneur (thus interacting with the market more directly)? The Google engineers making >300k /annual are definitely an order of magnitude more skilled than the Java dev making 75k in my experience. Despite the rhetoric, high performance is linked to pay if the employee does basic due diligence in job shopping. EDIT reply to child comment since I can't post to this thread anymore: Do you make that much money because you were highly assertive or are you highly skilled? I'm sure it's the latter, Google wouldn't be paying you that much if you weren't worth it. > And there's a million reasons for why a high-performing IC should not become an entrepreneur. Indeed, but it is an option, as is raising your skill level to the point where you can work at Google. > Speaking of Google... It's found that equally capable women are routinely under-rewarded, as they rarely nominate themselves for promotion. [1] Not receiving a promotion they didn't ask for does not sound like a problem in any way. We're talking about adults not children, if you want something, ask for it.
- vkou 10y agohttp://www.glassceiling.com/being-assertive-can-be-costly-for-women/ http://www.glassceiling.com/being-assertive-can-be-costly-fo... Fortunately for the average woman, you don't see any problems - I suppose that means that they don't exist. And there's a million reasons for why a high-performing IC should not become an entrepreneur. -A just-shy-of 300K Google engineer. Speaking of Google... It's found that equally capable women are routinely under-rewarded, as they rarely nominate themselves for promotion. [1] This is a problem - why women don't ask for promotion is not relevant to this conversation. What is relevant is that I just gave an example of a group that benefits from homogenized compensation... And said group is not composed of talent-less layabouts. [1] http://www.wnyc.org/story/google-test-case-gender-bias/ http://www.wnyc.org/story/google-test-case-gender-bias/
- Spooky23 10y agoPerks. Better offices, better gear, professional recognition, more respect, more autonomy. I hire contractors and consultants all of the time who are very well compensated. As part of that, we recorded 350 engagements and had at least 3 peers rate the people we hire. In my experience, there's no correlation between pay and rating, with limited exceptions.
- twic 10y agoBecause people aren't motivated by money! Why is this mistaken idea still in circulation? Surely we've all seen Drive by now: https://www.thersa.org/discover/videos/rsa-animate/2010/04/rsa-animate---drive https://www.thersa.org/discover/videos/rsa-animate/2010/04/r...
- random_rr 10y agoHuman society revolves around getting, trading, saving, and spending money. I think that money is a primary motivator for many, many, many people. Including myself - why else would I show up to a job every day? I show up because I need money. I perform at a high level in order to ask for more money. I use that money to do things that I want. Money is a great motivator - I care about trivial things because I am paid to care about them. I would never care if I weren't being paid.
- dagw 10y agoObviously money is my primary motivator for going to work, but offering me more of it won't necessarily make me work more or in itself convince me to go work for someone else. Two salary negotiations ago I turned down money in exchange for more vacation days for example. I've turned down jobs offering more money because they placed greater demands on my time. I've also taken jobs offering less money since they offered me more intellectual freedom and autonomy as to how I go about my work.
- jotato 10y agoI only go to work for a pay check! I wouldn't be doing what I do if I was financially independent. I stopped working more than 40 hours after 3 months of 65-75 hour weeks and realizing I wasn't getting squat for it. Other people were getting paid the same I was and they weren't doing the extra hours. So I stopped. Why put in the extra effort if it isn't paying out? Don't get me wrong. I am not doing sub-par work. I just don't do extra unless I am paid for it. Saying people aren't motivated by money is fallacy, IMO
- tcoppi 10y agoI think this is true only to the point of perceiving that you are compensated correctly relative to the market, i.e. that you can't switch jobs tomorrow and get a 10% or greater pay raise. After that definitely the motivations put forth by Drive apply. At least, this has been my experience with myself and past/present coworkers. There are also some cases where one will take a pay cut for more meaningful work, but that requires a position of relative privilege to contemplate.